HP merely voiced his opinion about what has been happening here. That is
his/her right and the Moderator was pretty cool to allow his posting out and we
did read his/hers. Had the Moderator censored his posting, we wouldnt have
any of these kinds of debates, so PPI India DOES promote DEMOCRACY amongst its
members after all. Therefore I applaud for that.
HP was brave enough to say what he/she wanted to say, even some of the words
were too harsh and werent appropriate. He/She couldve stated his/her position
better using a respectful language but then again we, humans are not free of
mistakes. I do agree with him/her to some degree and I can understand where
he/she is coming from. I dont really have a big problem regarding people who
have nicknames here, so what?!! It does not mean a form of a name will
ACTUALLY BE A REAL NAME of the person who has that name. We can always make up
a name, whats so hard about that?!
Anyway, we may have different opinion about other beliefs, principles, values,
ideologies, and ethics but as long as we respect each other, we should have any
problem at all. So guys, lets have a nice debate.
Carla Annamarie <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
dear hewlett,
tell u what.., tulisan anda dibawah ini sangat contradicted dengan email2
anda sebelumnya yang berbau SARA, kebencian, pardon me to say kebodohan...,
even mengemukakan pendapat adalah hak anda..
and kenapa gak menggunakan nama asli..? it seems so coward to hide behinds
"hewlett"..what a joke..:))...
dalam milis ini gak terdiri dari orang2 yang sempurna but at least we re
learning..and learning is a process..., ko dilihat dari kata2 anda yang
udah pengalaman 7 thn jadi member2 di milis2 lain..wow bgt..still ur
paradigm and ur attitude is not change at all..what ashame..:))..pak/mba/or
'cong..:))..whatever ur name or gender is.., ur words explain ur attitude
or mind and heart..., there're great anger in u..i think u dont have a
problems with this milis or any other milis..i think u have a big problem
with ur self..., i suggest that u should try to get help..emotionally,
intelllectually and more over spiritually..., pls do.., it's a friendly
advise..
anyway, u still can use ur right to speak or to express ur feeling or mind
here.., but i think it wont be taken seriously as a meaningful
statement..., but i think it's good for u to release ur anger and
hatred..., it's kinda the theraphy for u.., and i will support u for
that...
hope u will find peace in ur heart..
Rgds,
Carla
"HewLeTT"
To
Sent by:
[EMAIL PROTECTED] cc
ups.com <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>,
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>,
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>,
05/31/2005 01:06 <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>,
AM<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subject
Re: [ppiindia] Dari Moderator:
Please respond to Mohon Maaf
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
ups.com
Saya sudah memasuki periode tujuh tahun menjadi pembaca budiman untuk
berbagai
milis. Entah itu sekuler kayak milis proletar, apakabar, milis2 kriesten
dan islam. Dari
kesemuanya banyak milis memang dimoderatori.
PPINDIA ini setali tiga uang dengan milis yang diomoderatori. Tujuannya
sih
muluk2,
seperti upaya membangun masyarakat bla bla bla ...
I tell you one thing, guys!
Sepanjang 7 tahun mencermati semua milis tipikal bermoderator, tidak
satupun sukses
dengan tujuan yg mereka ingin capai. Dengan kata lain milis2 itu semua -
juga PPINDIA -
ini, tampak banci dan hipokrit.
Kenapa saya katakan demikian? Saya punya bukti.
Pertama setiap topik diskusi SARA tidak pernah berujung seperti apa yg
diharapkan.
Kedua, para anggota milis tetap menjadi dirinya seperti sedia kala. Kalau
dia anti
Islam, maka dia akan demikian selamanya dengan variasi tulisan dan
jotosannya
dengan segala hal yg menyangkut Islam.
Demikian juga pribadi-pribadi lainnya. Ke manapun mereka masuk milis,
karakternya
tetap tidak berubah. Ada bebarapa anggota milis PPIINDIA
