Re: Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between?
I do not think this really a big improvement. In my usecase, I need to do 4 things in a defined order in the after-package, so you are just moving the problem. A real ordering of plugin execution during the phases is what I really need. I admit that I just recently had a need for it after using Maven 2 for more then 2 years on various (big) projects, so it is rare I think that you need it, but if you do, you *really* need it. 2010/7/14 Gorham-Engard, Frank frank_gorham-eng...@cable.comcast.com Hello users, I have an alternate suggestion to the phase/goal ordering issues that are often raised here. Allow for the specification of phase to include a 'before-' or 'after-' prefix. Users could specify the phase for a plugin execution to be, for example, 'before-deploy' or 'after-package'. This wouldn't break the life-cycle model while permitting a constrained method for expanding it. Also, any 'after-' phases should be executed when the phase is the target. For example, if I specified a plugin for 'after-deploy' it would be executed (at the end) when the command line was 'mvn deploy'. Perhaps even 'before-before-test' should be allowed as well? But not 'before-after-test', let's not go there! !-- Frank Gorham-Engard → Be kinder than necessary. Everyone you work with is fighting some kind of battle. -Original Message- From: Wim Deblauwe [mailto:wim.debla...@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, July 13, 2010 5:10 AM To: Maven Users List Subject: Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between? Hi, I need to run the antrun plugin twice in the packaging phase. I found this on the wiki: http://docs.codehaus.org/display/MAVENUSER/MiniGuide-AntMultiPhase However, it speaks of different lifecycle phases. I tried with the same phase and that works, however, I need to run another plugin in between. Is this possible? I was hoping that all plugins' executions would be sorted by their id. That way, i could use id's like 'step-1-do-something', 'step-2-do-something-else', to force a certain order of plugin execution. regards, Wim
Re: Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between?
Can't you order the tasks inside Ant? Ron On 15/07/2010 2:31 AM, Wim Deblauwe wrote: I do not think this really a big improvement. In my usecase, I need to do 4 things in a defined order in the after-package, so you are just moving the problem. A real ordering of plugin execution during the phases is what I really need. I admit that I just recently had a need for it after using Maven 2 for more then 2 years on various (big) projects, so it is rare I think that you need it, but if you do, you *really* need it. 2010/7/14 Gorham-Engard, Frankfrank_gorham-eng...@cable.comcast.com Hello users, I have an alternate suggestion to the phase/goal ordering issues that are often raised here. Allow for the specification ofphase to include a 'before-' or 'after-' prefix. Users could specify thephase for a plugin execution to be, for example, 'before-deploy' or 'after-package'. This wouldn't break the life-cycle model while permitting a constrained method for expanding it. Also, any 'after-' phases should be executed when the phase is the target. For example, if I specified a plugin for 'after-deploy' it would be executed (at the end) when the command line was 'mvn deploy'. Perhaps even 'before-before-test' should be allowed as well? But not 'before-after-test', let's not go there! !-- Frank Gorham-Engard → Be kinder than necessary. Everyone you work with is fighting some kind of battle. -Original Message- From: Wim Deblauwe [mailto:wim.debla...@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, July 13, 2010 5:10 AM To: Maven Users List Subject: Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between? Hi, I need to run the antrun plugin twice in the packaging phase. I found this on the wiki: http://docs.codehaus.org/display/MAVENUSER/MiniGuide-AntMultiPhase However, it speaks of different lifecycle phases. I tried with the same phase and that works, however, I need to run another plugin in between. Is this possible? I was hoping that all plugins' executions would be sorted by their id. That way, i could use id's like 'step-1-do-something', 'step-2-do-something-else', to force a certain order of plugin execution. regards, Wim - To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@maven.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@maven.apache.org
Re: Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between?
That would mean I would have to call maven plugins from inside the maven antrun plugin. Seems odd and no idea if that is even possible? 2010/7/15 Ron Wheeler rwhee...@artifact-software.com Can't you order the tasks inside Ant? Ron On 15/07/2010 2:31 AM, Wim Deblauwe wrote: I do not think this really a big improvement. In my usecase, I need to do 4 things in a defined order in the after-package, so you are just moving the problem. A real ordering of plugin execution during the phases is what I really need. I admit that I just recently had a need for it after using Maven 2 for more then 2 years on various (big) projects, so it is rare I think that you need it, but if you do, you *really* need it. 2010/7/14 Gorham-Engard, Frankfrank_gorham-eng...@cable.comcast.com Hello users, I have an alternate suggestion to the phase/goal ordering issues that are often raised here. Allow for the specification ofphase to include a 'before-' or 'after-' prefix. Users could specify thephase for a plugin execution to be, for example, 'before-deploy' or 'after-package'. This wouldn't break the life-cycle model while permitting a constrained method for expanding it. Also, any 'after-' phases should be executed when the phase is the target. For example, if I specified a plugin for 'after-deploy' it would be executed (at the end) when the command line was 'mvn deploy'. Perhaps even 'before-before-test' should be allowed as well? But not 'before-after-test', let's not go there! !-- Frank Gorham-Engard → Be kinder than necessary. Everyone you work with is fighting some kind of battle. -Original Message- From: Wim Deblauwe [mailto:wim.debla...@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, July 13, 2010 5:10 AM To: Maven Users List Subject: Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between? Hi, I need to run the antrun plugin twice in the packaging phase. I found this on the wiki: http://docs.codehaus.org/display/MAVENUSER/MiniGuide-AntMultiPhase However, it speaks of different lifecycle phases. I tried with the same phase and that works, however, I need to run another plugin in between. Is this possible? I was hoping that all plugins' executions would be sorted by their id. That way, i could use id's like 'step-1-do-something', 'step-2-do-something-else', to force a certain order of plugin execution. regards, Wim - To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@maven.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@maven.apache.org
RE: Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between?
Hello users, I have an alternate suggestion to the phase/goal ordering issues that are often raised here. Allow for the specification of phase to include a 'before-' or 'after-' prefix. Users could specify the phase for a plugin execution to be, for example, 'before-deploy' or 'after-package'. This wouldn't break the life-cycle model while permitting a constrained method for expanding it. Also, any 'after-' phases should be executed when the phase is the target. For example, if I specified a plugin for 'after-deploy' it would be executed (at the end) when the command line was 'mvn deploy'. Perhaps even 'before-before-test' should be allowed as well? But not 'before-after-test', let's not go there! !-- Frank Gorham-Engard → Be kinder than necessary. Everyone you work with is fighting some kind of battle. -Original Message- From: Wim Deblauwe [mailto:wim.debla...@gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, July 13, 2010 5:10 AM To: Maven Users List Subject: Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between? Hi, I need to run the antrun plugin twice in the packaging phase. I found this on the wiki: http://docs.codehaus.org/display/MAVENUSER/MiniGuide-AntMultiPhase However, it speaks of different lifecycle phases. I tried with the same phase and that works, however, I need to run another plugin in between. Is this possible? I was hoping that all plugins' executions would be sorted by their id. That way, i could use id's like 'step-1-do-something', 'step-2-do-something-else', to force a certain order of plugin execution. regards, Wim
Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between?
Hi, I need to run the antrun plugin twice in the packaging phase. I found this on the wiki: http://docs.codehaus.org/display/MAVENUSER/MiniGuide-AntMultiPhase However, it speaks of different lifecycle phases. I tried with the same phase and that works, however, I need to run another plugin in between. Is this possible? I was hoping that all plugins' executions would be sorted by their id. That way, i could use id's like 'step-1-do-something', 'step-2-do-something-else', to force a certain order of plugin execution. regards, Wim
Re : Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between?
Hi, Have you tried the following configuration? build plugins plugin artifactIdmaven-antrun-plugin/artifactId executions execution idtask1/id phaseyourphase/phase configuration tasks !-- Some task -- /tasks /configuration goals goalrun/goal /goals /execution /executions /plugin plugin artifactIdyour middle plugin/artifactId executions execution idtask2/id phaseyourphase/phase configuration ... /configuration goals ... /goals /execution /executions /plugin plugin artifactIdmaven-antrun-plugin/artifactId executions execution idtask3/id phaseyourphase/phase configuration tasks !-- Some other task -- /tasks /configuration goals goalrun/goal /goals /execution /executions /plugin /plugins /build I have not tested so I'm not sure it will work. Regards, Julien - Message d'origine De : Wim Deblauwe wim.debla...@gmail.com À : Maven Users List users@maven.apache.org Envoyé le : Mar 13 juillet 2010, 11h 09min 36s Objet : Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between? Hi, I need to run the antrun plugin twice in the packaging phase. I found this on the wiki: http://docs.codehaus.org/display/MAVENUSER/MiniGuide-AntMultiPhase However, it speaks of different lifecycle phases. I tried with the same phase and that works, however, I need to run another plugin in between. Is this possible? I was hoping that all plugins' executions would be sorted by their id. That way, i could use id's like 'step-1-do-something', 'step-2-do-something-else', to force a certain order of plugin execution. regards, Wim - To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@maven.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@maven.apache.org
Re: Re : Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between?
Hi Julien, yes, I tried that too and it does not work. task1 does not get executed :( regards, Wim 2010/7/13 Julien HENRY henr...@yahoo.fr Hi, Have you tried the following configuration? build plugins plugin artifactIdmaven-antrun-plugin/artifactId executions execution idtask1/id phaseyourphase/phase configuration tasks !-- Some task -- /tasks /configuration goals goalrun/goal /goals /execution /executions /plugin plugin artifactIdyour middle plugin/artifactId executions execution idtask2/id phaseyourphase/phase configuration ... /configuration goals ... /goals /execution /executions /plugin plugin artifactIdmaven-antrun-plugin/artifactId executions execution idtask3/id phaseyourphase/phase configuration tasks !-- Some other task -- /tasks /configuration goals goalrun/goal /goals /execution /executions /plugin /plugins /build I have not tested so I'm not sure it will work. Regards, Julien - Message d'origine De : Wim Deblauwe wim.debla...@gmail.com À : Maven Users List users@maven.apache.org Envoyé le : Mar 13 juillet 2010, 11h 09min 36s Objet : Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between? Hi, I need to run the antrun plugin twice in the packaging phase. I found this on the wiki: http://docs.codehaus.org/display/MAVENUSER/MiniGuide-AntMultiPhase However, it speaks of different lifecycle phases. I tried with the same phase and that works, however, I need to run another plugin in between. Is this possible? I was hoping that all plugins' executions would be sorted by their id. That way, i could use id's like 'step-1-do-something', 'step-2-do-something-else', to force a certain order of plugin execution. regards, Wim - To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@maven.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@maven.apache.org
Re: Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between?
You can't do this. On 7/13/10 5:09 AM, Wim Deblauwe wrote: Hi, I need to run the antrun plugin twice in the packaging phase. I found this on the wiki: http://docs.codehaus.org/display/MAVENUSER/MiniGuide-AntMultiPhase However, it speaks of different lifecycle phases. I tried with the same phase and that works, however, I need to run another plugin in between. Is this possible? I was hoping that all plugins' executions would be sorted by their id. That way, i could use id's like 'step-1-do-something', 'step-2-do-something-else', to force a certain order of plugin execution. regards, Wim - To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@maven.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@maven.apache.org
Re: Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between?
However, it speaks of different lifecycle phases. I tried with the same phase and that works, however, I need to run another plugin in between. Is this possible? You could: release the maven-antrun-plugin under your own artifactId, say wim-antrun-plugin then use (in order): m-antrun-p, plugin2, w-antrun-p in your pom But this seems like a lot of extra work to me. Wayne - To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@maven.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@maven.apache.org
Re: Running antrun plugin twice in same phase with another plugin in between?
I had a look at the maven 2.2.x code and I created a small patch that does it. See http://jira.codehaus.org/browse/MNG-4727 All the patch does is sorting the 'MojoExecution' classes based on their id. It is very few lines of code really. It is a bit hackish as you need to use step- in your id/ declaration, but it works perfectly. I hope the maven devs will pick it up under some form or another. regards, Wim 2010/7/13 Wayne Fay wayne...@gmail.com However, it speaks of different lifecycle phases. I tried with the same phase and that works, however, I need to run another plugin in between. Is this possible? You could: release the maven-antrun-plugin under your own artifactId, say wim-antrun-plugin then use (in order): m-antrun-p, plugin2, w-antrun-p in your pom But this seems like a lot of extra work to me. Wayne - To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@maven.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@maven.apache.org
