Re: Audio and video not working
Hello I got it working. For the time being, I opened : iptables -A INPUT -p udp -m udp --dport 3478 -j ACCEPT iptables -A OUTPUT -p udp -m udp --sport 3478 -j ACCEPT Thanks On Wednesday, March 25, 2020, 11:04:24 AM EDT, Marcus Schulz wrote: Hi, that's what I wrote yesterday to another thread with that problem. It may help you.I finally got it working, but without vpn. Kind regards Marcus Hi, I just subscribed to this list. I had the same problems and managed to get it works after tweo nights. I needed it also for a virtual classroom (who does not at the moemnt?? ) and for office.Please don't blame me, if i did not follow some rules here at the moment.I just want to help. My set up: ubuntu 18.04 lts image at a Strato VServer. OpenMeeting M3. First steps:I took the installation guide for ubuntu I found at the open meetings project site. Worked like a charm.Then I saw green bars when someone spoke, but no sound and no video except my own. first i had to run kurento not as user nobody as decribed, but I used default kurento. Otherwise there where exceptions cause home folder is "/nonexistent" and gstreamer caches failed to work.Not sure if it's important, but I fixed it for me. My openmeeting installation runs with user kurento also. Just change it in the /etc/init.d/tomcat3 skript and chown -R kurento /opt/open503 of course.When the compilation of ffmpeg that is made by the skript provided fails, just install the missing dev packages. Don't remeber all. But's that's easy to find out, because "make " complains about. Then I saw in the logs that connection to kurento server fails for web sockets. I read in the net and found that a turnserver is needed, when clients accessing kurento are located behind NAT. Guess almsot every home dial has such a setup, so I did it.If I am wrong with it, and that's only needed, If openmeetings is behind NAT, please tell me. Than I remove it again. if needed: apt-get install coturn vi /etc/turnserver.conf configure this:realm=kurento.orguser=kurento:somepasslog-file=/var/log/turnserver/turnserver.log I think that has been all. Then: vi /etc/kurento/modules/kurento/WebRtcEndpoint.conf.iniedit:turnURL=kurento:somepass@:3478 restart everything. Than didn't work very much better also, so I took a look at iptables log file. I added this rules: iptables -A INPUT -p udp -m udp --dport 1:65535 -j ACCEPTiptables -A OUTPUT -p udp -m udp --sport 1:65535 -j ACCEPTiptables -A INPUT -p udp -m udp --dport 3478 -j ACCEPTiptables -A OUTPUT -p udp -m udp --sport 3478 -j ACCEPT Now it works for me. There is may be missing something or useless. But finally I got a working solution.I am no WebRTC expert... just a JEE Developer with loves Linux for years :) Any suggestions or hints if somhing is wrong or useless are welcome. Kind regards Marcus Am Mittwoch, den 25.03.2020, 14:55 + schrieb Benteftifa, Hafed: Hello, It seems I am having the same problems as others regarding audio and video. Here is the setup (Ubuntu 18) after following Alvaro's instructions: Setup 1: VM on vpsserver worked correctly. While users had the https not safe message when using the IP address for the room, we were able to go through the conference with audio and video. This is a backup solutions for us. Setup 2: VM on our internal network. Access is through a VPN from the outside. While users had the https not safe message when using the IP address for the room, we were able to go through the conference with audio and video. Unfortunately, a lot of jitters and random freeze and booting out of some users occured. I believe this is due to the internal cloud server we used. We will not be using this solution (too difficult for some users to setup their vpn). Setup 3: We have a VM instance on Microsoft azure. While users had the https not safe message when using the IP address for the room, everybody was able to access the room and see his/her own camera and see the microphone working. However, the rest of us were not able to hear audio and video from the others. After spending hours on the mailing list, it boils down to us not using a TURN server. I found this link on the mailing list (see post by René Sholtz): https://markmail.org/message/3dgy62lj3m74mogy#query:+page:1+mid:3dgy62lj3m74mogy+state:results These are the instructions for configuring a TURN server (coturn). Since we are using an IP address, did anyone have success in making those configuration steps. Maybe Alvaro has written a setup manual for this part? Thanks
Re: Audio and video not working
Thanks. I appreciate. On Wednesday, March 25, 2020, 12:54:22 PM EDT, Alvaro wrote: In less than a week i will have prepared a tutorial for Let's Encrtpt certificates and Coturn. It is tested and works right on a server installed after router NAT. Alvaro ... El mié, 25-03-2020 a las 14:55 +, Benteftifa, Hafed escribió: > Hello, > > It seems I am having the same problems as others regarding audio and > video. > > Here is the setup (Ubuntu 18) after following Alvaro's instructions: > > Setup 1: VM on vpsserver worked correctly. While users had the https > not safe message when using the IP address for the room, we were able > to go through the conference with audio and video. This is a backup > solutions for us. > > Setup 2: VM on our internal network. Access is through a VPN from the > outside. While users had the https not safe message when using the IP > address for the room, we were able to go through the conference with > audio and video. Unfortunately, a lot of jitters and random freeze > and booting out of some users occured. I believe this is due to the > internal cloud server we used. We will not be using this solution > (too difficult for some users to setup their vpn). > > Setup 3: We have a VM instance on Microsoft azure. While users had > the https not safe message when using the IP address for the room, > everybody was able to access the room and see his/her own camera and > see the microphone working. However, the rest of us were not able to > hear audio and video from the others. After spending hours on the > mailing list, it boils down to us not using a TURN server. > > I found this link on the mailing list (see post by René Sholtz): htt > ps://markmail.org/message/3dgy62lj3m74mogy#query:+page:1+mid:3dgy62lj > 3m74mogy+state:results > > These are the instructions for configuring a TURN server (coturn). > Since we are using an IP address, did anyone have success in making > those configuration steps. Maybe Alvaro has written a setup manual > for this part? > > Thanks
Re: Audio and video not working
In less than a week i will have prepared a tutorial for Let's Encrtpt certificates and Coturn. It is tested and works right on a server installed after router NAT. Alvaro ... El mié, 25-03-2020 a las 14:55 +, Benteftifa, Hafed escribió: > Hello, > > It seems I am having the same problems as others regarding audio and > video. > > Here is the setup (Ubuntu 18) after following Alvaro's instructions: > > Setup 1: VM on vpsserver worked correctly. While users had the https > not safe message when using the IP address for the room, we were able > to go through the conference with audio and video. This is a backup > solutions for us. > > Setup 2: VM on our internal network. Access is through a VPN from the > outside. While users had the https not safe message when using the IP > address for the room, we were able to go through the conference with > audio and video. Unfortunately, a lot of jitters and random freeze > and booting out of some users occured. I believe this is due to the > internal cloud server we used. We will not be using this solution > (too difficult for some users to setup their vpn). > > Setup 3: We have a VM instance on Microsoft azure. While users had > the https not safe message when using the IP address for the room, > everybody was able to access the room and see his/her own camera and > see the microphone working. However, the rest of us were not able to > hear audio and video from the others. After spending hours on the > mailing list, it boils down to us not using a TURN server. > > I found this link on the mailing list (see post by René Sholtz): htt > ps://markmail.org/message/3dgy62lj3m74mogy#query:+page:1+mid:3dgy62lj > 3m74mogy+state:results > > These are the instructions for configuring a TURN server (coturn). > Since we are using an IP address, did anyone have success in making > those configuration steps. Maybe Alvaro has written a setup manual > for this part? > > Thanks
Re: Audio and video not working
Hello, I'm using same steps as listed in Rene's post - and everything is working Maybe you have TURN ports closed? On Wed, 25 Mar 2020 at 23:01, Daniel Baker wrote: > Yeah maybe we can build a VM for download that has TURN > installed already. A VM with TURN and one without. > > Thanks, > > > Dan > > On 25/03/2020 14:55, Benteftifa, Hafed wrote: > > Hello, > > > > It seems I am having the same problems as others regarding audio and > video. > > > > Here is the setup (Ubuntu 18) after following Alvaro's instructions: > > > > Setup 1: VM on vpsserver worked correctly. While users had the https > not safe message when using the IP address for the room, we were able to go > through the conference with audio and video. This is a backup solutions for > us. > > > > Setup 2: VM on our internal network. Access is through a VPN from the > outside. While users had the https not safe message when using the IP > address for the room, we were able to go through the conference with audio > and video. Unfortunately, a lot of jitters and random freeze and booting > out of some users occured. I believe this is due to the internal cloud > server we used. We will not be using this solution (too difficult for some > users to setup their vpn). > > > > Setup 3: We have a VM instance on Microsoft azure. While users had the > https not safe message when using the IP address for the room, everybody > was able to access the room and see his/her own camera and see the > microphone working. However, the rest of us were not able to hear audio and > video from the others. After spending hours on the mailing list, it boils > down to us not using a TURN server. > > > > I found this link on the mailing list (see post by René Sholtz): > https://markmail.org/message/3dgy62lj3m74mogy#query:+page:1+mid:3dgy62lj3m74mogy+state:results > > > > These are the instructions for configuring a TURN server (coturn). Since > we are using an IP address, did anyone have success in making those > configuration steps. Maybe Alvaro has written a setup manual for this part? > > > > Thanks > > > -- WBR Maxim aka solomax
Re: Audio and video not working
Yeah maybe we can build a VM for download that has TURN installed already. A VM with TURN and one without. Thanks, Dan On 25/03/2020 14:55, Benteftifa, Hafed wrote: Hello, It seems I am having the same problems as others regarding audio and video. Here is the setup (Ubuntu 18) after following Alvaro's instructions: Setup 1: VM on vpsserver worked correctly. While users had the https not safe message when using the IP address for the room, we were able to go through the conference with audio and video. This is a backup solutions for us. Setup 2: VM on our internal network. Access is through a VPN from the outside. While users had the https not safe message when using the IP address for the room, we were able to go through the conference with audio and video. Unfortunately, a lot of jitters and random freeze and booting out of some users occured. I believe this is due to the internal cloud server we used. We will not be using this solution (too difficult for some users to setup their vpn). Setup 3: We have a VM instance on Microsoft azure. While users had the https not safe message when using the IP address for the room, everybody was able to access the room and see his/her own camera and see the microphone working. However, the rest of us were not able to hear audio and video from the others. After spending hours on the mailing list, it boils down to us not using a TURN server. I found this link on the mailing list (see post by René Sholtz): https://markmail.org/message/3dgy62lj3m74mogy#query:+page:1+mid:3dgy62lj3m74mogy+state:results These are the instructions for configuring a TURN server (coturn). Since we are using an IP address, did anyone have success in making those configuration steps. Maybe Alvaro has written a setup manual for this part? Thanks
Audio and video not working
Hello, It seems I am having the same problems as others regarding audio and video. Here is the setup (Ubuntu 18) after following Alvaro's instructions: Setup 1: VM on vpsserver worked correctly. While users had the https not safe message when using the IP address for the room, we were able to go through the conference with audio and video. This is a backup solutions for us. Setup 2: VM on our internal network. Access is through a VPN from the outside. While users had the https not safe message when using the IP address for the room, we were able to go through the conference with audio and video. Unfortunately, a lot of jitters and random freeze and booting out of some users occured. I believe this is due to the internal cloud server we used. We will not be using this solution (too difficult for some users to setup their vpn). Setup 3: We have a VM instance on Microsoft azure. While users had the https not safe message when using the IP address for the room, everybody was able to access the room and see his/her own camera and see the microphone working. However, the rest of us were not able to hear audio and video from the others. After spending hours on the mailing list, it boils down to us not using a TURN server. I found this link on the mailing list (see post by René Sholtz): https://markmail.org/message/3dgy62lj3m74mogy#query:+page:1+mid:3dgy62lj3m74mogy+state:results These are the instructions for configuring a TURN server (coturn). Since we are using an IP address, did anyone have success in making those configuration steps. Maybe Alvaro has written a setup manual for this part? Thanks
