[RCSE] LMR motor for Pike Superior

2005-11-14 Thread Jim Laurel
I am setting up a Pike Superior for F5J next season and am looking  
for some suggestions as to what drivetrain to put in it.  I have in  
my collection a couple of Aveox motors that I have never used: An  
F12LMR (10-16 cells) and F7LMR (7-10 cells).


So far, my experience with unlimited F5J planes is with my molded E- 
Graphite, which uses a Hacker B50S LMR (7-10 cell).  I've been  
running it on 10 cell GP2200 packs and it gives the Graphite a  
vertical climb.  I'd like the same sort of climb with this new Pike.


Few questions for you F5J  experts out there:

1) I want to run this plane on 10 cells so as to keep the weight  
down.  Am I better off running the F12LMR or the F7LMR with 10  
cells?  What are the pros and cons?


2) Will I be better off simply putting a tried and true Hacker  
B50SLMR in this plane?


3) In addition to the three large wires, the Aveox motors have a five- 
wire connector that apparently connects only to the Aveox  
controllers.  But all other controllers I've seen have only the three  
large wires.  What are the 5 small wires for?  And can an Aveox motor  
that has them be controlled by a Jeti or other brushless controller?


Thanks for any suggestions and advice!

--Jim Laurel
Seattle Area Soaring Society

RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News.  Send subscribe and 
unsubscribe requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]  Please note that subscribe and unsubscribe 
messages must be sent in text only format with MIME turned off.  Email sent from web based email 
such as Hotmail and AOL are generally NOT in text format


Re: [RCSE] LMR motor for Pike Superior

2005-11-14 Thread Dave
Jim I cannot answer the which powertrain question due to little knowledge but can answer the wire problem.In the early days of brushless controllers they needed a sensor in the motod to relate therotor position for motor control hence the 5 wires.With the later controllers these are not required this data is picked up by the micro from I believethe current waveform.You can run the motors on a modern controller no prob (I do an Aveoxon a Jeti controller) just ignore the sensor wires and tie them neatly in the nose area.RegardsDave (uk)
		To help you stay safe and secure online, we've developed the all new Yahoo! Security Centre.

Re: [RCSE] LMR motor for Pike Superior

2005-11-14 Thread Lee Estingoy

Hi Jim,

Sounds like a neat project.  I have recently converted an Artemis to 10 cell 
and it is a lot of fun.


I use an Aveox F10LMR in it with 10 GP2200s.  That's all that will fit!

You should consider trying out the various combinations in MotoCalc.  It's a 
great program that lets you test drive your combinations before you buy.


I think you will find that the Hacker motors are lighter for the same output 
as the Aveox.  Due to their better magnet design they can spin faster, and 
using the higher ratio gearboxes, spin a larger prop than the Aveox.  Larger 
prop disc results in moving more air = more thrust.


You will want to keep the setup as light as possible for best sailplane 
performance.  The added weight will also make it more challenging to spot 
land the ship.  It won't be the same as landing the TD ships.  A landing 
that would be normal for a TD ship DID result in cracked fuse on the Artemis 
due to the added mass.


All that said, I too had an F10 and an F12 hanging on the wall when I went 
to convert the Artemis.  I found the F10 to be the better option for me.



Commercial plug warning -- 
If you are in the market for a new speed control I'd like to suggest a 
Castle P-80 for this project.  It is a sensorless design, as are all 
controllers these days.  They work, and they have great support both for 
setup and for troubleshooting should you have any difficulties.  I think 
they are priced comparably to the Jetis, but I'd better find out for sure... 
There are a number of reasons that the P80 is a good choice, but in sum, 
it's very flexible and options may be selected in the programming that will 
help you have more fun and less trouble from your ship.


Yes, I do have a relationship with Castle.  I also have some LMR 
knowledge...


Good luck,  any questions, please don't hesitate to contact me.

Lee Estingoy
Overland Park, KS
2000 NATS Unlimited Electric Sailplane winner (woohooo!)
- Original Message - 
From: Jim Laurel [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To: RCSE soaring@airage.com
Sent: Monday, November 14, 2005 3:03 AM
Subject: [RCSE] LMR motor for Pike Superior


I am setting up a Pike Superior for F5J next season and am looking  for 
some suggestions as to what drivetrain to put in it.  I have in  my 
collection a couple of Aveox motors that I have never used: An  F12LMR 
(10-16 cells) and F7LMR (7-10 cells).


So far, my experience with unlimited F5J planes is with my molded E- 
Graphite, which uses a Hacker B50S LMR (7-10 cell).  I've been  running it 
on 10 cell GP2200 packs and it gives the Graphite a  vertical climb.  I'd 
like the same sort of climb with this new Pike.


Few questions for you F5J  experts out there:

1) I want to run this plane on 10 cells so as to keep the weight  down. 
Am I better off running the F12LMR or the F7LMR with 10  cells?  What are 
the pros and cons?


2) Will I be better off simply putting a tried and true Hacker  B50SLMR in 
this plane?


3) In addition to the three large wires, the Aveox motors have a five- 
wire connector that apparently connects only to the Aveox  controllers. 
But all other controllers I've seen have only the three  large wires. 
What are the 5 small wires for?  And can an Aveox motor  that has them be 
controlled by a Jeti or other brushless controller?


Thanks for any suggestions and advice!

--Jim Laurel
Seattle Area Soaring Society

RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News.  Send subscribe 
and unsubscribe requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]  Please note 
that subscribe and unsubscribe messages must be sent in text only format 
with MIME turned off.  Email sent from web based email such as Hotmail and 
AOL are generally NOT in text format




RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News.  Send subscribe and 
unsubscribe requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]  Please note that subscribe and unsubscribe 
messages must be sent in text only format with MIME turned off.  Email sent from web based email 
such as Hotmail and AOL are generally NOT in text format