Re: Why is slice module not depended on persistence-jdbc module
I suspect that one of Pinaki's design goals with Slice was to make it persistence personality agnostic. So one could use it with a JDO personality as well as a JPA personality (KODO provides both, OpenJPA provides the latter). Slice uses both openjpa-persistence and openjpa-persistence-jdbc for testing though (since no other personalities are available). I imagine if we beefed up the xml module or added a new personality it would be fairly easy for Slice to test with them as well. -mike On Mon, Jun 22, 2009 at 7:13 AM, Donald Woods wrote: > For runtime, Slice only needs access to the jdbc, kernel, and lib jars as > it is a BrokerFactory/JDBCProvider. It provides its own ProductDerivation > in - > src/main/java/org/apache/openjpa/slice/ProductDerivation.java > > For junit tests, it should only need to include openjpa-persistence for the > tests. If other tests are being added that need to use > openjpa-persistence-jdbc, then you should ask Pinaki to review your proposed > tests. > > > -Donald > > > > ashish paliwal wrote: > >> Hi, >> >> I wanted to know that why is slice module not depended on >> openjpa-persistence-jdbc module. I was trying to figure out the reason but >> could not get to anything conclusive. I felt that both persistence and >> persistence-jdbc module are central to design of openjpa and since there >> is >> dependency on persistence module why is there no dependency on >> persistence-jdbc module. >> >> I actually created a test case in slice module and that test case depended >> on whether JDBCProductDerivation gets loaded or not. Since, slice module >> has >> no dependency on persistence-jdbc moule, it doesn't gets loaded. If I move >> my test case to example module(which has dependency on persistence-jdbc) >> then test runs fine. >> >> It will be really helpful for me if someone can throw some kight on this. >> >> thanks and regards >> >>
Re: Why is slice module not depended on persistence-jdbc module
For runtime, Slice only needs access to the jdbc, kernel, and lib jars as it is a BrokerFactory/JDBCProvider. It provides its own ProductDerivation in - src/main/java/org/apache/openjpa/slice/ProductDerivation.java For junit tests, it should only need to include openjpa-persistence for the tests. If other tests are being added that need to use openjpa-persistence-jdbc, then you should ask Pinaki to review your proposed tests. -Donald ashish paliwal wrote: Hi, I wanted to know that why is slice module not depended on openjpa-persistence-jdbc module. I was trying to figure out the reason but could not get to anything conclusive. I felt that both persistence and persistence-jdbc module are central to design of openjpa and since there is dependency on persistence module why is there no dependency on persistence-jdbc module. I actually created a test case in slice module and that test case depended on whether JDBCProductDerivation gets loaded or not. Since, slice module has no dependency on persistence-jdbc moule, it doesn't gets loaded. If I move my test case to example module(which has dependency on persistence-jdbc) then test runs fine. It will be really helpful for me if someone can throw some kight on this. thanks and regards
Why is slice module not depended on persistence-jdbc module
Hi, I wanted to know that why is slice module not depended on openjpa-persistence-jdbc module. I was trying to figure out the reason but could not get to anything conclusive. I felt that both persistence and persistence-jdbc module are central to design of openjpa and since there is dependency on persistence module why is there no dependency on persistence-jdbc module. I actually created a test case in slice module and that test case depended on whether JDBCProductDerivation gets loaded or not. Since, slice module has no dependency on persistence-jdbc moule, it doesn't gets loaded. If I move my test case to example module(which has dependency on persistence-jdbc) then test runs fine. It will be really helpful for me if someone can throw some kight on this. thanks and regards -- Ashish Paliwal Mobile : 9305128367 IIT Kanpur India
