Re: [newbie] Living in the real world - Win4Lin4 NO INTEREST TO GEEK FOLKS

2002-03-23 Thread john rigby

Hi Sridhar,
First, thanks for all the help I've seen you offer to newbie and geek alike
here, me included.
I am very happy to discuss the bits of the GNU World that I can, seeing as
my contributions technically are zilch!
My only skill is really in seeing solutions for sick corporations - and
sometimes people who are really ill.
MOST people like to contribute in some way, there are really very few - and
usually very young and frustrated - who don't.

As Joy C says,  Even Cybervandals (scriptkiddies) usually burn into people
by 30.
I am very happy to help anyone where I can and discussing practical
commerce-oriented matters is where I do have the experience to share is how
to do it.
Answers to your post :  **

- Original Message -
From: Sridhar Dhanapalan [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Friday, March 22, 2002 2:26 PM
Subject: Re: [newbie] Living in the real world - Win4Lin4 NO INTEREST TO
GEEK FOLKS


 Wordperfect was one of the first things I got going myself after I started
using
 GNU/Linux. I had next to no GNU/Linux experience at the time, but I found
the
 installation to be a breeze. It is a free (as in beer) download.
*** There was a post here about it a week ago - I couldn't even
understand the simple destructions needed. :-)
I did try and install a freebie copy way back when but it had no sense to it
for a non-geek. The expert at the Oz Computer magazine confessed he
couldn't either at the time.

 FrontPage98 is a joke. It is malware like this that is destroying the open
 Internet.
 I agree it could be lots better, but an awful lot of pros use it
for QANTAS ( No, not the Airline, Quick And Not Too Arty Sites). I know of
nothing faster and easier anywhere for non-geeks. So long as you don't use
FP Extensions and keep off  IIS Sites... there aren't a lot of
tricks to using it. :-)

  2.  If you are a serious business user, you NEED to be moving toward
voice
  recognition as you know.

 No, I don't know. Why would a business need voice recognition? I once
tried
 using Viavoice for a whole year -- my productivity decreased despite my
best
 efforts at speaking clearly (something which I've been told I'm good at)
and
 training the software. These packages often advertise 90%-95% accuracy.
This
 sounds great, until you realise that this means that every 10-20 words
will be
 incorrectly interpreted. John Dvorak recently wrote an interesting article
on
 the topic: http://zdnet.com.com/2100-1107-826862.html.

 A point at a time:
1. Because real men never did type and modern liberated females won't
anymore. :-)
Like Dvorak, you might have vocal range problem, much less an accent one. I
couldn't imagine a Good Ol' Boy ever getting to use it, or an excitable
Southern Indian. :-)
More to the point, at around 40 w.p.m. with 90% accuracy as a typist, VR
will break even under most conditions. Over that it drops rapidly. HOWEVER ,
in the publishing world, in technical material we used to cost on 19 w.p.m.
with girls whose rating was 65 w.p.m. in Pittmans test. In the real world
( that phrase again!) it was extremely rare to find an executive that could
properly dictate to a stenographer. They were status symbols for the most
part.
As a professional dictator (ha!) I must say I do know few people as
experienced, trained and natural as me at it, for over 30 years.  I am
approximately 120% more effective/productive using VR.  BUT as a typist I am
only quite fast - about twice the rate of finished work as an average
self-typing person creatively trying to do the two things at once.
But poor old Dvorak - a most unhappy puppy alla time - lives in the wannabee
world of pontificating pundits. He has no idea of the incredible science and
wonder that has got VR this far!  But, it isn't for everyone. Like playing
with command lines thrashing around with broken software and loving it! :-)

 What is your definition of incredibly poor presentation? Open source
 developers usually prefer to focus on code quality rather than polish. MS
bangs-and-whistles.
* I used to teach methods engineering ( IT speak Systems Analysis)
and the very first thing I would stress was:  forget the production, write
the manual. Do that first and you will always do well. Yes, it is boring -
and usually embarrassing, too. But I also meant overall. The physical
display of onscreen fonts was not acceptable to a serious user. Imagine
trying to write for 5 hours using it.

StarOffice and KDE (to use your examples) are very usable
 and stable. They _do_ have extensive help structures, so either you didn't
 install them or you just didn't look properly.
* No they just weren't there - it was a problem not resolved at the
time on this list - it was a known bug as I recall.


 Nothing is perfect. Go to a Windows list and I'll guarantee you that
you'll see
 many users with problems. On this list, most problems are quite minor, and
many
 messages are simple enquiries.
 Oh, I agree 100% 

Re: [newbie] Living in the real world - Win4Lin4 NO INTEREST TO GEEK FOLKS

2002-03-23 Thread Sridhar Dhanapalan

On Sat, 23 Mar 2002 21:59:42 +1000, john rigby [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 Hi Sridhar,
 First, thanks for all the help I've seen you offer to newbie and geek alike
 here, me included.
 I am very happy to discuss the bits of the GNU World that I can, seeing as
 my contributions technically are zilch!
 My only skill is really in seeing solutions for sick corporations - and
 sometimes people who are really ill.

But we're not dealing with a corporation here, we're dealing with a community.
Anything you do to Mandrake needs to be community-compatible.

 MOST people like to contribute in some way, there are really very few - and
 usually very young and frustrated - who don't.
 
 As Joy C says,  Even Cybervandals (scriptkiddies) usually burn into people
 by 30.
 I am very happy to help anyone where I can and discussing practical
 commerce-oriented matters is where I do have the experience to share is how
 to do it.
 Answers to your post :  **
 
 - Original Message -
 From: Sridhar Dhanapalan [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Sent: Friday, March 22, 2002 2:26 PM
 Subject: Re: [newbie] Living in the real world - Win4Lin4 NO INTEREST TO
 GEEK FOLKS
 
 
   2.  If you are a serious business user, you NEED to be moving toward
 voice
   recognition as you know.
 
  No, I don't know. Why would a business need voice recognition? I once
 tried
  using Viavoice for a whole year -- my productivity decreased despite my
 best
  efforts at speaking clearly (something which I've been told I'm good at)
 and
  training the software. These packages often advertise 90%-95% accuracy.
 This
  sounds great, until you realise that this means that every 10-20 words
 will be
  incorrectly interpreted. John Dvorak recently wrote an interesting article
 on
  the topic: http://zdnet.com.com/2100-1107-826862.html.
 
  A point at a time:
 1. Because real men never did type and modern liberated females won't
 anymore. :-)
 Like Dvorak, you might have vocal range problem, much less an accent one. I
 couldn't imagine a Good Ol' Boy ever getting to use it, or an excitable
 Southern Indian. :-)

I wouldn't know, because I'm not Southern Indian. Your assumption would be
like me thinking you're English simply because the name John came from
England. I was born in Australia, and years of private school education has
trained me to speak clearly and properly. I pronounce my words in the 'proper'
(i.e. British) fashion (although this wasn't something which was taught at
school), and I don't have a vocal range problem. I was using the British English
version of Viavoice, which better suits my voice than the American one.

 More to the point, at around 40 w.p.m. with 90% accuracy as a typist, VR
 will break even under most conditions. Over that it drops rapidly. HOWEVER ,
 in the publishing world, in technical material we used to cost on 19 w.p.m.
 with girls whose rating was 65 w.p.m. in Pittmans test. In the real world
 ( that phrase again!) it was extremely rare to find an executive that could
 properly dictate to a stenographer. They were status symbols for the most
 part.
 As a professional dictator (ha!) I must say I do know few people as
 experienced, trained and natural as me at it, for over 30 years.  I am
 approximately 120% more effective/productive using VR.  BUT as a typist I am
 only quite fast - about twice the rate of finished work as an average
 self-typing person creatively trying to do the two things at once.
 But poor old Dvorak - a most unhappy puppy alla time - lives in the wannabee
 world of pontificating pundits. He has no idea of the incredible science and
 wonder that has got VR this far!  But, it isn't for everyone. Like playing
 with command lines thrashing around with broken software and loving it! :-)

Most (probably over 95%) of businesses are still not using voice dictation, and
probably won't be doing so for the foreseeable future.

  What is your definition of incredibly poor presentation? Open source
  developers usually prefer to focus on code quality rather than polish. MS
 bangs-and-whistles.
 * I used to teach methods engineering ( IT speak Systems Analysis)
 and the very first thing I would stress was:  forget the production, write
 the manual. Do that first and you will always do well. Yes, it is boring -
 and usually embarrassing, too. But I also meant overall. The physical
 display of onscreen fonts was not acceptable to a serious user. Imagine
 trying to write for 5 hours using it.

Ah, Systems Analysis! I studied that last year. The course was 100%
buzzword-compliant. I don't think I learned anything truly useful from it at
all. University IT courses nowadays (at least in Australia) seem to be headed by
business and marketing people who know nothing about technology and how it
really works. It is these sorts of people who created the entire Dot Com
speculative bubble, which as you should know burst and hurt everyone.

Ever wonder why countries like Japan and South Korea 

Re: [newbie] Living in the real world - Win4Lin4 NO INTEREST TO GEEK FOLKS

2002-03-21 Thread James Thomas

I generally avoid these kinds of discussions but I feel compelled to 
respond.

I have two computers, both of which use Linux (one dual boots WinXp so I can 
play games and use my SanDisk card reader as it's not yet supported under 
Linux).

One runs 8.1 and the other 8.2rc1 (I see no reason to go full out to 8.2 
because the beta works awesomely imo).

Anyway, they both installed without a hitch and work perfectly. 8.2 even set 
up my printer and Zip Disk (Both USB) without any (except a couple of 
clicks) input. I only have minor problems, but no different than I would 
have under Windows - AND I didn't have to install ANY Drivers - it even 
recognized my Audigy sound card!

Can't get much easier than that - dealing with Driver disks is always a 
gotcha for non-geeks. Linux runs and installs effortlessly.

James

_
Send and receive Hotmail on your mobile device: http://mobile.msn.com




Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? 
Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com



Re: [newbie] Living in the real world - Win4Lin4 NO INTEREST TO GEEK FOLKS

2002-03-21 Thread Michael Scottaline

On Thu, 21 Mar 2002 17:16:48 +1000
john rigby [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

snippage
 Even Civilme (the resident expert on the Newbie list) THOUGHT he was
 putting me in my place by telling me that in some Govt Dept they had
 some typistes*actually* using Linux and olde Star Office. BUT then went
 on and said they were *using* WorpdPerfect!  (Sigh) A separate and quite
 expensive product(but very good) except that nobody I know outside of
 Civilme has ever got it to go on and work!
=
Nonsense!!  I'm no geek..., just an OK user.  Out of sheer curiosity, I
intalled Mandrake 5.3 on one of our lab computers back in April of 1999 (I
think?).  I had NEVER used linux before.  It installed OK (despite not
fully supporting our S3 video card).  I downloaded WordPerfect 8.0 for
linux and got it successfully installed LONG before I understood anything
about tar/configure, etc., etc. How?  I *read* and *FOLLOWED* the
directions.  First try, I got it to work and even borrowed a fellow
teacher's floppy (had to learn the mount comand real quick ;o) ) and
opened her WordPerfect for Windows files flawlessly.  AND printed them on
an old HPDeskJet 695c.  Lucky, I suppose, but I credit it to *reading*
carefully and following the directions.  I went on to loading Caldera 2.2
onto a Toshiba notebook w/o any problem and have since used a variety of
distros on a variety of computers: desktops/server/and several
notebooks. I believe you really need a
Geek to get you online.===
Nope!  Got home home computer and a notebook (that old Toshiba) hooked up
with an external modem on the very first try.  I just followed the
directions shrug.  At work, my ethernet card has ALWAYS been
automagically configured (I wouldn't have had a clue!!) and worked
immediately, even with that old Mandrake 5.3 version!!!snippage

Cheers,
Mike
-- 
You can't be a real country unless you have a beer and an airline - it
helps if you have some kind of a football team, or some nuclear weapons,
but at the very least you need a beer.
- Frank Zappa


_
Do You Yahoo!?
Get your free @yahoo.com address at http://mail.yahoo.com




Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? 
Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com



Re: [newbie] Living in the real world - Win4Lin4 NO INTEREST TO GEEK FOLKS

2002-03-21 Thread Todd Slater

Since nobody on this list is a non-geek in your mind, isn't your message a
colossal waste of your time?

ZZZzz . . . *plonk*

-- 
Todd Slater
What does education often do? It makes a straight cut ditch of a free
meandering brook. (Henry David Thoreau)

On Thu, 21 Mar 2002 17:16:48 +1000
john rigby [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 
 Hello Non-geeks,
 Good news  - but like the Curate's egg,  only - quite good in
 parts :-)

[and lots of other shit]



Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? 
Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com



Re: [newbie] Living in the real world - Win4Lin4 NO INTEREST TO GEEK FOLKS

2002-03-21 Thread Tom Brinkman

On Thursday 21 March 2002 02:50 am, James Thomas wrote:
 I generally avoid these kinds of discussions but I feel compelled
 to respond.

 Thanks for not including the original troll ;)   Best way to 
handle is to put 'em on ignore.

 One runs 8.1 and the other 8.2rc1 (I see no reason to go full out
 to 8.2 because the beta works awesomely imo).

 Well, I'm been usin 8.2 since the Christmas cooker thanks to a 
good friend on the list that sent me the CD's before Cheapbytes had 
'em.  Absolutely no problems even with that alpha version.  Some 
non-Mandrake software apps need to catch up a little, but NBD. Now 
I've got 8.2b2, but with 100's of MB's of cooker updates.  Still no 
problems, but I ordered 8.2 final CD's anyway. Nice to have 'em, and 
not need to archive lot'sa update rpm's.  'Sides, it's a good way to 
get current, clean up (ie, fresh install), and then start addin in 
newer cooker updates again ;)
-- 
Tom Brinkman   Corpus Christi, Texas



Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? 
Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com



Re: [newbie] Living in the real world - Win4Lin4 NO INTEREST TO GEEK FOLKS

2002-03-21 Thread Robin Turner

On Thursday 21 March 2002 16:45, Michael Scottaline wrote:
[snippet]
 Nope!  Got home home computer and a notebook (that old Toshiba) hooked up
 with an external modem on the very first try.  I just followed the
 directions shrug. 

I think Mike hit the nail on the head there.  OK, there are plenty of real 
problems with hardware configuration, but most problems occur because people 
don't follow the directions, or in pther words RTFM (don't let that put 
anyone off posting problems though - RTFM is one reply that isn't tolerated 
on this list!).  People woh don't follw the directions (i.e. click on the 
first thing they see) also have problems installing Windows, or anything, for 
that matter.

BTW, the reason Mdk didn't support the S3 card in 1999 was probably that 
virtually nothing did. Win95 doesn't support the S3Trio (though you can 
download drivers).  It's a truly disguting piece of hardware.

Robin




Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? 
Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com



Re: [newbie] Living in the real world - Win4Lin4 NO INTEREST TO GEEK FOLKS

2002-03-21 Thread Miark

On Thu, 21 Mar 2002 17:16:48 +1000, john rigby [EMAIL PROTECTED] spoke thusly:

 I almost fell off my highchair when I learned it is limited to 64k. 

Considering that's not true, I would have fallen out of my chair, too.

 Even Civilme (the resident expert on the Newbie list) THOUGHT he was putting
 me in my place by telling me that in some Govt Dept they had some typistes
 *actually* using Linux and olde Star Office. BUT then went on and said they
 were *using* WorpdPerfect!  (Sigh) A separate and quite expensive product
 (but very good) except that nobody I know outside of Civilme has ever got it
 to go on and work!

Are you implying that there are no places on the planet that use StarOffice? 
My company uses it. And all my friends with a computer do too--(non-geeks) 
despite having access to M$ Office. As for other companies, have you ever 
visited http://www.mandrakebizcase.com ?

 You will need to consider some of the Doze options for some time to come, in
 my *practical applications* opinion.

I would consider the following practical: office productivity tasks (i.e. word
processing, spreadsheets, etc.), e-mail, web browsing, listening to music 
(MP3/OGG), and thematic eye-candy for the weary eye. These are all no-brainers 
in Linux. 

True, Linux may lack specialty apps, like FrontPage, but what percentage of
computer users need a WYSIWYG web authoring tool?

 Win4Lin doesn't support anything fancy at all .
 No sound, no fancy computational/graphical demands .

Did a VMware sales rep tell you that? It does support sound, and it handles
graphics fine. I use Photoshop every other day, and the only draw back is
the lack of Apple's gamma loader for screen calibration which is hardly a
crisis.

 4. Sensible backups to CD?  Forget it!  I have learned that this is a
 non-event for Win4Lin for the forseeable future.

You can make your own Win4Lin backup from the Linux side which, in fact,
is more powerful and flexible than it could ever be in Winsux.  

 5. The 8.2 Mandrake had terrific writeups in the press - but in the light of
 the failures being experienced by the geek contingent on this list already,
 it is a loong way off being real-world ready. It is actually trashing
 many previously hard-won working installations!

You're delusional.

 6. It appears to me to be still the most fabulous Server System in the world
 and great fun for the hobbyist/masochist, but I am still highly motivated by
 the continual failures of the MS OS and their draconian plans for the
 future, so will keep coming back in hopes.

The problem is not with Mandrake, it's with you. Seeing as that's not likely
to change, I don't see much point in you coming back. 

 1. I did own a specialised Networking Company before it was even called
 that! So I KNOW what can go wrong.

... in what, staffing and financing issues?

 I now believe that even a Civilme(expert)  could take literally days to get
 an existing Hardware  system up and WORKABLY on line.

Like I said: delusional. Civileme could get Linux running on a bread maker
and in less time that it took you to spin this drivel.

 NOTE: Because of the problems caused by Spammers, all email addressses must
 be real ( no freeby things like Hotmail etc) You can get advance info by
 going here, which is an autoresponder, and to subscribe:
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Thank you, Sinsei Spammer.
 
 If wanting something to be so was enough, we could create Hell, right here
 on earth
 Kilneth
 (Think about THAT one! :-)  )

If wanting something to be so was enough, we could send John to Mars,
right here and now
Miark
(Think about that one! :-P


Miark



Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? 
Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com



Re: [newbie] Living in the real world - Win4Lin4 NO INTEREST TO GEEK FOLKS

2002-03-21 Thread Sridhar Dhanapalan

On Thu, 21 Mar 2002 17:16:48 +1000, john rigby [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 Even Civilme (the resident expert on the Newbie list) THOUGHT he was putting
 me in my place by telling me that in some Govt Dept they had some typistes
 *actually* using Linux and olde Star Office. BUT then went on and said they
 were *using* WorpdPerfect!  (Sigh) A separate and quite expensive product
 (but very good) except that nobody I know outside of Civilme has ever got it
 to go on and work!

Wordperfect was one of the first things I got going myself after I started using
GNU/Linux. I had next to no GNU/Linux experience at the time, but I found the
installation to be a breeze. It is a free (as in beer) download.

 1.  There is nothing like even FrontPage98 in the Linux world that I could
 get to install/see working. One of them trashed one of my semi-successful
 installs completely.
 ( I also  used the one IBM bought out, in its Doze form and it was full of
 holes.)

FrontPage98 is a joke. It is malware like this that is destroying the open
Internet.

 2.  If you are a serious business user, you NEED to be moving toward voice
 recognition as you know.

No, I don't know. Why would a business need voice recognition? I once tried
using Viavoice for a whole year -- my productivity decreased despite my best
efforts at speaking clearly (something which I've been told I'm good at) and
training the software. These packages often advertise 90%-95% accuracy. This
sounds great, until you realise that this means that every 10-20 words will be
incorrectly interpreted. John Dvorak recently wrote an interesting article on
the topic: http://zdnet.com.com/2100-1107-826862.html.

 3. I don't think the available products that I used, when I did sometimes
 get Manrake to *partially* work, are anywhere near commercial acceptability.
 ( Star Office, KDE etc. incredibly poor presentation and often almost
 non-existent help structures).

What is your definition of incredibly poor presentation? Open source
developers usually prefer to focus on code quality rather than polish. MS
products are riddled with bugs and holes; you just don't notice them as much
because the source is closed and they deliberately obscure things with
bangs-and-whistles. StarOffice and KDE (to use your examples) are very usable
and stable. They _do_ have extensive help structures, so either you didn't
install them or you just didn't look properly.

 5. The 8.2 Mandrake had terrific writeups in the press - but in the light of
 the failures being experienced by the geek contingent on this list already,
 it is a loong way off being real-world ready. It is actually trashing
 many previously hard-won working installations!

Nothing is perfect. Go to a Windows list and I'll guarantee you that you'll see
many users with problems. On this list, most problems are quite minor, and many
messages are simple enquiries.

 6. It appears to me to be still the most fabulous Server System in the world
 and great fun for the hobbyist/masochist, but I am still highly motivated by
 the continual failures of the MS OS and their draconian plans for the
 future, so will keep coming back in hopes.

You seem awfully pessimistic for one who is in hopes.

 I believe you really need a Geek to get you online.

Back in 2000, I decided to give Win2K a test drive. The CD refused to boot into
the installer, even though I had installed numerous GNU/Linux distros this way.
After pouring through the docs on the CD, I managed to make some discs from
which to start the installation. IIRC, there were _five_ of them. Next, I
started the installation with the discs. After an inordinate amount of time
waiting for it to load (not because of the discs), I was thrown into a
boring-looking text-based installer. It refused to accept my PartitionMagic-made
NTFS partition, and proceeded to reformat it. After that, the installation
began. A long time and several gigabytes (!) later, the installation was
complete. I rebooted, but the system refused to boot into Win2K! I tried the
whole installation process two more times before giving up.

Then the geekiness kicked in. I remembered that LILO used to have a problem with
booting from a partition that was past the 1024th cylinder on a drive. I deduced
that Win2K might have the same problem (probably deliberately, to prevent users
from dual-booting with a non-MS OS). I repartitioned my drive, making an NTFS
partition at the beginning. After reinstalling Win2k, it booted to the GUI. Had
I not been a geek, I would not hae known this relatively obscure tidbit of
information.

Getting online was the interesting bit. I have a Netcomm external modem (which
are very common in Australia), which has a _real_ Rockwell (now Connexant)
chipset. I tried a variety of different generic and vendor-issued drivers, and I
tried just about every Dial-up-networking setting. After a week of trying and
then giving up, my modem magically started to work. I still don't know why this
happened.

In 

[newbie] Living in the real world - Win4Lin4 NO INTEREST TO GEEK FOLKS

2002-03-20 Thread john rigby


Hello Non-geeks,
Good news  - but like the Curate's egg,  only - quite good in
parts :-)

Win4lin is to release a new product soon which will release more memory for
operations in Windoze. I almost fell off my highchair when I learned it is
limited to 64k. BUT apparently is so efficient in the use of it under Linux
that it doesn't do too badly at all.
As a solution though, it is still very loose for the serious (but non-geek)
user.
Even Civilme (the resident expert on the Newbie list) THOUGHT he was putting
me in my place by telling me that in some Govt Dept they had some typistes
*actually* using Linux and olde Star Office. BUT then went on and said they
were *using* WorpdPerfect!  (Sigh) A separate and quite expensive product
(but very good) except that nobody I know outside of Civilme has ever got it
to go on and work!

You will need to consider some of the Doze options for some time to come, in
my *practical applications* opinion.

Here is the game state up to now as I have been able to drag it out in the
last month since I returned to see if the performance had improved for
Mandrake since I gave up on 8.0:

1.  There is nothing like even FrontPage98 in the Linux world that I could
get to install/see working. One of them trashed one of my semi-successful
installs completely.
( I also  used the one IBM bought out, in its Doze form and it was full of
holes.)

2.  If you are a serious business user, you NEED to be moving toward voice
recognition as you know. Win4Lin doesn't support anything fancy at all .
No sound, no fancy computational/graphical demands .
BUT
They do expect to have a decent amount of memory available in V4 for our
bloated  MS products.

You do have the option of using the IBM ViaVoice product - if you can ever
get Linux working on your system, but I've not tried it and it is a
lower-level version than the outside world version.
BTW: Be careful of the included Software with anyone's packages, but
Mandrakes 8.0 claimed to include Via Voice et al and I've since been told
that they were only trial programs!!
(Nobody I personally know has been able to get Mandrake any distro to work
properly, you see, so this is heresay... )

3. I don't think the available products that I used, when I did sometimes
get Manrake to *partially* work, are anywhere near commercial acceptability.
( Star Office, KDE etc. incredibly poor presentation and often almost
non-existent help structures).

4. Sensible backups to CD?  Forget it!  I have learned that this is a
non-event for Win4Lin for the forseeable future.
But, I don't know anyone that got anything simple like Doze's  Nero or EZCD
to go under Linux and several Geeks (privately) told me to forget it.
 Borne out by the massive problems reported on the list here with CDR much
less CDW).

5. The 8.2 Mandrake had terrific writeups in the press - but in the light of
the failures being experienced by the geek contingent on this list already,
it is a loong way off being real-world ready. It is actually trashing
many previously hard-won working installations!

6. It appears to me to be still the most fabulous Server System in the world
and great fun for the hobbyist/masochist, but I am still highly motivated by
the continual failures of the MS OS and their draconian plans for the
future, so will keep coming back in hopes.

SUMMARY:

I believe you really need a Geek to get you online.
BUT Be careful!  I've  wasted money on would-be experts - but I must say I
was sympathetic on 2 grounds:

1. I did own a specialised Networking Company before it was even called
that! So  I KNOW what can go wrong.

2. Distros are notoriously confounded by the insane desperate attempt to
serve 2 masters:
the poor Geek who wants/expects everything in life to be free, including
full-blown Server Systems(!) and the real world market which simply wants to
pay its money and get a working, useful product.

SO, get a fixed price for the job. NEVER pay by the hour - even $5 p.h. !!!
I now believe that even a Civilme(expert)  could take literally days to get
an existing Hardware  system up and WORKABLY on line.
*** (Having said that, there is an interesting piece in the E-News REALITY
in the next week or so.)

Do be prepared to install Win4Lin to keep access to your proven and
trained-in products. I have heard of excellent results from people using
Lotus Smartsuite in these conditions.
Do have one or more systems Windows bootable with Win4Lin and use Linux as a
dedicated Internet Server on another, if possible.

DON'T DO ANYTHING NOW.  Unless you can dedicate a lot of non-producing time
to the project, it is still early days.
By all means, get a standby machine and have a go. But, don't attempt
serious business integration for some time yet.

I believe that someone of (business) maturity will take over in Mandrake, or
one of the many others and do the bleedin' obvious ( to any experienced
businessman) and get out a productivity-designed package for the 90