Re: Problems with porting jsonrpc binding

2006-08-26 Thread ant elder

I don't think you are missing anything, this looks like a bug. Could you
raise a JIRA for it?...and a patch to fix it if you're keen :)

  ...ant

On 8/25/06, Bert Lamb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:


Ok, so the good news is that I got the binding and the sample working
when modifying the webapp.system.scdl in webapp-host.jar.

I decided it would be cleaner though to create my own copy of
webapp.system.scdl (and call it jsonrpc.system.scdl) to put in my
hello world webapp.  I tried this and modified the web.xml to have

context-param
 param-namesystemScdlPath/param-name
 param-value/META-INF/sca/jsonrpc.system.scdl/param-value
/context-param

However, this gives me a Null system SCDL URL Exception thrown.  I
looked at ServletLauncherListener.java and it looks like the
systemScdlPath URL is being loaded with a different classloader than
the applicationScdlPath which may be leading to the exception.

Guess I'll just stick with hacking into webapp-host.jar for now,
unless there is something I'm missing?

-Bert


On 8/24/06, ant elder [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 On 8/24/06, Bert Lamb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 snip/

 So just to clarify, until the extension mechanism is finalized I need
  be modifying scdl files in the webapp-host.jar to get my binding
  picked up?


 Thats right, or alternatively use your own version of the
webapp.system.scdl
 file in your web app.

...ant



-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: Problems with porting jsonrpc binding

2006-08-25 Thread Bert Lamb

Ok, so the good news is that I got the binding and the sample working
when modifying the webapp.system.scdl in webapp-host.jar.

I decided it would be cleaner though to create my own copy of
webapp.system.scdl (and call it jsonrpc.system.scdl) to put in my
hello world webapp.  I tried this and modified the web.xml to have

context-param
param-namesystemScdlPath/param-name
param-value/META-INF/sca/jsonrpc.system.scdl/param-value
/context-param

However, this gives me a Null system SCDL URL Exception thrown.  I
looked at ServletLauncherListener.java and it looks like the
systemScdlPath URL is being loaded with a different classloader than
the applicationScdlPath which may be leading to the exception.

Guess I'll just stick with hacking into webapp-host.jar for now,
unless there is something I'm missing?

-Bert


On 8/24/06, ant elder [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

On 8/24/06, Bert Lamb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

snip/

So just to clarify, until the extension mechanism is finalized I need
 be modifying scdl files in the webapp-host.jar to get my binding
 picked up?


Thats right, or alternatively use your own version of the webapp.system.scdl
file in your web app.

   ...ant




-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Problems with porting jsonrpc binding

2006-08-24 Thread Bert Lamb

Ant,

Changed the subject which I forgot to do on the last email...

So just to clarify, until the extension mechanism is finalized I need
be modifying scdl files in the webapp-host.jar to get my binding
picked up?

-Bert


On 8/24/06, ant elder [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

It looks pretty good. I'm guessing the system scdl being used by the web app
doesn't include the scdl for your binding. The way the sample webapps are
done right now with all the jars going into the webapp lib you need to add
all extensions to the system scdl being used. In you web.xml there's a
parameter systemScdlPath which is set to /META-INF/sca/webapp.system.scdl.
That will pick up the resource from the webapp-host.jar. Update that file or
copy it somewhere else and update the systemScdlPath to point at the new
file, and add in your jsonrpc scdl elements.

Once we get extension plugabilty going properly in the samples this wont be
necessary.

   ...ant

On 8/24/06, Bert Lamb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 Ok, my I tried to send this email earlier, but it bounced as spam, so
 I'm going to try again with a link to my attachment and see if that
 helps

 So I'm sure it is something stupid, but I'm missing something.
 I've got the sample webapp packaged correctly (I think) and it was
 giving the error about the unrecognized element binding.jasonrpc.  I
 then added my jsonrpc-1.0-SNAPSHOT.jar that I thought was at least
 mocked up correctly to get me onto the next error, but it doesn't seem
 to be getting picked up, and I still have the unrecognized element
 binding.jsonrpc error.

 Here is a link to a zip of my binding.jsonrpc source tree.  Any ideas?

 http://bertlamb.com/binding.jsonrpc.zip

 Thanks!

 -Bert

 On 8/18/06, ant elder [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
  Hi Bert,
 
  I agree there's going to be some challenges to solve to integrate REST
 well
  with Tuscany, I'll stay out of that for now and focus on how to get you
  started with bindings. Implementing a simple binding would be a good
 place
  to start so if you want to port over the old jsonrpc binding that would
 be
  great.
 
  The code for that is at,
 
 
http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/incubator/tuscany/branches/java-post-M1/sca/bindings/binding.jsonrpc/
 ,
  and there's a sample,
 
 
http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/incubator/tuscany/branches/java-post-M1/samples/sca/helloworldjsonrpc/
 .
  You could download the Tuscany M1 distribution if you want to see the
 sample
  running.
 
  I'd start by taking the sample and getting it to fit in with the new
 code
  base - convert the SCDL to the new format, and get the war packaging
  correct. You could use the Axis2 WS sample as a model for that which is
 at,
 
 
http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/incubator/tuscany/java/samples/sca/helloworldws/
 .
  (The WAR packaging is going to change once I finish the
  TuscanyServletListener and ServletHost work, I'll let you know when that
  goes in)
 
  Once you get the WAR right when you deploy it to tomcat you should see
 an
  exception about an unrecognized element: binding.jsonrpc, thats because
  Tuscany doesn't have a binding for it  so now you need to convert the
  binding over to the new Tuscany runtime. There's several bindings to use
 as
  models, the RMI or echo ones are simple, the Axis2 uses the ServletHost
  which you'll also need to do:
 
 
 
http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/incubator/tuscany/java/sca/bindings/binding.rmi/
 
 
http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/incubator/tuscany/java/samples/sca/echo.binding/
 
 
http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/incubator/tuscany/java/sca/bindings/binding.axis2/
 
  Copy the existing echo or RMI binding, rename all 'rmi' to jsonrpc',
 then
  try to hook up the JSONRPCEntryPointServlet based on what the Axis2
 binding
  is doing. You wont need the RMIReference or RMIInvoker classes as
 jsonrpc
  only supports services.
 
  There's also a binding using DWR instead of json-rpc-java which you port
 to
  the new runtime and its a bit more interesting as it also supports
  references (well, externalServices) so you could look at that as well if
  you're interested:
  http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/incubator/tuscany/sandbox/ant/ajax/.
 
  If you search back in the dev list archives there's a few mails where we
  talk about what these two binding do.
 
  Hope this helps,
 
 ...ant
 
  On 8/17/06, Bert Lamb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
  
   On 8/16/06, Jeremy Boynes [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
   
In terms of the basic transport, in M1 we had a JSON-RPC binding
 that
supported JSON encoded data over HTTP. We have not got around yet to
porting that to the new structure in the trunk. Looking at that
 would
be a good way to dig into how Tuscany works.
   
  
   I can make an attempt to try and port the jsonrpc binding from M1 over
   to trunk style extensions if this would be appreciated.  I agree that
   should help me get an understanding of how some of Tuscany works.
  
Oisin may have been referring to how REST would impact the
programming 

Re: Problems with porting jsonrpc binding

2006-08-24 Thread ant elder

On 8/24/06, Bert Lamb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

snip/

So just to clarify, until the extension mechanism is finalized I need

be modifying scdl files in the webapp-host.jar to get my binding
picked up?



Thats right, or alternatively use your own version of the webapp.system.scdl
file in your web app.

  ...ant