Re: Custom core dump folder ?

2013-04-05 Thread Florenz Kley
On Apr 4, 2013, at 11:18 PM, patrick keshishian wrote:
 On single directory for everyone's core files? Personally I don't like
 that idea. Especially if I'm working on a project and want to find the
 core files in my current directory

as a developer, you have a point :-) but you could just not change the default

as admin, it's sure convenient to configure away from the default and have them 
in one place with one system-level config setting.. today, a cron job looks for 
cores once a day and tells me when he found some.

 On Thu, Apr 04, 2013 at 15:37, Jack N. Asher wrote:
 Is there a way to specify a custom core dump folder in OpenBSD ?
 
 This is the FreeBSD way (AFAIK, OpenBSD does not support it):
 sysctl.conf
 kern.corefile=/custom-folder/%U.%N.core

cool, I didn't know that feature. thanks Jack!

fl



Custom core dump folder ?

2013-04-04 Thread Jack N. Asher
Is there a way to specify a custom core dump folder in OpenBSD ? I do
not see any references to it in sysctl -a
If not, is there a security reason for it not being supported or can
it be added to a wishlist ?

This is the FreeBSD way (AFAIK, OpenBSD does not support it):

sysctl.conf

kern.corefile=/custom-folder/%U.%N.core



Re: Custom core dump folder ?

2013-04-04 Thread Ted Unangst
On Thu, Apr 04, 2013 at 15:37, Jack N. Asher wrote:
 Is there a way to specify a custom core dump folder in OpenBSD ? I do
 not see any references to it in sysctl -a
 If not, is there a security reason for it not being supported or can
 it be added to a wishlist ?

It is not supported, probably because nobody found any use for it.

You can add anything you like to your wishlist, just keep your expectations
in check. :)



Re: Custom core dump folder ?

2013-04-04 Thread Jack N. Asher
If there is a list of daemons, etc. running 24/7, it would be useful
if they all dumped in 1 folder rather than using a script to search
for them. This way we will actually notice when a core dumps; the core
is not buried deep inside a current-working-directory waiting for it
to be discovered by some script. Even Python dumps core sometimes.

Anyway, my $0.02.

On Thu, Apr 4, 2013 at 5:02 PM, Ted Unangst t...@tedunangst.com wrote:
 On Thu, Apr 04, 2013 at 15:37, Jack N. Asher wrote:
 Is there a way to specify a custom core dump folder in OpenBSD ? I do
 not see any references to it in sysctl -a
 If not, is there a security reason for it not being supported or can
 it be added to a wishlist ?

 It is not supported, probably because nobody found any use for it.

 You can add anything you like to your wishlist, just keep your expectations
 in check. :)



Re: Custom core dump folder ?

2013-04-04 Thread patrick keshishian
On Thu, Apr 4, 2013 at 12:42 PM, Jack N. Asher jnash...@gmail.com wrote:
 If there is a list of daemons, etc. running 24/7, it would be useful
 if they all dumped in 1 folder rather than using a script to search
 for them. This way we will actually notice when a core dumps; the core
 is not buried deep inside a current-working-directory waiting for it
 to be discovered by some script. Even Python dumps core sometimes.

On single directory for everyone's core files? Personally I don't like
that idea. Especially if I'm working on a project and want to find the
core files in my current directory rather than some other place where
there may be a ton of other core files festering away...

--patrick




 Anyway, my $0.02.

 On Thu, Apr 4, 2013 at 5:02 PM, Ted Unangst t...@tedunangst.com wrote:
 On Thu, Apr 04, 2013 at 15:37, Jack N. Asher wrote:
 Is there a way to specify a custom core dump folder in OpenBSD ? I do
 not see any references to it in sysctl -a
 If not, is there a security reason for it not being supported or can
 it be added to a wishlist ?

 It is not supported, probably because nobody found any use for it.

 You can add anything you like to your wishlist, just keep your expectations
 in check. :)