Re: Weston mirror/clone to 2 different displays
On Mon, Apr 29, 2024 at 08:55:31PM +, Dawn HOWE wrote: > Hello, Hi, > > I posted a question last year about mirroring/cloning to LVDS/hdmi on > an imx8, which is not supported by the display driver. This thread > suggests that a solution for this was being worked last June, but I > have not seen follow up on the topic since then. Is there any change > in the status? Yes, we landed that in Weston 13, but configuring was left out for the next version. That work is currently WIP at https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/wayland/weston/-/merge_requests/1476 > > thanks, > Dawn > > > > > From: Daniel Stone > Sent: Friday, June 23, 2023 10:04 AM > To: Dawn HOWE > Cc: wayland-devel@lists.freedesktop.org > Subject: Re: Weston mirror/clone to 2 different displays > > Hi Dawn, > > On Thu, 22 Jun 2023 at 18:09, Dawn HOWE > mailto:dawn.h...@alten.com>> wrote: > > I am developing an (embedded) medical device which is required to have a > touchscreen display and also mirror the output to a monitor connected via > HDMI. The device is using Wayland/Weston on TorizonCore (based on a yocto > kirkstone). I am able to get the display extended from HDMI to LVDS, but not > have the output mirrored to both displays. I posted a query on the Toradex > community, and received a response that Weston may not be capable of doing > this. > (https://community.toradex.com/t/apalis-imx8-hdmi-and-lvds-display-not-mirroring-cloning/19869<https://secure-web.cisco.com/1qqKzDdWiU1WxNx_1TpOWJ-iSI2TjeLkxdsz1u3dTzFUAeGjZk3MkNig_jPd-wds8_naYOU4DgHGNY7S5gLnEomhCtYlxT2Eq_al1fYRbeKRSy6zzqhyt1iWUudR9EUtgBcffrsaAYdXc5X-ECue_LMusWt5iDW39uJpx_bAgRNkx-7vl34qGXQMz4V6KIJS6HdH8-LWCtucb0DMPb8SaHi0jKOWYo_ilZwTPLgtTatbmhhZD_TF8OXfOHBJYHKfHyysh0zQW8jT61c3-RbCCa06qQJkILh2etzkUWkhLeDO4UylwQaODEYrF7V8_ArLvfggwPmbCOKSeiDdDdLEk3GQx7o0FkC7v-_Jse1glUkfG7zVY5-BW2_bQjH36tMFiyOk34qW5ZO-_0IUIrMJ2Er4uR6XMnq2G-Ckh9nqomzu6DACKXMIiSqUS2F3P5EBxyO2nobhtO21X8vdB4hnxNjLZ4zHyDYuKQlatrGSo8yKlCT5lLng4yp1ztU5uWBUHf4WGFju4oXblCQMR30Xa5g/https%3A%2F%2Fcommunity.toradex.com%2Ft%2Fapalis-imx8-hdmi-and-lvds-display-not-mirroring-cloning%2F19869>). > > > > I have searched and found some old posts from several years ago indicating > that it was not supported, but may be with a patch. I understand that > “same-as” configuration in weston.ini does not work for my scenario. > > > > What is the current state of cloning/mirroring to two different outputs, but > on the same card. E.g (card1-HDMI-A-1 and card1-LVDS-1): > > > ls /sys/class/drm > > card0 card1 card1-HDMI-A-1 card1-LVDS-1 renderD128 > renderD129 version > > Weston can currently mirror it if the display driver directly supports it. > You can use the same-as configuration option (see man weston-drm) to enable > this. If your display driver doesn't support this in the kernel, then Weston > won't do it for now, but we are actively working on this and expect to have a > branch capable of this within the next couple of weeks or so. > > Cheers, > Daniel > The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments are intended > solely for the addressees. If you have received this email in error, please > contact the sender and delete the email from your system. signature.asc Description: PGP signature
Re: Weston mirror/clone to 2 different displays
Hello, I posted a question last year about mirroring/cloning to LVDS/hdmi on an imx8, which is not supported by the display driver. This thread suggests that a solution for this was being worked last June, but I have not seen follow up on the topic since then. Is there any change in the status? thanks, Dawn From: Daniel Stone Sent: Friday, June 23, 2023 10:04 AM To: Dawn HOWE Cc: wayland-devel@lists.freedesktop.org Subject: Re: Weston mirror/clone to 2 different displays Hi Dawn, On Thu, 22 Jun 2023 at 18:09, Dawn HOWE mailto:dawn.h...@alten.com>> wrote: I am developing an (embedded) medical device which is required to have a touchscreen display and also mirror the output to a monitor connected via HDMI. The device is using Wayland/Weston on TorizonCore (based on a yocto kirkstone). I am able to get the display extended from HDMI to LVDS, but not have the output mirrored to both displays. I posted a query on the Toradex community, and received a response that Weston may not be capable of doing this. (https://community.toradex.com/t/apalis-imx8-hdmi-and-lvds-display-not-mirroring-cloning/19869<https://secure-web.cisco.com/1qqKzDdWiU1WxNx_1TpOWJ-iSI2TjeLkxdsz1u3dTzFUAeGjZk3MkNig_jPd-wds8_naYOU4DgHGNY7S5gLnEomhCtYlxT2Eq_al1fYRbeKRSy6zzqhyt1iWUudR9EUtgBcffrsaAYdXc5X-ECue_LMusWt5iDW39uJpx_bAgRNkx-7vl34qGXQMz4V6KIJS6HdH8-LWCtucb0DMPb8SaHi0jKOWYo_ilZwTPLgtTatbmhhZD_TF8OXfOHBJYHKfHyysh0zQW8jT61c3-RbCCa06qQJkILh2etzkUWkhLeDO4UylwQaODEYrF7V8_ArLvfggwPmbCOKSeiDdDdLEk3GQx7o0FkC7v-_Jse1glUkfG7zVY5-BW2_bQjH36tMFiyOk34qW5ZO-_0IUIrMJ2Er4uR6XMnq2G-Ckh9nqomzu6DACKXMIiSqUS2F3P5EBxyO2nobhtO21X8vdB4hnxNjLZ4zHyDYuKQlatrGSo8yKlCT5lLng4yp1ztU5uWBUHf4WGFju4oXblCQMR30Xa5g/https%3A%2F%2Fcommunity.toradex.com%2Ft%2Fapalis-imx8-hdmi-and-lvds-display-not-mirroring-cloning%2F19869>). I have searched and found some old posts from several years ago indicating that it was not supported, but may be with a patch. I understand that “same-as” configuration in weston.ini does not work for my scenario. What is the current state of cloning/mirroring to two different outputs, but on the same card. E.g (card1-HDMI-A-1 and card1-LVDS-1): ls /sys/class/drm card0 card1 card1-HDMI-A-1 card1-LVDS-1 renderD128 renderD129 version Weston can currently mirror it if the display driver directly supports it. You can use the same-as configuration option (see man weston-drm) to enable this. If your display driver doesn't support this in the kernel, then Weston won't do it for now, but we are actively working on this and expect to have a branch capable of this within the next couple of weeks or so. Cheers, Daniel The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments are intended solely for the addressees. If you have received this email in error, please contact the sender and delete the email from your system.
Re: Weston mirror/clone to 2 different displays
Hi Dawn, On Thu, 22 Jun 2023 at 18:09, Dawn HOWE wrote: > I am developing an (embedded) medical device which is required to have a > touchscreen display and also mirror the output to a monitor connected via > HDMI. The device is using Wayland/Weston on TorizonCore (based on a yocto > kirkstone). I am able to get the display extended from HDMI to LVDS, but > not have the output mirrored to both displays. I posted a query on the > Toradex community, and received a response that Weston may not be capable > of doing this. ( > https://community.toradex.com/t/apalis-imx8-hdmi-and-lvds-display-not-mirroring-cloning/19869 > ). > > > > I have searched and found some old posts from several years ago indicating > that it was not supported, but may be with a patch. I understand that > “same-as” configuration in weston.ini does not work for my scenario. > > > > What is the current state of cloning/mirroring to two different outputs, > but on the same card. E.g (card1-HDMI-A-1 and card1-LVDS-1): > > ls /sys/class/drm > > card0 card1 card1-HDMI-A-1 card1-LVDS-1 renderD128 > renderD129 version > Weston can currently mirror it if the display driver directly supports it. You can use the same-as configuration option (see man weston-drm) to enable this. If your display driver doesn't support this in the kernel, then Weston won't do it for now, but we are actively working on this and expect to have a branch capable of this within the next couple of weeks or so. Cheers, Daniel
