Re: virtual domains, cyrus and lmtp integration
On 5/29/2013 10:30 PM, Carl Brewer wrote: On 30/05/2013 1:23 PM, Viktor Dukhovni wrote: ... At previous employer Cyrus was used with users defined in LDAP. I want to avoid multiple places where user data is stored, at present it's in cyrus and using sasldb for passwords, I'd like to keep that if I can. LDAP is just another thing I'd have to learn and maintain. If you deliver from Postfix to Cyrus via LMTP it may be possible to target RAV against the Cyrus' LMTP server. http://www.postfix.org/ADDRESS_VERIFICATION_README.html#recipient I don't know if anyone has tried RAV via LMTP, but since RCPTO exists in LMTP this should be able to work. There are some caveats to using RAV, but this should meet your single user database requirement. -- Stan
Re: virtual domains, cyrus and lmtp integration
On 30/05/2013 7:47 PM, Stan Hoeppner wrote: If you deliver from Postfix to Cyrus via LMTP it may be possible to target RAV against the Cyrus' LMTP server. http://www.postfix.org/ADDRESS_VERIFICATION_README.html#recipient I don't know if anyone has tried RAV via LMTP, but since RCPTO exists in LMTP this should be able to work. There are some caveats to using RAV, but this should meet your single user database requirement. Awesome, thank you, I'll read up on it! Carl
Re: virtual domains, cyrus and lmtp integration
Viktor Dukhovni: http://www.jmaimon.com/sendmail/anfi.homeunix.net/sendmail/rtcyrus2.html Perhaps someone would like to contribute a table driver for the Cyrus socketmap interface, or you could query it via a tcp table. Postfix 2.10 supports sendmail-style socketmap. Wietse
Re: virtual domains, cyrus and lmtp integration
On Thu, May 30, 2013 at 01:03:04PM +1000, Carl Brewer wrote: Firstly, the doco I've read suggests that every mailbox needs an entry in the virtual_mailbox_maps file, with my current sendmail setup sendmail checks against Cyrus for if a mailbox exists and has no (or at least not very many, and they're aliases etc) direct lists of email addresses. The Cyrus check you perform with Sendmail is also a table lookup, the table happens to be maintained by Cyrus. Can you make this data available via one of the table types supported by Postfix? - cdb - Berkeley DB - LDAP - PgSQL - MySQL - tcp - ... Does Postfix require a list of all email addresses or can it pull this from cyrus in realtime like Sendmail does (means I can admin it mostly just using cyradm). The realtime sendmail integration is from here : http://www.jmaimon.com/sendmail/anfi.homeunix.net/sendmail/rtcyrus2.html Perhaps someone would like to contribute a table driver for the Cyrus socketmap interface, or you could query it via a tcp table. If I'm using unix domain separators (/) for cyrus's virtual domains, how do I tell Postfix about this? My Cyrus usernames are user/f...@bar.com The above does not make sense (the unix domain part is a non sequitur). What is the public email address of a typical valid user? What is the mailbox SMTP address when this is internally forwarded to Cyrus? Do you really include / in the local part of user email addresses? Is there anyone out there with a working cyrus, virtual domains and postfix setup (there must be 100's!) who's got a solid howto somewhere? The one on the postfix website is blank : http://www.postfix.org/CYRUS_README.html At previous employer Cyrus was used with users defined in LDAP. -- Viktor.
Re: virtual domains, cyrus and lmtp integration
On 30/05/2013 1:23 PM, Viktor Dukhovni wrote: On Thu, May 30, 2013 at 01:03:04PM +1000, Carl Brewer wrote: Firstly, the doco I've read suggests that every mailbox needs an entry in the virtual_mailbox_maps file, with my current sendmail setup sendmail checks against Cyrus for if a mailbox exists and has no (or at least not very many, and they're aliases etc) direct lists of email addresses. The Cyrus check you perform with Sendmail is also a table lookup, the table happens to be maintained by Cyrus. Can you make this data available via one of the table types supported by Postfix? - cdb - Berkeley DB - LDAP - PgSQL - MySQL - tcp - ... Without knowing the inner workings of cyrus, I don't know. Anyone here who's a cyrus guru? Does Postfix require a list of all email addresses or can it pull this from cyrus in realtime like Sendmail does (means I can admin it mostly just using cyradm). The realtime sendmail integration is from here : http://www.jmaimon.com/sendmail/anfi.homeunix.net/sendmail/rtcyrus2.html Perhaps someone would like to contribute a table driver for the Cyrus socketmap interface, or you could query it via a tcp table. If I'm using unix domain separators (/) for cyrus's virtual domains, how do I tell Postfix about this? My Cyrus usernames are user/f...@bar.com The above does not make sense (the unix domain part is a non sequitur). What is the public email address of a typical valid user? What is the mailbox SMTP address when this is internally forwarded to Cyrus? Do you really include / in the local part of user email addresses? No, but when using cyrus, you can use a . or a / as the UNIX heirarchy separator in the imapd.conf file as follows : unixhierarchysep: yes which is a /, the default is a . so when I use cyradm to create a user : cyradm cm user/f...@bar.com that then maps neatly into the filesystem. Is there anyone out there with a working cyrus, virtual domains and postfix setup (there must be 100's!) who's got a solid howto somewhere? The one on the postfix website is blank : http://www.postfix.org/CYRUS_README.html At previous employer Cyrus was used with users defined in LDAP. I want to avoid multiple places where user data is stored, at present it's in cyrus and using sasldb for passwords, I'd like to keep that if I can. LDAP is just another thing I'd have to learn and maintain. thank you Carl
