Re: [Apache UIMA 2.3 RC] - Missing Eclipse fragment org.apache.uima.runtime.fragments.deployeditor ?

2009-11-15 Thread Marshall Schor


Tong Fin wrote:
 It looks like we don't have the Eclipse fragment
 org.apache.uima.runtime.fragments.deployeditor which is required by the
 Deployment Descriptor Editor.
   
I see it in eclipsePlugins directory of my test dir built by unzipping
the uimaj binary distribution, and then the uima-as binary distribution
(on top of the uimaj base - as is now required).  (It is true it is not
provided with the base uima bin distribution, but it is provided with
the uima-as distribution.)

Where do you see it missing?

-Marshall
 -- Tong

   


Re: [Apache UIMA 2.3 RC] - Missing Eclipse fragment org.apache.uima.runtime.fragments.deployeditor ?

2009-11-15 Thread Tong Fin
On Sun, Nov 15, 2009 at 9:09 AM, Marshall Schor m...@schor.com wrote:



 Tong Fin wrote:
  It looks like we don't have the Eclipse fragment
  org.apache.uima.runtime.fragments.deployeditor which is required by the
  Deployment Descriptor Editor.
 
 I see it in eclipsePlugins directory of my test dir built by unzipping
 the uimaj binary distribution, and then the uima-as binary distribution
 (on top of the uimaj base - as is now required).  (It is true it is not
 provided with the base uima bin distribution, but it is provided with
 the uima-as distribution.)

OK. Now, I understand why I cannot see it in the base uimaj bin
distribution's eclipsePlugins directory unless I overlay uima-as
distribution.

I think we should not put DDE in the base uima bin distribution if we don't
expect it to work in that way. It will create a confusion for the end-users
that only use the base uima bin distribution unless we have a good raison to
put there.

-- Tong


Re: [Apache UIMA 2.3 RC] - Missing Eclipse fragment org.apache.uima.runtime.fragments.deployeditor ?

2009-11-15 Thread Marshall Schor


Tong Fin wrote:
 On Sun, Nov 15, 2009 at 9:09 AM, Marshall Schor m...@schor.com wrote:

   
 Tong Fin wrote:
 
 It looks like we don't have the Eclipse fragment
 org.apache.uima.runtime.fragments.deployeditor which is required by the
 Deployment Descriptor Editor.

   
 I see it in eclipsePlugins directory of my test dir built by unzipping
 the uimaj binary distribution, and then the uima-as binary distribution
 (on top of the uimaj base - as is now required).  (It is true it is not
 provided with the base uima bin distribution, but it is provided with
 the uima-as distribution.)

 
 OK. Now, I understand why I cannot see it in the base uimaj bin
 distribution's eclipsePlugins directory unless I overlay uima-as
 distribution.

 I think we should not put DDE in the base uima bin distribution if we don't
 expect it to work in that way. 

Sounds correct.  I looked in the bin distr for base UIMA, in the
eclipsePlugins folder, and don't see the DDE there - but it sounds like
you are seeing it somewhere it shouldn't be.  Can you be more speciifc?

-Marshall

 It will create a confusion for the end-users
 that only use the base uima bin distribution unless we have a good raison to
 put there.

 -- Tong

   


Re: [Apache UIMA 2.3 RC] - Missing Eclipse fragment org.apache.uima.runtime.fragments.deployeditor ?

2009-11-15 Thread Tong Fin
Sorry, it is a false alarm !

After repeating the operations and double checking the Eclipse Extension
Sites of my testing Eclipse, I really that there are two copy of uima
related plugins in different extension sites.

The distribution builds of the UIMA RC is CORRECT.

Sorry, Marshall !

-- Tong

On Sun, Nov 15, 2009 at 1:44 PM, Marshall Schor m...@schor.com wrote:



 Tong Fin wrote:
  On Sun, Nov 15, 2009 at 9:09 AM, Marshall Schor m...@schor.com wrote:
 
 
  Tong Fin wrote:
 
  It looks like we don't have the Eclipse fragment
  org.apache.uima.runtime.fragments.deployeditor which is required by
 the
  Deployment Descriptor Editor.
 
 
  I see it in eclipsePlugins directory of my test dir built by unzipping
  the uimaj binary distribution, and then the uima-as binary distribution
  (on top of the uimaj base - as is now required).  (It is true it is not
  provided with the base uima bin distribution, but it is provided with
  the uima-as distribution.)
 
 
  OK. Now, I understand why I cannot see it in the base uimaj bin
  distribution's eclipsePlugins directory unless I overlay uima-as
  distribution.
 
  I think we should not put DDE in the base uima bin distribution if we
 don't
  expect it to work in that way.

 Sounds correct.  I looked in the bin distr for base UIMA, in the
 eclipsePlugins folder, and don't see the DDE there - but it sounds like
 you are seeing it somewhere it shouldn't be.  Can you be more speciifc?

 -Marshall

  It will create a confusion for the end-users
  that only use the base uima bin distribution unless we have a good raison
 to
  put there.
 
  -- Tong