[ZESTCaste] Fwd: Screening of INDIA UNTOUCHED on 2nd October

2007-10-01 Thread Tarun Udwala
on the occasion of the 138th birth anniversary of Mahatma Gandhi
Nazariya Drishti-Natarani Film Club Presents
Stalin K's documentary film

INDIA UNTOUCHED - Stories of a People Apart
Winner of One Billion Eyes - Documentary Film Festival Award.
After six months traveling to Hyderabad, Pune, Chennai, Delhi, Mumbai
and Madurai, the film is coming back to Ahmedabad.

Date - 2nd October
Venue - Natarani, Usmanpura
Time - 8:15 pm

About India Untouched
108 minutes/Hindi, Bhojpuri, Gujarati, Punjabi, Tamil, Telugu,
Malayalm with English sub-titles.

This film is perhaps the most comprehensive look at Untouchability
ever undertaken on film. Director Stalin K. spent four years
traveling the length and breadth of the country to expose the
continued oppression of 'Dalits,' the 'broken people' who suffer under
a 4000 year-old religious system. The film introduces leading
Benares scholars who interpret Hindu scriptures to mean that Dalits
'have no right' to education, and Rajput farmers who proudly proclaim
that no Dalit may sit in their presence, and that the police must seek
their permission before pursuing cases of atrocities. The film
captures many 'firsts-on-film, ' such as Dalits being forced to
dismount from their cycles and remove their shoes when in the upper
caste part of the village. It exposes the continuation of caste
practices and Untouchability in Sikhism, Christianity and Islam, and
even amongst the communists in Kerala. Dalits themselves are not let
off the hook: within Dalits, sub-castes practice Untouchability on the
'lower' sub-castes, and a Harijan boy refuses to drink water from a
Valmiki boy. The viewer hears that Untouchability is an urban
phenomenon as well, inflicted upon a leading medical surgeon and in
such hallowed institutions as JNU, where a Brahmin boy builds a
partition so as not to look upon his Dalit roommate in the early
morning. A section on how newspaper matrimonial columns are divided
according to caste presents urban Indians with an uncomfortable truth:
marriage is the leading perpetuator of caste in India. But the film
highlights signs of hope, too: the powerful tradition of Dalit
drumming is used to call people to the struggle, and a young Dalit
girl holds her head high after pulling water from her village well for
the first time in her life.

Spanning eight states and four religions, this film will make it
impossible for anyone to deny that Untouchability continues to be
practiced in India.

Stalin K: Stalin K. is a human rights activist and award-winning
documentary filmmaker. In recent years, he has become known for his
pioneering 'participatory media' work with urban and rural
communities, in which local people produce their own videos and radio
programs as an empowerment tool. He is the Co-Founder of DRISHTI-
Media, Arts and Human Rights, Convener of the Community Radio
Forum-India, and the India Director of Video Volunteers. He is a
renowned public speaker and has lectured or taught at over 20
institutions ranging from the National Institute of Design and the
Tata Institute of Social Sciences in India, to New York University and
Stanford and Berkeley in the US.


[ZESTCaste] �Secularism has become another religion�

2007-10-01 Thread MN sanil
http://www.tehelka.com/story_main34.asp?filename=Ne061007SECULARISM.asp
   
CURRENT AFFAIRS   eminences 
 
‘Secularism has become another religion’

French Marxist philosopher Étienne Balibar was in New Delhi last week for a 
series of lectures 

Étienne Balibar is a Marxist philosopher who is critical of hardline French 
secularists for their xenophobic intolerance of issues concerning French 
citizens of Arab and African descent. In the 2007 French presidential election, 
he was among the two hundred intellectuals who expressed support for the 
candidature of Marie-Ségolène Royal of the Socialist Party. Professor Emeritus 
of Moral and Political Philosophy at Université de Paris X – Nanterre, and 
Distinguished Professor of Humanities at the University of California, Irvine, 
Balibar gave a series of lectures in New Delhi last week. S. Anand of TEHELKA 
joins Nivedita Menon, Reader in Political Science at the University of Delhi, 
and Aditya Nigam, Fellow at the Centre for Study of Developing Societies, in 
discussing with Balibar the overlap of racism, Islamophobia and secularism in a 
global context.

Menon: You have written about the race riots in 2005 in the French banlieues, 
the suburbs, as a ‘revolt of the excluded’ and have linked it to the 
contradictions of globalisation. What were the dynamics of these riots?
Balibar: I am surprised these events provoke such curiosity in places as far 
away as Chicago and New Delhi since I think these riots were extremely banal in 
the sense that they are a type of urban disorder that has repeatedly taken 
place all over the world for a long period, owing to similar issues of 
“difference”. Perhaps the French were exceptional in thinking that the typical 
effects of the redistribution of populations created by globalisation, 
involving race and class factors, would not affect France. There’s also been 
extreme reluctance on the part of French commentators, not only of the Right 
but also the Left, to use race and racial categories. 

In France we have been trained to understand politics - whether secular 
ideologies, parliamentary politics, or social movements and campaigns - in 
universalistic terms. I don’t say this tradition is completely over, that 
there’s nothing left of it. But this tradition has been forced to reckon with 
the wrongs of French colonialism. The French citizens of African descent, the 
inner-city youth, formed a group in February 2005 calling themselves Indigènes 
de la République—Natives of the Republic. They were the children and 
grandchildren of colonialism, French-born youths of Arab and African 
extraction, who viewed the consequences of colonialism as anything but 
positive. This nomenclature is ironic since the word ‘native’ was used in the 
colonies to refer to the subject-race while the French referred to themselves 
as citizens. By claiming to be “natives” of the “republic”, they are 
underlining the fact that the colony is now inside the republic - the 
neighbourhoods where the French Muslims are like colonial enclaves. 

Natives of the Republic assert their “difference” against a perspective based 
on civic and national integration. But the French Interior Minister [Nicolas] 
Sarkozy, now the president, saw Islam as a challenge to French citizenship. 

But these youth do still have faith in French democracy. For instance, when a 
group of rap artistes and others made a public intervention urging the rioters 
to re-direct their legitimate anger by registering as voters, I thought it was 
a naive suggestion. But in fact they did register in large numbers, and in the 
recent elections, the Left won massive majorities in the violence-affected 
banlieues.

Anand: Did the violence during the ‘riots’ justify the kind of global attention 
it received?
Balibar: These are events that somehow illustrate the very different conditions 
in which politics is taking place in the contemporary world. The youngsters 
involved in the three-week ‘uprising’ (a term the French intelligentsia is 
loathe to use), fought against their relegation to territories where republican 
equality did not reach - they did not contest the principles of French 
citizenship. They claimed their legitimate place within it. In this sense it 
was a revolt of the excluded, if not a ‘molecular civil war’. It is necessary 
first of all to ask whether this violence was spontaneous or, to the contrary, 
provoked, even deliberately planned.… 

Menon: You have written about the media as “passive organizers” of social 
movements. In India too, the mainstream media has the monopoly over 
representing events in the public arena, thus shaping public perceptions of 
events as well sometimes, the events themselves. What was the role of the media 
during these events in France?
Balibar: Yes, I have said that the media play the role of the passive 
organiser. The riots, the burning of cars, was magnified in the media. Contrary 
to what television coverage suggested, this highly 

[ZESTCaste] Here, every village is a 'Khairlanji' today

2007-10-01 Thread Shivam Vij
Here, every village is a 'Khairlanji' today

By Jaideep Hardikar
Bhandara and Gondia, Sept 28:
http://beyondmargins.blogspot.com/2007/09/here-every-village-is-khairlanji-today.html

There is a palpable tension in the dalit basti of Pimpalgaon Kohali
village, some 80 km from Bhandara in Lakhandur tehsil. The village is
going in for panchayat election, and 'caste-card' is in play once
more. Or leaders would ensure it does.

This year our basti had to buy two tractors to complete 'our' work in
the fields, because 'they' refused to lend us theirs, reveals Sumedh
Lade, a neo-Buddhist (Mahars who have embraced Buddhism). Earlier this
year, every Ambedkarite – the neo-Buddhists or converted dalits, as
they are called here – in his village faced social and economic
boycott.

We were not allowed to shop; we were not offered any work, says
Bhaiyyalal Motghare, a villager. The entire basti was erased from the
BPL list (below poverty line), but we fought to bring back our names
into it, he informs. Things have eased a bit off late, but only just.
We know it's all superficial; a small trigger is enough.

The village saw the dominant castes turned against the Ambedkarites,
when one of the farmers from the latter registered a case under
Prevention of Atrocities Act against a farmer from the former
community during a village get-together. The matter was trivial, say
villagers, but local leaders blew it up. Result: the tension triggered
the rift, followed by complete isolation and boycott of the Buddhists.

Pimpalgaon is a sample of what's happened – and is happening – across
the rural Vidarbha, particularly in Bhandara and Gondia districts,
exactly a year after four members of Bhotmange family were brutally
killed in Khairlanji sparking a wave of violent protests in
Maharashtra. Today, it's they versus us; but Buddhists are
isolated, ostracized and living in fear and insecurity in village unto
villages.

You can see the reflection of this polarization and total isolation
of Buddhists in village elections, notes Vinod Thakre, a BJP worker
in Lakhandur, Bhandara. It's a stark reminder that the caste divide is
a reality, but in the absence of any reconciliatory efforts on either
side, it's growing worse for the Buddhists.

Every small incident, charges Bhandara ZP member Vasant Einchilwar, is
given a caste colour and tagged as a case of atrocity by the small
time leaders. Threats by the dalit activists have become common that
they'll slap an atrocity case even if the matter is trivial and could
be resolved at village-level, he says. On the other hand, politicians
from dominant castes exploit the situation to consolidate their base,
by antagonizing the impoverished people of Buddhist community.

This, coupled with fiery speeches and statements by the Republican
leaders from outside, has fuelling the caste division farther,
Einchilwar suggests. This past year has seen a spurt in the atrocity
cases, though many were actually very trivial and personal issues,
says a senior police officer in Bhandara. If there was any chance of
reconciliation, political class ensured the tension remained. Yet, he
admits that the genuine Atrocity cases fall apart due to pressure from
the leaders of the dominant political class. Anger against Buddhists
is growing.

Nobody opposes the installation of Babasaheb Ambedkar's statues in
villages, but there will be reaction if their leaders publicly
humiliate us and our religious sentiments. This is what has happened
over the last one year during such events in and around Bhandara,
vitiating the village harmony, says deputy sarpanch of Pimpalgaon
Ramchandra Parshuramkar. Agriculture work suffered due to it.

Ostensibly, the exchange and interaction between the Buddhists and
dominant castes in villages has stopped. In Surewada, a teacher from
OBC community sprinkled cow-urine on dalit students to purify them six
months ago. The teacher was transferred, but the incident further
antagonized the Buddhist community.

The matter is serious. Every village is a Khairlanji today, warns a
senior police officer. While the four members of Bhotmange family
were hacked to death in one stroke, the poor Buddhists would die a
slow death everyday, being isolated and ostracized, he fears, in view
of the alarming social fallout.

Last month, an engineering student was denied accommodation by the
landlord because he was an Ambedkarite, says Gondia-based journalist
Kishor Borkar.

Adds Rajendra Gajbhiye of Dhusala: Our community farmers did not get
farm labourers this year, and Buddhist labourers didn't get work from
dominant and upper caste farmers. Denied work, Buddhist farmers and
farm labourers from Bhawal village in Bhandara, for instance, migrated
to Dhusala where they got work from the landed farmers of their
community. Migration shot up this year.

One year of protest, hatred, isolation and riots hasn't resulted in
any benefit or economic empowerment of dalits, including the more
organized neo-Buddhists.

The naxal 

[ZESTCaste] Mala employees to fight ‘victimisation’

2007-10-01 Thread Tarun Udwala
http://www.siasat.com/english/index.php?option=contenttask=viewid=210855Itemid=63cattitle=Andhra%20Pradesh


Mala employees to fight 'victimisation'

Monday, 01 October 2007

Kadapa, October 01: Mala Mahanadu formed Mala Employees Association on
Sunday to protect the interests of employees of the community in the
movement against classification of Scheduled Castes, Mala Mahanadu
State general secretary J.V. Ramana said on Sunday.

Political forces were dividing SCs in order to bring about disunity
and employees of Mala community were being victimised by their Madiga
counterparts, Mr. Ramana alleged at a meeting here. Those demanding
classification of SCs should foresee the threat of foregoing their
constitutional rights, he cautioned. He charged political leaders with
usurping crores of rupees earmarked for uplift of SCs.

Administration's indifference to recognise Dalits in cases of
atrocities against SC/STs and reluctance to issue caste certificates
to genuine Dalits posed problems, he said. He alleged victimisation of
Mala employees in the Treasury Department, suspensions, cut in
increments and stoppage of promotions at the behest of Madiga
employees.

Madiga community should realise their folly in demanding
classification of SCs, Mala Mahanadu district president R.
Ramachandraiah said. Officials and upper castes subjected SCs to
attacks and they would be countered, he said.

Mala Employees Association district president D. Satyanand Babu
announced election of a 39-member body for the association with K.
Suresh Babu as working president, seven vice-presidents, six general
secretaries, seven secretaries, four organising secretaries, five
joint secretaries, a treasurer and six honorary advisors.

--Agencies


[ZESTCaste] Dalit students battle prejudice and violence

2007-10-01 Thread Tarun Udwala
http://koyatoor.blogspot.com/2007/09/dalit-students-battle-prejudice-and.html


Sunday, September 30, 2007
Dalit students battle prejudice and violence

Times of India

Siddarth Varadarajan


NEW DELHI: Vikram Ram, a Dalit student at the UniversityCollege of
Medical Sciences (UCMS) in east Delhi, got a rudeshock when he sat
down for his first meal at the hostel mess.``Bloody Shaddu'', he was
told fiercely by a group of upper castestudents (using an abusive term
for Scheduled Castes), ``youcannot eat with us''. Hurt and bewildered,
he made his way to therow of tables where the Dalit students normally
sit.

According to the Dalit students, even the hostel has de factobeen
ghettoised, with most of them on two floors. When RakeshKumar, an SC
student, was assigned a room elsewhere, aneighbour said: ``We will not
let you stay here, Shaddu. Yourkind of person cleans our toilets.''
Faced with the prospect ofconstant harassment, he asked to be shifted.


When this reporter asked some upper caste boys at UCMSabout the term
`Shaddu', they denied the word was ever used,except during arguments.
After some prodding, one student,Anand Bakshi, said: ``It is only a
pet name.''As for separate dining and living areas, the upper caste
studentsthis reporter spoke to say there is no such policy. ``If at
all theyeat and live together'', said Sudhir Kathuria, ``it is because
theylike sticking to their own community''.

Today, Vikram, Rakesh and several other Dalit students are ondharna.
After years of discrimination, they say they have hadenough. The last
straw was the violent attack on them by someupper caste students on
February 22. UCMS authorities insist itwas a run-of-the-mill fight
between students but the fact is severalDalits were badly beaten. The
hostel PA system was used to asall `general category' students to
assemble.

The turban of DrJaswant Singh, a gentle, small-built Dalit, was pulled
off and hewas punched and kicked. Another Dalit intern, Balwinder
Bhatti,hid himself but the mob ransacked his room.When this reporter
went to talk to the Dalit students, they weresuspicious. It was only
gradually that their complaints poured out.Stubbornly, reluctantly.
More than anything, it is the perceiveddiscrimination from the faculty
that rankles. A tall, intensetwenty-something, Vikram had topped his
school and had neverbefore experienced casteism. ``My parents say
`thoda seh lo;but become a doctor at any cost','' he said, wistfully
twisting hisstethoscope this way and that.The son of a driver, Vikram
hasn't graduated despite being atUCMS for eight years. Like many SC
students, he has frequentlybeen made to repeat exams.

If the intake of reserved students is22, only four graduate on
time.``We study as hard as anyone else but it is the faculty's
casteismwhich is holding us back,'' said a Dalit student. Ram Das, a
finalyear student, had just appeared in an exam. ``The first
questionthe examiner asked was `Are you a bania?'.

When I said no, hesaid `Then what? Are you from reserved category?
What is yourcaste?'.``If an exam begins like this'', said Ram, ``we
get demoralised,nervous. How are we supposed to cope?''

(The names of the students have been changed.)


[ZESTCaste] Dalit+OBC is Maya’s formula for Chhattisgarh (News)

2007-10-01 Thread Tarun Udwala
http://www.indianexpress.com/story/222926.html

Dalit+OBC is Maya's formula for Chhattisgarh

Nitin Mahajan
Posted online: Monday, October 01, 2007 at  hrs IST
RAIPUR, SEPTEMBER 30
After successfully wooing Brahmins in Uttar Pradesh, the Bahujan Samaj
Party (BSP) in Chhattisgarh has decided to engineer a social pact with
OBCs and Scheduled Castes to make inroads into the state polity.
The state unit of the BSP is preparing to replicate Uttar Pradesh's
social engineering experiment in the 2008 Assembly polls through an
alliance with SCs and OBCs.
Chhattisgarh BSP President Dau Ram Ratnakar said the party was
confident that the alliance would succeed. The party has decided to
contest all 90 Assembly seats in next year's polls, he said.
As OBCs are a majority in the state, comprising mostly Sahus and
Kurmis, an alliance of Dalits and OBCs will be an advantage for us in
next year's Assembly polls, Ratnakar added. With the total population
comprising 52 per cent OBCs and 22.3 per cent SCs, the party is
hopeful that the alliance will be invincible.
To bring OBCs into the party fold, bhaichara committees have been
launched by the BSP in each of the parliamentary constituencies. The
committees have been entrusted with the task of organising
constituency-level contact programmes for these communities, he said.
In the last Chhattisgarh Assembly polls held in 2003, the party had
contested 52 seats out of which it secured 2. However, polling on one
of these seats — Malkharauda — was annulled by the High Court and a
bypoll held for the seat was won by the BJP. The BSP in the last
Assembly elections had secured a total vote share of 5 per cent by
contesting on 52 seats. The party hopes to improve the vote share
significantly once the alliance of the two castes is established.
Party sources pointed out that upper castes only constitute about 4
per cent of the total population here, but the state has always been
governed by them. Once an alliance between OBCs and Dalits is
achieved, along with some upper caste leaders coming into the party
fold, the state BSP hopes to make significant gains in next year's
Assembly polls.
As part of the party's strategy to woo the community, several OBC
ministers from Uttar Pradesh will address mass rallies in various
parts of the state. Also, the charge of Chhattisgarh has been handed
over by the national leadership over to OBC leader Sewak Ram Sahu to
prepare for next year's Assembly polls.


--
Subscribe to ZESTCaste by sending a BLANK email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] OR, if you 
have a Yahoo! ID, by visiting http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTCaste/join 
Yahoo! Groups Links

* To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTCaste/

* Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional

* To change settings online go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTCaste/join
(Yahoo! ID required)

* To change settings via email:
mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

* To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

* Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 


[ZESTCaste] Are Madigas Behind Chiranjeevi?

2007-10-01 Thread Tarun Udwala
http://www.humsurfer.com/view/are-madigas-behind-chiranjeevi

Monday, October 1, 2007
Are Madigas Behind Chiranjeevi?


Are madigas behind Chiranjeevi? This impression is rising as Manda
Krishna Madiga's cutout was placed along with Chiranjeevi and Ram
Charan in Machilipatnam region. How Krishna Madiga is connected with
Chiranjeevi and the film? There is nothing, but the impressions are
making rounds that the community is behind Chiranjeevi. It is true
that Chiranjeevi is being considered the man of all now. This
certainly wouldn't continue if he starts a party for himself.
Chiranjeevi is worried only in that aspect.

The first thing that happens to Chiranjeevi if he starts a new party
is income tax ride by present government to threaten him. The next
thing is lack of majority in elections as TDP would give tight
competition. The next thing is chances for Congress to form government
again as opposite votes would split into two between TDP and
Chiranjeevi's party. The other thing is Chiranjeevi getting new set of
enemies for the rest of his life. So, under these circumstances can
Chiranjeevi dare to start a party?

October 2nd is falling tomorrow. There was gossip that Chiranjeevi
will be announcing his new party on the occasion of this Gandhi
Jayanthi. But will he do that? There are no signals till now.


[ZESTCaste] BSP MLA shielding murderers of a dalit youth (News)

2007-10-01 Thread Tarun Udwala
http://www.asiantribune.com/index.php?q=node/7594

BSP MLA shielding murderers of a dalit youth
Mon, 2007-10-01 03:02
By Bobby Ramakant

Mayawati led Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) has been trumpeting the welfare
of dalits, but in UP state of India where they are in power, one of
their own Member of Legislative Assembly (MLA) is allegedly shielding
the murderers of a dalit youth.

On the fateful morning of 1 August 2007, a dalit youth Chakrasen was
brutally assaulted by two upper-caste men and murdered in Bhadevra
village of Pratapgarh district, about 200 kilometres away from the
state capital Lucknow.

Ram Shiromani Shukla, local Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) MLA, has been
protecting the accused.

On 30 September 2007, a fact-finding team went to this village in the
morning, led by Magsaysay awardee (2002) and head of National Alliance
of People's Movements (NAPM) Dr Sandeep Pandey, retired Inspector
General of Police SR Darapuri, and Dynamic Action Group activists
Gyan, Sujit and Ram Kumar to strengthen community's voices for
justice.

Ironically this is yet another blot on BSP's claim to champion
dalit's welfare in UP with BSP MLA and party workers shielding the
alleged murderers of a talented dalit youth said Dr Sandeep Pandey.

The deceased Chakrasen graduated from Allahabad University this year
and had qualified for the State-level Engineering Entrance
Examination. He came to the village a day before he was murdered, to
meet his family before joining the Engineering College.

On the ill-fated day of 1 August 2007, when he went out in the
morning, Santosh Mishra and Akash Dubey allegedly started battering
him. Chakrasen tried to escape to the nearby village Sudemau but
Santosh and Akash followed him shouting 'thief'. In response to the
false 'thief' alarm, some people from the Pasi community caught hold
of Chakrasen. He was then tied up with a thick rope, beaten
mercilessly, dragged, eyes were gouged with needles and beaten with
rods and strangulated to death. Chakrasen's eyes held dreams of
college and career. They didn't just kill him. They first punished him
by smashing the eye that dared to dream of education.

Santosh Mishra is a BSP party worker and close associate of Ram
Shiromani Shukla, the local BSP MLA.

On 11 August 2007, a fact-finding team of DAG members went to the
said-villages, and met the members of the family as well as other
villagers. Till then none of the assailants had been arrested.

Surprisingly the role of BSP MLA was not protective towards the dalit
community but instead BSP MLA kept the murderers in his protection and
had pressurized the local administration not to arrest them. Dalit
family members too were being threatened by BSP members to keep
silent.

The dreams to live with dignity fostered by dalits in the wake of the
recent landslide victory for BSP in UP, are being thwarted by such
unfortunate incidents.

Chakrasen's grandfather Shiv Murat was distributing ration and
kerosene in the village. Santosh and Akash made illegal demands for
ration and kerosene. Chakrasen reportedly didn't allow them to take
more ration or kerosene than the allotted quota. Santosh and Akash
often used to fight with bhaiya for this, says his youngest brother
Shaktisen. The family says they got even more upset when he got
admission to the engineering college.

One of the two accused, Santosh Mishra had threatened Shiv Murat by
life. Shivmurat reported this death-threat to the local police 'thana'
10 months back but police did not pay any heed to it.

Role of police in this case has been very dubious. When Chakrasen was
being beaten brutally, the village pradhan Rammani Vishwakarma tried
to call the police three times but all calls fell on deaf ears.
Although the murder took place at about 6am on 1 August, the police
registered a first information report (FIR) only at 7pm of that
evening, due to mounting pressure from outraged villagers. The police
first lodged the report under Section 304 i.e. culpable homicide not
amounting to murder. It was only two days later, that section 302 was
added.

The police neither allowed the family of Chakrasen nor the villagers
to go near the dead body. They took the dead body into their custody
after reaching the spot. Panchnama was also not done. The family
members of the deceased were called to the police station but the dead
body was sent for post mortem before they could reach the police
station.

The family members of Chakrasen allege that the local police is trying
to shield the accused and deliberately trying to weaken the case. For
instance, police named Matadin as one of the main accused, who had
died four years ago!

The two main accused, Santosh and Akash, were arrested earlier on
direct orders of Superintendent of Police, but later released on bail.
After coming out on bail they had again beaten up the family members
of Chakrasen.

Let's hope dalit voices for justice are held in the current corridors
of power in UP assembly and justice meted out at the 

[ZESTCaste] Periyar An Iconoclast and a Reformer

2007-10-01 Thread Tarun Udwala
http://www.chowk.com/articles/12637

Periyar An Iconoclast and a Reformer
Shantanu Dutta September 20, 2007

I woke up to the news that in an apparent reaction to Tamil Nadu Chief
Minister M Karunanidhi's statements on Lord Rama and the Ramar Sethu
controversy, miscreants pelted stones and hurled petrol bombs at his
daughter's house near Ragigudda in J P Nagar. The Tamil Nadu CM had of
course taken someheat of Sonia Gandhi and Man Mohan Singh by boldly
claiming there was no historic proof of Lord Ram's existence. There
was also no proof of Lord Ram having constructed a bridge and being an
expert in engineering, he told a TV channel. It is one thing for an
Italian born Sonia Gandhi and a Sikh Prime Minister to make such
inflammatory statements and another thing for a born son of the soil
Hindu to say so, albeit a rationalist and atheist.

But the man who first said such things and more was not the current
Dravidian Patriarch, Karunanidhi, but the original founder patriarch
of the Dravidian movement, EVR Ramasami popularly known as Periyar.
His birth anniversary was on the 17th September, just two days ago and
unlike another social reformer, Vinoba Bhave, Periyar got his garlands
and tributes. He remains an iconic figure in Tamil Nadu and unlike the
Congress which seems to have completely abandoned its Gandhian legacy,
as long people of Karunaninidhi's generation are active at least the
legacy of EVR is safe.

The first time that I had heard of Periyar was in the context of the
Ravana Leelas that he and his organization, the DK used to conduct.
This was as an answer to Ram Leela conducted in North. They would
carry pictures of Hindu Gods garlanded with slippers and depict Hindu
mythologies in obscene manner. In my childhood, I used to watch the
Ram Leela but trying to imagine what the Ravana Leela might be like
where the hero turned villain was exciting. Fortunately or
unfortunately now the performances have now stopped having made their
point about the trampling of the Dravidian identity by the Aryan one.

But Periyar's contribution was far more than the eccentric and perhaps
even offensive Ravana Leelas. He was initially a Congressman inducted
into the party by Acharya Vinoba Bhave, C Rajagopalachari, Gandhiji
and others. He passionately espoused Gandhian ideals, such as the use
of khadi. However, he soon became disenchanted with the Congress and
its indecisive ways when he brings up the issue of eliminating caste
discrimination The Self-Respect Movement, founded by him in 1925,
carried on a vigorous and ceaseless propaganda against ridiculous and
harmful superstitions, traditions, customs and habits. He wanted to
dispel the ignorance of the people and make them enlightened. He
exhorted them to take steps to change the institutions and values that
led to meaningless divisions and unjust discrimination. He advised
them to change according to the requirements of the changing times and
keep pace with the modern conditions.

Self-respecters performed marriages without Brahmin priests (purohits)
and without religious rites. They insisted on equality between men and
women in all walks of life. They encouraged inter-caste and widow
marriages. Periyar propagated the need for birth-control even from
late 1920s. He gathered support for lawful abolition of Devadasi
(temple prostitute) system and the practice of child marriage.

In a sense Periyar and Gandhiji were contemporaries. Gandhiji was born
in 1869 and Periyar in 1879. In many aspects they did or stood for
similar things. But there were significant differences. Gandhiji's
movement was deeply and irrevocably rooted in Hinduism, even if it was
a kind of Hinduism that satisfied nobody. It did not satisfy the likes
of Jinnah, who still thought of the Congress as a Hindu party and it
of course did not satisfy the likes of Nathuram Godse and who thought
that Gandhiji's Hinduism wasn't pure enough. Gandhiji did a lot to
remove untouchability and was active in agitations like the temple
entry movement but his stance on caste was ambivalent which made first
EVR and later Dr. Ambedkar part ways with him.

Some day it would be worthwhile to study the distance that both Dr.
Ambedkar and Periyar covered in their journey away from Gandhi. Both
were clear that the solution to the caste problem was not to be found
within the boundaries of Hinduism but whereas Dr. Ambedkar found his
answers in Buddhism, Periyar felt the answer lay in humanism and going
down that route, he became progressively an atheist and a rationalist.
I am not an atheist and believe that religion and a longing for God is
firmly and deeply embedded in the racial memory of men and women
because God created them in His image.

But nevertheless, the anguish and pathos of Periyar in describing his
experience as he looked at the dehumanization of life and God
seemingly silent is best captured in his own words  Men should not
touch each other, see each other; and cannot enter temples, fetch
water from the