Install defaults

2006-03-20 Thread Bruno Carnazzi
  Hi all,

Why not use soft update as a default for created file system on
install ? It seems to be a good practice, no ?

Best regards,

Bruno.



Re: Install defaults

2006-03-20 Thread Nick Holland

Bruno Carnazzi wrote:

  Hi all,

Why not use soft update as a default for created file system on
install ? It seems to be a good practice, no ?


Well...assuming you:
  * Have some extra RAM to spare.
  * Don't mind added complexity
  * aren't running on a Sun4c

sure, soft updates are a fine idea for most people to use on most of 
their systems.


However, no one's system is broke because of not having softdeps on.  No 
one's system will crash because of no softdeps.


Softdeps is an added complexity.  You don't add complexity and get a 
more solid result.


IF you always want softdeps on the systems you work with, it is two 
lines of shell script in a siteXX.tgz file (or less if you know what you 
are doing, or more if you know of some edge cases I didn't think of). 
However, I don't think it will be defaulting to on anytime in the next 
release (and probably not the one after that). :)


Nick.



Re: Install defaults

2006-03-20 Thread Bruno Carnazzi
Thank you, you convinced me that it's not a good idea :)

2006/3/21, Nick Holland [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
 Bruno Carnazzi wrote:
Hi all,
 
  Why not use soft update as a default for created file system on
  install ? It seems to be a good practice, no ?

 Well...assuming you:
* Have some extra RAM to spare.
* Don't mind added complexity
* aren't running on a Sun4c

 sure, soft updates are a fine idea for most people to use on most of
 their systems.

 However, no one's system is broke because of not having softdeps on.  No
 one's system will crash because of no softdeps.

 Softdeps is an added complexity.  You don't add complexity and get a
 more solid result.

 IF you always want softdeps on the systems you work with, it is two
 lines of shell script in a siteXX.tgz file (or less if you know what you
 are doing, or more if you know of some edge cases I didn't think of).
 However, I don't think it will be defaulting to on anytime in the next
 release (and probably not the one after that). :)

 Nick.