Re: [Simple-evcorr-users] SEC tutorial
hi Jim, feel free to share your remarks! Perhaps it is better to send them to my private email address, since the mailing list has a low limit for the maximum email size (I think it is only around 30-40KB). I will be out of office this weekend and next week to have my vacation, but after that I can start reading your remarks. kind regards, risto Kontakt Jim Van Meggelen () kirjutas kuupäeval N, 10. august 2023 kell 19:35: > Risto, > > I know it's been a long time, but I have been chipping away at that > tutorial. It has been really helpful. > > I'm not an academic person (I dropped out of high school), so I don't know > the correct and formal way to comment on academic papers. As such, my notes > might seem a bit less formal than is appropriate. > > I did however write a book for O'Reilly, so I do have a bit of a feel for > book writing, and it is from that angle that most of my comments are coming. > > Are you interested in what I've written? I fear giving offense, but I had > some ideas that might be worth considering. > > Jim > > > > -- > Jim Van Meggelen > ClearlyCore Inc. > > > > +1-416-639-6001 (DID) > +1-877-253-2716 (Canada) > +1-866-644-7729 (USA) > +1-416-425-6111 x6001 > jim.vanmegge...@clearlycore.com > http://www.clearlycore.com > > > *Asterisk: The Definitive GuideFIFTH EDITION NOW AVAILABLE TO DOWNLOAD:* > https://cdn.oreillystatic.com/pdf/Asterisk_The_Definitive_Guide.pdf > > -- > > *From: *"Risto Vaarandi" > *To: *"Jim Van Meggelen" > *Cc: *"simple-evcorr-users" > *Sent: *Thursday, 1 December, 2022 13:07:03 > *Subject: *Re: [Simple-evcorr-users] SEC tutorial > > hi Jim, > many thanks for your very kind offer! The tutorial is fairly large (around > 50 pages), but if you have time, I would appreciate your feedback. Adding > the remarks and recommendations into PDF works fine for me, and you can > just send the modified PDF over to my private email address. > kind regards, > risto > > Kontakt Jim Van Meggelen () kirjutas > kuupäeval N, 1. detsember 2022 kell 15:25: > >> Risto, >> >> Thanks for doing that up. I'll work through it. >> >> Are you interested in feedback on it? If so, do you have a preferred >> mechanism for that? (I can just mark up the PDF as I read through and >> upload it somewhere when I'm done). Note that I might find myself mostly >> copyediting, rather than testing all the examples. >> >> Jim >> >> >> -- >> Jim Van Meggelen >> ClearlyCore Inc. >> >> >> >> +1-416-639-6001 (DID) >> +1-877-253-2716 (Canada) >> +1-866-644-7729 (USA) >> +1-416-425-6111 x6001 >> jim.vanmegge...@clearlycore.com >> http://www.clearlycore.com >> >> >> *Asterisk: The Definitive GuideFIFTH EDITION NOW AVAILABLE TO DOWNLOAD:* >> https://cdn.oreillystatic.com/pdf/Asterisk_The_Definitive_Guide.pdf >> >> -- >> >> *From: *"Risto Vaarandi" >> *To: *"simple-evcorr-users" >> *Sent: *Thursday, 1 December, 2022 05:23:48 >> *Subject: *[Simple-evcorr-users] SEC tutorial >> >> hi all, >> >> during the last few weeks, I have written a new SEC tutorial paper which >> can be accessed through this web link: >> https://raw.githubusercontent.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial/main/SEC-tutorial.pdf >> Links to this tutorial and the relevant Github repository ( >> https://github.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial) are also available in the SEC >> home page. >> >> This tutorial is primarily intended for people who haven't used SEC >> before, and it explains the essentials of SEC in a gentle way, starting >> from simple examples and gradually moving to more complex ones. After >> reading this tutorial, the reader should have a good understanding of event >> correlation rules, event correlation operations, contexts, synthetic >> events, pattern match caching, and many other things. And it might provide >> interesting insights even for experienced users :) >> >> As mentioned in the introduction, this tutorial does not intend to be a >> replacement for the official documentation. Therefore, it does not attempt >> to explain every possible detail, but rather provide an overview of the key >> concepts, so that it would be easier to look up more detailed information >> from the man page. >> >> Hopefully the tutorial will be useful and you will find it easy to follow >> :) >> >> kind regards, >> risto >> >> >> ___ >> Simple-evcorr-users mailing list >> Simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net >> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/simple-evcorr-users >> >> > ___ Simple-evcorr-users mailing list Simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/simple-evcorr-users
Re: [Simple-evcorr-users] SEC tutorial
Risto, I know it's been a long time, but I have been chipping away at that tutorial. It has been really helpful. I'm not an academic person (I dropped out of high school), so I don't know the correct and formal way to comment on academic papers. As such, my notes might seem a bit less formal than is appropriate. I did however write a book for O'Reilly, so I do have a bit of a feel for book writing, and it is from that angle that most of my comments are coming. Are you interested in what I've written? I fear giving offense, but I had some ideas that might be worth considering. Jim -- Jim Van Meggelen ClearlyCore Inc. +1-416-639-6001 (DID) +1-877-253-2716 (Canada) +1-866-644-7729 (USA) +1-416-425-6111 x6001 jim.vanmegge...@clearlycore.com [ http://www.clearlycore.com/ | http://www.clearlycore.com ] Asterisk: The Definitive Guide FIFTH EDITION NOW AVAILABLE TO DOWNLOAD: [ https://cdn.oreillystatic.com/pdf/Asterisk_The_Definitive_Guide.pdf | https://cdn.oreillystatic.com/pdf/Asterisk_The_Definitive_Guide.pdf ] > From: "Risto Vaarandi" > To: "Jim Van Meggelen" > Cc: "simple-evcorr-users" > Sent: Thursday, 1 December, 2022 13:07:03 > Subject: Re: [Simple-evcorr-users] SEC tutorial > hi Jim, > many thanks for your very kind offer! The tutorial is fairly large (around 50 > pages), but if you have time, I would appreciate your feedback. Adding the > remarks and recommendations into PDF works fine for me, and you can just send > the modified PDF over to my private email address. > kind regards, > risto > Kontakt Jim Van Meggelen (< [ mailto:jim.vanmegge...@clearlycore.com | > jim.vanmegge...@clearlycore.com ] >) kirjutas kuupäeval N, 1. detsember 2022 > kell 15:25: >> Risto, >> Thanks for doing that up. I'll work through it. >> Are you interested in feedback on it? If so, do you have a preferred >> mechanism >> for that? (I can just mark up the PDF as I read through and upload it >> somewhere >> when I'm done). Note that I might find myself mostly copyediting, rather than >> testing all the examples. >> Jim >> -- >> Jim Van Meggelen >> ClearlyCore Inc. >> +1-416-639-6001 (DID) >> +1-877-253-2716 (Canada) >> +1-866-644-7729 (USA) >> +1-416-425-6111 x6001 >> [ mailto:jim.vanmegge...@clearlycore.com | jim.vanmegge...@clearlycore.com ] >> [ http://www.clearlycore.com/ | http://www.clearlycore.com ] >> Asterisk: The Definitive Guide >> FIFTH EDITION NOW AVAILABLE TO DOWNLOAD: >> [ https://cdn.oreillystatic.com/pdf/Asterisk_The_Definitive_Guide.pdf | >> https://cdn.oreillystatic.com/pdf/Asterisk_The_Definitive_Guide.pdf ] >>> From: "Risto Vaarandi" < [ mailto:risto.vaara...@gmail.com | >>> risto.vaara...@gmail.com ] > >>> To: "simple-evcorr-users" < [ >>> mailto:simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net | >>> simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net ] > >>> Sent: Thursday, 1 December, 2022 05:23:48 >>> Subject: [Simple-evcorr-users] SEC tutorial >>> hi all, >>> during the last few weeks, I have written a new SEC tutorial paper which >>> can be >>> accessed through this web link: [ >>> https://raw.githubusercontent.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial/main/SEC-tutorial.pdf >>> | >>> https://raw.githubusercontent.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial/main/SEC-tutorial.pdf >>> ] >>> Links to this tutorial and the relevant Github repository ( [ >>> https://github.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial | >>> https://github.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial ] ) are also available in the SEC >>> home page. >>> This tutorial is primarily intended for people who haven't used SEC before, >>> and >>> it explains the essentials of SEC in a gentle way, starting from simple >>> examples and gradually moving to more complex ones. After reading this >>> tutorial, the reader should have a good understanding of event correlation >>> rules, event correlation operations, contexts, synthetic events, pattern >>> match >>> caching, and many other things. And it might provide interesting insights >>> even >>> for experienced users :) >>> As mentioned in the introduction, this tutorial does not intend to be a >>> replacement for the official documentation. Therefore, it does not attempt >>> to >>> explain every possible detail, but rather provide an overview of the key >>> concepts, so that it would be easier to look up more detailed information >>> from >>> the man page. >>> Hopefully the tutorial will be useful and you will find it easy to follow :) >>> kind regards, >>> risto >>> ___ >>> Simple-evcorr-users mailing list >>> [ mailto:Simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net | >>> Simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net ] >>> [ https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/simple-evcorr-users | >>> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/simple-evcorr-users ]___ Simple-evcorr-users mailing list Simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/simple-evcorr-users
Re: [Simple-evcorr-users] SEC tutorial
hi Dusan, many thanks for your kind words :) risto Kontakt Dusan Sovic () kirjutas kuupäeval R, 2. detsember 2022 kell 23:07: > Hi Risto, > > > > Thanks for this tutorial. > > It’s very handy (especially 4.5 Internal contexts). > > I’ve learned again something new. > > SEC helping me reliably more than 6 years without any issues. > > It’s simple, reliable and well-documented. > > > > Thank you, > > Dusan > > > > *Od: *Risto Vaarandi > *Odoslané: *štvrtok 1. decembra 2022 11:25 > *Komu: *simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net > *Predmet: *[Simple-evcorr-users] SEC tutorial > > > > hi all, > > > > during the last few weeks, I have written a new SEC tutorial paper which > can be accessed through this web link: > https://raw.githubusercontent.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial/main/SEC-tutorial.pdf > > Links to this tutorial and the relevant Github repository ( > https://github.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial) are also available in the SEC > home page. > > > > This tutorial is primarily intended for people who haven't used SEC > before, and it explains the essentials of SEC in a gentle way, starting > from simple examples and gradually moving to more complex ones. After > reading this tutorial, the reader should have a good understanding of event > correlation rules, event correlation operations, contexts, synthetic > events, pattern match caching, and many other things. And it might provide > interesting insights even for experienced users :) > > > > As mentioned in the introduction, this tutorial does not intend to be a > replacement for the official documentation. Therefore, it does not attempt > to explain every possible detail, but rather provide an overview of the key > concepts, so that it would be easier to look up more detailed information > from the man page. > > > > Hopefully the tutorial will be useful and you will find it easy to follow > :) > > > > kind regards, > > risto > > > ___ Simple-evcorr-users mailing list Simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/simple-evcorr-users
Re: [Simple-evcorr-users] SEC tutorial
hi Jim, many thanks for your very kind offer! The tutorial is fairly large (around 50 pages), but if you have time, I would appreciate your feedback. Adding the remarks and recommendations into PDF works fine for me, and you can just send the modified PDF over to my private email address. kind regards, risto Kontakt Jim Van Meggelen () kirjutas kuupäeval N, 1. detsember 2022 kell 15:25: > Risto, > > Thanks for doing that up. I'll work through it. > > Are you interested in feedback on it? If so, do you have a preferred > mechanism for that? (I can just mark up the PDF as I read through and > upload it somewhere when I'm done). Note that I might find myself mostly > copyediting, rather than testing all the examples. > > Jim > > > -- > Jim Van Meggelen > ClearlyCore Inc. > > > > +1-416-639-6001 (DID) > +1-877-253-2716 (Canada) > +1-866-644-7729 (USA) > +1-416-425-6111 x6001 > jim.vanmegge...@clearlycore.com > http://www.clearlycore.com > > > *Asterisk: The Definitive GuideFIFTH EDITION NOW AVAILABLE TO DOWNLOAD:* > https://cdn.oreillystatic.com/pdf/Asterisk_The_Definitive_Guide.pdf > > -- > > *From: *"Risto Vaarandi" > *To: *"simple-evcorr-users" > *Sent: *Thursday, 1 December, 2022 05:23:48 > *Subject: *[Simple-evcorr-users] SEC tutorial > > hi all, > > during the last few weeks, I have written a new SEC tutorial paper which > can be accessed through this web link: > https://raw.githubusercontent.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial/main/SEC-tutorial.pdf > Links to this tutorial and the relevant Github repository ( > https://github.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial) are also available in the SEC > home page. > > This tutorial is primarily intended for people who haven't used SEC > before, and it explains the essentials of SEC in a gentle way, starting > from simple examples and gradually moving to more complex ones. After > reading this tutorial, the reader should have a good understanding of event > correlation rules, event correlation operations, contexts, synthetic > events, pattern match caching, and many other things. And it might provide > interesting insights even for experienced users :) > > As mentioned in the introduction, this tutorial does not intend to be a > replacement for the official documentation. Therefore, it does not attempt > to explain every possible detail, but rather provide an overview of the key > concepts, so that it would be easier to look up more detailed information > from the man page. > > Hopefully the tutorial will be useful and you will find it easy to follow > :) > > kind regards, > risto > > > ___ > Simple-evcorr-users mailing list > Simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/simple-evcorr-users > > ___ Simple-evcorr-users mailing list Simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/simple-evcorr-users
Re: [Simple-evcorr-users] SEC tutorial
Risto, Thanks for doing that up. I'll work through it. Are you interested in feedback on it? If so, do you have a preferred mechanism for that? (I can just mark up the PDF as I read through and upload it somewhere when I'm done). Note that I might find myself mostly copyediting, rather than testing all the examples. Jim -- Jim Van Meggelen ClearlyCore Inc. +1-416-639-6001 (DID) +1-877-253-2716 (Canada) +1-866-644-7729 (USA) +1-416-425-6111 x6001 jim.vanmegge...@clearlycore.com [ http://www.clearlycore.com/ | http://www.clearlycore.com ] Asterisk: The Definitive Guide FIFTH EDITION NOW AVAILABLE TO DOWNLOAD: [ https://cdn.oreillystatic.com/pdf/Asterisk_The_Definitive_Guide.pdf | https://cdn.oreillystatic.com/pdf/Asterisk_The_Definitive_Guide.pdf ] > From: "Risto Vaarandi" > To: "simple-evcorr-users" > Sent: Thursday, 1 December, 2022 05:23:48 > Subject: [Simple-evcorr-users] SEC tutorial > hi all, > during the last few weeks, I have written a new SEC tutorial paper which can > be > accessed through this web link: [ > https://raw.githubusercontent.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial/main/SEC-tutorial.pdf > | > https://raw.githubusercontent.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial/main/SEC-tutorial.pdf > ] > Links to this tutorial and the relevant Github repository ( [ > https://github.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial | > https://github.com/simple-evcorr/tutorial ] ) are also available in the SEC > home page. > This tutorial is primarily intended for people who haven't used SEC before, > and > it explains the essentials of SEC in a gentle way, starting from simple > examples and gradually moving to more complex ones. After reading this > tutorial, the reader should have a good understanding of event correlation > rules, event correlation operations, contexts, synthetic events, pattern match > caching, and many other things. And it might provide interesting insights even > for experienced users :) > As mentioned in the introduction, this tutorial does not intend to be a > replacement for the official documentation. Therefore, it does not attempt to > explain every possible detail, but rather provide an overview of the key > concepts, so that it would be easier to look up more detailed information from > the man page. > Hopefully the tutorial will be useful and you will find it easy to follow :) > kind regards, > risto > ___ > Simple-evcorr-users mailing list > Simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/simple-evcorr-users ___ Simple-evcorr-users mailing list Simple-evcorr-users@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/simple-evcorr-users
