lack of definition -- is that so wrong?

1999-03-05 Thread Rob Russell

Since everybody always asks, upon finding out that I have a band, 
"What kind of music do you play?", I have had to think about genre 
definitions way too much for my own good. Still, I don't have a good 
answer. Here are a couple of recent incidents that reveal the inadequacy of 
prevailing terminology/attitudes:

* a girl from the bluegrass program, working with a tutor in our 
center, asks me about my band; as I start to name off bands she might 
have heard of that we might have some similarity to, I use the 
unfortunate term "alt.country." "Like Shania Twain?" she asks. I try 
to hide my disgust ... but do not succeed!

*at a gig last weekend in Bristol (the "birthplace" of country 
music) a couple of young ladies enter the club's door while we are 
playing our opening number, one of our "countries" tunes. They watch 
in amazement for about 30 seconds, shake their heads and leave. Half 
an hour later, another set of ladies, a few years older, walk through 
the bar door while we're playing one of our hardest-rocking songs; 
the watch in amazement for about 30 seconds, shake their heads and 
leave.  Disturbed at this phenomenon, I asked the doorman during the 
break, "Are we THAT ugly?" He said, "Yes, but that's not why the 
didn't come in -- the first group hated country, and the second group 
didn't want to hear any of that 'acid rock.' So that's us -- Acid 
Country!

___
Robert A. Russell
Director, Writing and Communication Center
East Tennessee State University
Box 70602
Johnson City, TN  37614
Phone:  (423) 439-8438
Fax: (423) 439-8666
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.etsu.edu/wcc

***
"Objective evidence and certitude are doubtless very fine ideals to play with
but where on this moonlit and dream-visited planet are they found?"

-- William James, 1842-1910, "The Will to Believe"



Re: lack of definition -- is that so wrong?

1999-03-05 Thread Jerry Curry

On Sat, 6 Mar 1999, Rob Russell wrote:

 have heard of that we might have some similarity to, I use the 
 unfortunate term "alt.country." "Like Shania Twain?" she asks. I try 
 to hide my disgust ... but do not succeed!

Well, applying the abbreviation "alt" to mean alternative to the
mainstream, I would say indeed.Shania Twain does play "alt. country".

That's an alternative to traditional/classic country.  Just a different
application of the abbr. alt. in my book, but a valid one, noe the less.

NP: Gary Allen - non alt.country
Jerry



Re: lack of definition -- is that so wrong?

1999-03-05 Thread Rob Russell


I wrote:

  have heard of that we might have some similarity to, I use the 
  unfortunate term "alt.country." "Like Shania Twain?" she asks. I try 
  to hide my disgust ... but do not succeed!
 

Jerry wrote:
 Well, applying the abbreviation "alt" to mean alternative to the
 mainstream, I would say indeed.Shania Twain does play "alt. country".
 

Absolutely -- I ain't disagreeing with you. The incident just shows how
flimsy the term is, don'tcha think? I mean ... ah, hell, whatever

Rob

Np. A tape of myself saying, "I will not over-intellectualize my ideas
about music, I will not over-intellectualize my ideas about music, I will
not over-intellectualize my ideas about music, I will not
over-intellectualize my ideas about music, I will not over-intellectualize
my ideas about music, I will not over-intellectualize my ideas about music,
I will not over-intellectualize my ideas about music," ad infinitum.

___
Rob Russell
Johnson City, TN
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://listen.to/thebystanders