Re: Wierd mbox/IMAP behavior
On 09/06/01 04:06 PM, Brendan Cully sat at the `puter and typed: > I think what you want is the $move option, which you should set to > 'no'. Also keep an eye out for any mbox-hooks you might have lying > around. I think you're right. Turns out it was turned on. > the '>' switches to $mbox, which you aren't interested in. To get back > to the spoolfile, use '!'. Ok, will do. > I don't know exactly what's happening here. Frankly I'm like you and > have $move perpetually turned off (everything's already filtered to the > right place), so bugs seem to crop up here more often than usual. > > If you have $move off, $mbox shouldn't even be used. But, one thing I > can say is mutt's mailbox comparison is exceedingly stupid (basically > just a strcmp), so to it your $mbox and $spoolfile appear to be > different mailboxes even though they're not. This is probably what's > gotten mutt confused and acting weird. > > I'd written about half of a proper mailbox comparison function a couple > days ago (for a very similar problem), but scrapped it a couple of days > ago for a less reliable fix (I tried to canonify paths when they were > entered, so we could use the less expensive strcmp later). It may be > that was the wrong approach. > > But on the other hand, you might try current CVS and see if it works out > for you. Oh, one final note: using the imap URL format > (eg imap:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/INBOX) tends to work a bit > better, since that's what mutt uses internally. > As I suspected, this problem was mine. I turned off the move directive and mbox, and switched the folder and spoolfile to the format you suggested. So far it seems to have worked. One bit of info I forgot to include that may have made it more obvious, is that when I did change to '>', I wound up in a local file (~/mbox). Apparently, since I had move on, but didn't define mbox, it defaulted to ~/mbox. I was probably flirting with disaster having it set back to my spoolfile. > In short, I don't really know what happened :) Oh, I don't know. You seem to have hit the nail on the head! :) Thanks! Lou -- Louis LeBlanc [EMAIL PROTECTED] Fully Funded Hobbyist, KeySlapper Extrordinaire :) http://acadia.ne.mediaone.net ԿԬ Of course you can't flap your arms and fly to the moon. After a while you'd run out of air to push against.
Re: Wierd mbox/IMAP behavior
On Thursday, 06 September 2001 at 15:33, Louis LeBlanc wrote:
> Wierd behavior here. I use IMAP, and don't move mail I've read to
> another mailbox. I usually have it delivered right where I want it.
>
> Anyway, I found that when I set mbox in my muttrc to point to my INBOX
> on the IMAP server, it would often not save the status or flags for
> more recent messages - a read message would be marked new next time I
> got on, a message I replied to didn't have the r flag, etc.
>
> Anyway, I found that I could fix this by unsetting the mbox directive
> in my muttrc.
I think what you want is the $move option, which you should set to
'no'. Also keep an eye out for any mbox-hooks you might have lying
around.
> Now something wierd happened. I just did a c> to change to the main
> folder (folder and spoolfile directives both point to the INBOX).
the '>' switches to $mbox, which you aren't interested in. To get back
to the spoolfile, use '!'.
> Anyway, when it changes, I see multiple copies of every message in my
> INBOX, plus copies of every other message I've read in other
> mailboxes.
I don't know exactly what's happening here. Frankly I'm like you and
have $move perpetually turned off (everything's already filtered to the
right place), so bugs seem to crop up here more often than usual.
> Here is what I've got for relevant config directives (I think):
> set folder="{[EMAIL PROTECTED]}INBOX"
> set spoolfile="{[EMAIL PROTECTED]}INBOX"
> set mbox="{acadia.ne.mediaone.net}INBOX"
>
> As near as I could tell, this was the way to do it for IMAP, but it
> looks like I'm doing something wrong.
If you have $move off, $mbox shouldn't even be used. But, one thing I
can say is mutt's mailbox comparison is exceedingly stupid (basically
just a strcmp), so to it your $mbox and $spoolfile appear to be
different mailboxes even though they're not. This is probably what's
gotten mutt confused and acting weird.
I'd written about half of a proper mailbox comparison function a couple
days ago (for a very similar problem), but scrapped it a couple of days
ago for a less reliable fix (I tried to canonify paths when they were
entered, so we could use the less expensive strcmp later). It may be
that was the wrong approach.
But on the other hand, you might try current CVS and see if it works out
for you. Oh, one final note: using the imap URL format
(eg imap:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/INBOX) tends to work a bit
better, since that's what mutt uses internally.
In short, I don't really know what happened :)
-Brendan
Wierd mbox/IMAP behavior
Wierd behavior here. I use IMAP, and don't move mail I've read to
another mailbox. I usually have it delivered right where I want it.
Anyway, I found that when I set mbox in my muttrc to point to my INBOX
on the IMAP server, it would often not save the status or flags for
more recent messages - a read message would be marked new next time I
got on, a message I replied to didn't have the r flag, etc.
Anyway, I found that I could fix this by unsetting the mbox directive
in my muttrc.
Now something wierd happened. I just did a c> to change to the main
folder (folder and spoolfile directives both point to the INBOX).
Anyway, when it changes, I see multiple copies of every message in my
INBOX, plus copies of every other message I've read in other
mailboxes.
Here is what I've got for relevant config directives (I think):
set folder="{[EMAIL PROTECTED]}INBOX"
set spoolfile="{[EMAIL PROTECTED]}INBOX"
set mbox="{acadia.ne.mediaone.net}INBOX"
As near as I could tell, this was the way to do it for IMAP, but it
looks like I'm doing something wrong.
Can someone toss me a clue?
Thanks
Lou
--
Louis LeBlanc [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Fully Funded Hobbyist, KeySlapper Extrordinaire :)
http://acadia.ne.mediaone.net ԿԬ
"... an experienced, industrious, ambitious, and often quite often
picturesque liar."
-- Mark Twain
