On 15 May 2004, at 01:21, Jack Campin wrote:
A cautionary note here - how _would_ your parser behave on discovering
it was asked to parse one of these 'illegal' constructs?
I'm in agreement with the point you're making but not with any of your
examples...
there is a significant number of existing
> A cautionary note here - how _would_ your parser behave on discovering
> it was asked to parse one of these 'illegal' constructs?
I'm in agreement with the point you're making but not with any of your
examples...
> there is a significant number of existing tune files (with hundreds
> of tunes
been lurking for a while, but following this with interest.
A cautionary note here - how _would_ your parser behave on discovering
it was asked to parse
one of these 'illegal' constructs? I've been very busy lately loosening
up Skink's parser based
on discovering that there is a significant numb
Jack Campin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
That's a standard rule of music. You can't put black and white
notes
on the same stem for instance.
||| Actually, this isn't a rule at all. Music printers routinely
||| put
||| white and black note heads on the same stem.
|| I quote Gardner
>>> That's a standard rule of music. You can't put black and white notes
>>> on the same stem for instance.
>> Actually, this isn't a rule at all. Music printers routinely put
>> white and black note heads on the same stem.
> I quote Gardner Read "Music Notation" page 69 "Intervals (involving
On 14 May 2004, at 07:56, Martin Tarenskeen wrote:
I'm a user of MUP. There was a similar discussion some time ago about
this
subject in the mup-users mailing list. Just like in abc in mup the
notes
in a chord have to be of the same length, or else be in different
voice.
Notes in a chord don't
On Fri, 14 May 2004, David Webber wrote:
> From: "John Chambers" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>
> > Actually, Gardner Read is the one who's mistaken here. ;-)
> Musicians
> > can and do play chords on several instruments with notes
> terminating
> Gardner and Bernard are quite correct, and with good rea
From: "John Chambers" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> Actually, Gardner Read is the one who's mistaken here. ;-)
Musicians
> can and do play chords on several instruments with notes
terminating
> at different times. Publishers can and do print music with note
heads
> of different lengths on the same stem.
In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, John Chambers
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes
Bernard Hill writes:
| In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, John Chambers
| <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes
| >Bernard Hill writes:
| >| That's a standard rule of music. You can't put black and white notes on
| >| the same stem for ins
Bernard Hill writes:
| In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, John Chambers
| <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes
| >Bernard Hill writes:
| >| That's a standard rule of music. You can't put black and white notes on
| >| the same stem for instance.
| >
| >Actually, this isn't a rule at all. Music printers routi
In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, John Chambers
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes
Bernard Hill writes:
| In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Neil
| Jennings <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes
| >Or, perhaps, by having a note object contain a list of (zero or
| >more) pitch objects rather than just one pitch va
All this is pretty much irrelevant. Within a polyphonic voice, notes are
not necessarily related to other simultaneous notes by any of start time,
end time or duration, therefore trying to put more than one pitch on a note
object is not a solution.
At 02:08 AM 5/13/04, you wrote:
Bernard Hill w
Bernard Hill writes:
| In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Neil
| Jennings <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes
| >Or, perhaps, by having a note object contain a list of (zero or
| >more) pitch objects rather than just one pitch value. A noteobject
| >with a duration and no pitch objects would, of co
In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Neil
Jennings <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes
At 08:21 AM 5/9/04, you wrote:
Or, perhaps, by having a note object contain a list of (zero or
more) pitch objects rather than just one pitch value. A noteobject
with a duration and no pitch objects would, of co
At 08:21 AM 5/9/04, you wrote:
Or, perhaps, by having a note object contain a list of (zero or
more) pitch objects rather than just one pitch value. A noteobject with
a duration and no pitch objects would, of course, be a rest.
The problem with this is that the duration would be the
At 07:34 AM 5/5/04 +0100, Neil Jennings wrote:
Output format:
My program HARMONY has a set of classes which I would be prepared to offer
as a starting point for discussion (but they are in VB at present).
It has a TUNE class, VOICE class and NOTE class
A TUNE can hold a number of VOICES
A Voice c
16 matches
Mail list logo
