Re: Mozilla Development Roadmap updated - Mozilla is not ready fo 1.0
Brendan Eich wrote: > http://www.mozilla.org/roadmap.html > > Comments welcome. Questions too, so I might have something to put > Hello, IMHO Mozilla is not ready for a 1.0 version. April is too early for 1.0. There are still some major bugs that still make problems. For example, text filling window menus. Mozilla has problems with those windows. (for example in those bulleting forum boards where you can post messages) Text Scrolling doesn't work correctly in those windows. There is also a cut&paste problem. Text is not pasted at the correct place, it is allways pasted some lines below or above the row (where your mouse points to). Then it looks like, that Mozilla has some speed an scrolling problems on a website that uses Flash and when Flash is activated in Mozilla. The last point is, that it still has some problems with showing websites correctly. For example Mozilla shows this website not correctly: http://www.interplay.com/giants/index2.html (This bug is known for about a year, don't know the bug number at the moment) Best Regards, Oliver C. It still needs a lot more
Re: Mozilla Development Roadmap updated - Mozilla is not ready fo 1.0
Oliver C. wrote: > The last point is, that it still has some problems with showing websites > correctly. > For example Mozilla shows this website not correctly: > http://www.interplay.com/giants/index2.html > (This bug is known for about a year, don't know the bug number at the > moment) Not a Mozilla bug - the site uses invalid HTML code. (Tech Evangelism bug: 79372) The two worst bugs currently in Mozilla, IMHO, is 55583 (view-source should show original page source) and 46845 (Form elements don't reset upon reloading page). They both cause very annoying dataloss, and they are both futured... :-( After them, standards compliance bugs (layout/DOM) should be the number one priority, IMHO. /Jonas
Re: Mozilla Development Roadmap updated - Mozilla is not ready fo 1.0
Oliver C. wrote: > Brendan Eich wrote: > >> http://www.mozilla.org/roadmap.html >> >> Comments welcome. Questions too, so I might have something to put >> > > > Hello, > > IMHO Mozilla is not ready for a 1.0 version. > April is too early for 1.0. > That didn't stop them with Netscape 6.0, it ain't gonna stop them with Netscape I mean Mozilla 1.0. Let the fiasco begin!
Re: Mozilla Development Roadmap updated - Mozilla is not ready fo 1.0
Jonas Jørgensen wrote: > > The two worst bugs currently in Mozilla, IMHO, is 55583 (view-source > should show original page source) and 46845 (Form elements don't reset > upon reloading page). They both cause very annoying dataloss, and they > are both futured... :-( > > After them, standards compliance bugs (layout/DOM) should be the number > one priority, IMHO. > I believe in order to have a good Mozilla 1.0 release performance work should be of very low priority and more focus should be placed on bugs that hinder proper usage of Mozilla. 'proper usage' optimally being: 1) no dataloss bugs 2) no crashes 3) UI polish 4) no unexpected behavior regarding interraction with mozilla This, with documentation, frozen API's and the promised standards compliance is what the ideal, possible 1.0 release. All performance bugs should be re-evaluated and targetted to Mozilla 1.0+ to give developers more time to fix bugs that can not be permitted in 1.0
Re: Mozilla Development Roadmap updated - Mozilla is not ready fo 1.0
Amen Jonas. Those are my two worst bugs also. jon Jonas Jørgensen wrote: > Oliver C. wrote: > >> The last point is, that it still has some problems with showing >> websites correctly. >> For example Mozilla shows this website not correctly: >> http://www.interplay.com/giants/index2.html >> (This bug is known for about a year, don't know the bug number at the >> moment) > > > Not a Mozilla bug - the site uses invalid HTML code. (Tech Evangelism > bug: 79372) > > The two worst bugs currently in Mozilla, IMHO, is 55583 (view-source > should show original page source) and 46845 (Form elements don't reset > upon reloading page). They both cause very annoying dataloss, and they > are both futured... :-( > > After them, standards compliance bugs (layout/DOM) should be the number > one priority, IMHO. > > /Jonas >
Re: Mozilla Development Roadmap updated - Mozilla is not ready fo 1.0
jon <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote in [EMAIL PROTECTED]:">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]: >> The two worst bugs currently in Mozilla, IMHO, is 55583 (view-source >> should show original page source) and 46845 (Form elements don't reset >> upon reloading page). They both cause very annoying dataloss, and they >> are both futured... :-( > I agree. I would add bug 59078 (bad desktop integration with w2k) and 119597 (for gif image tracking bug - I still have some gifs displayed badly under Mozilla !!) -- Le Vintz. http://membres.tripod.fr/vnicolas/
