Re: Kill the Pig
thank you Attila for all that you do On Fri, May 12, 2023 at 9:30 AM Attila Turoczy wrote: > This decision must be made based on consensus. As we can see, there is > still usage within the community. Despite the personal challenges it > presents to me, I believe we should all agree to maintain support for > Apache Pig, and unfortunately, there won't be any bacon soon :) Thank you > to everyone who has shared their opinions. We will revisit this topic at a > later time. > > -Attila > > On Fri, Apr 28, 2023 at 4:22 PM Ugur Yardimci > wrote: > >> I totally agree +1 >> >> On Thu, 20 Apr 2023, 10:50 Attila Turoczy, wrote: >> >>> Hi All, >>> >>> In Hive we have a pretty old component from 1972 and this is the Pig. >>> Pig was cool somewhere in 2008, but nowadays it does not have any value in >>> the big data world. Even the last small release of big was 6 years ago in >>> 2017, also the pig community has pretty much died. Because this component >>> is obsolete I would suggest removing it from Hive 4.0. The hive 3 will >>> still contain it, but I think this is a right time to remove those >>> components that are not valuable for the community. >>> >>> What do you think about it? >>> >>> Ps: If nobody wrote it back, It would mean I could kill the pig (rof >>> rof) :) >>> >>> -Attila >>> >>
Re: Kill the Pig
This decision must be made based on consensus. As we can see, there is still usage within the community. Despite the personal challenges it presents to me, I believe we should all agree to maintain support for Apache Pig, and unfortunately, there won't be any bacon soon :) Thank you to everyone who has shared their opinions. We will revisit this topic at a later time. -Attila On Fri, Apr 28, 2023 at 4:22 PM Ugur Yardimci wrote: > I totally agree +1 > > On Thu, 20 Apr 2023, 10:50 Attila Turoczy, wrote: > >> Hi All, >> >> In Hive we have a pretty old component from 1972 and this is the Pig. Pig >> was cool somewhere in 2008, but nowadays it does not have any value in the >> big data world. Even the last small release of big was 6 years ago in 2017, >> also the pig community has pretty much died. Because this component is >> obsolete I would suggest removing it from Hive 4.0. The hive 3 will still >> contain it, but I think this is a right time to remove those components >> that are not valuable for the community. >> >> What do you think about it? >> >> Ps: If nobody wrote it back, It would mean I could kill the pig (rof rof) >> :) >> >> -Attila >> >
Re: Kill the Pig
I totally agree +1 On Thu, 20 Apr 2023, 10:50 Attila Turoczy, wrote: > Hi All, > > In Hive we have a pretty old component from 1972 and this is the Pig. Pig > was cool somewhere in 2008, but nowadays it does not have any value in the > big data world. Even the last small release of big was 6 years ago in 2017, > also the pig community has pretty much died. Because this component is > obsolete I would suggest removing it from Hive 4.0. The hive 3 will still > contain it, but I think this is a right time to remove those components > that are not valuable for the community. > > What do you think about it? > > Ps: If nobody wrote it back, It would mean I could kill the pig (rof rof) > :) > > -Attila >
Re: Kill the Pig
I checked the Pig repo and I see some recent activity. Rohini is actively leading the effort towards a new Pig release. Given that there is proven interest to maintain and contribute to this module I would prefer to keep it for the time being unless there are major issues that I am not aware of. Best, Stamatis On Thu, Apr 20, 2023, 9:09 PM Rohini Palaniswamy wrote: > Hi Attila, >We still use HCatLoader and HCatStorer heavily and would like to retain > the support. We are also fixing it to work with Iceberg tables and will be > contributing patches for both Hive 3 and Hive 4. So would like the support > to be continued with Hive 4. > > Regards, > Rohini > > On Thu, Apr 20, 2023 at 1:59 AM Alessandro Solimando < > alessandro.solima...@gmail.com> wrote: > > > +1 from me, let's just make sure we make a good salame out of it :) > > > > Best regards, > > Alessandro > > > > On Thu, 20 Apr 2023 at 10:50, Attila Turoczy > > wrote: > > > >> Hi All, > >> > >> In Hive we have a pretty old component from 1972 and this is the Pig. > Pig > >> was cool somewhere in 2008, but nowadays it does not have any value in > the > >> big data world. Even the last small release of big was 6 years ago in > 2017, > >> also the pig community has pretty much died. Because this component is > >> obsolete I would suggest removing it from Hive 4.0. The hive 3 will > still > >> contain it, but I think this is a right time to remove those components > >> that are not valuable for the community. > >> > >> What do you think about it? > >> > >> Ps: If nobody wrote it back, It would mean I could kill the pig (rof > rof) > >> :) > >> > >> -Attila > >> > > >
Re: Kill the Pig
Hi Attila, We still use HCatLoader and HCatStorer heavily and would like to retain the support. We are also fixing it to work with Iceberg tables and will be contributing patches for both Hive 3 and Hive 4. So would like the support to be continued with Hive 4. Regards, Rohini On Thu, Apr 20, 2023 at 1:59 AM Alessandro Solimando < alessandro.solima...@gmail.com> wrote: > +1 from me, let's just make sure we make a good salame out of it :) > > Best regards, > Alessandro > > On Thu, 20 Apr 2023 at 10:50, Attila Turoczy > wrote: > >> Hi All, >> >> In Hive we have a pretty old component from 1972 and this is the Pig. Pig >> was cool somewhere in 2008, but nowadays it does not have any value in the >> big data world. Even the last small release of big was 6 years ago in 2017, >> also the pig community has pretty much died. Because this component is >> obsolete I would suggest removing it from Hive 4.0. The hive 3 will still >> contain it, but I think this is a right time to remove those components >> that are not valuable for the community. >> >> What do you think about it? >> >> Ps: If nobody wrote it back, It would mean I could kill the pig (rof rof) >> :) >> >> -Attila >> >
Re: Kill the Pig
+1 from me, let's just make sure we make a good salame out of it :) Best regards, Alessandro On Thu, 20 Apr 2023 at 10:50, Attila Turoczy wrote: > Hi All, > > In Hive we have a pretty old component from 1972 and this is the Pig. Pig > was cool somewhere in 2008, but nowadays it does not have any value in the > big data world. Even the last small release of big was 6 years ago in 2017, > also the pig community has pretty much died. Because this component is > obsolete I would suggest removing it from Hive 4.0. The hive 3 will still > contain it, but I think this is a right time to remove those components > that are not valuable for the community. > > What do you think about it? > > Ps: If nobody wrote it back, It would mean I could kill the pig (rof rof) > :) > > -Attila >
Kill the Pig
Hi All, In Hive we have a pretty old component from 1972 and this is the Pig. Pig was cool somewhere in 2008, but nowadays it does not have any value in the big data world. Even the last small release of big was 6 years ago in 2017, also the pig community has pretty much died. Because this component is obsolete I would suggest removing it from Hive 4.0. The hive 3 will still contain it, but I think this is a right time to remove those components that are not valuable for the community. What do you think about it? Ps: If nobody wrote it back, It would mean I could kill the pig (rof rof) :) -Attila
