Re: [agi] A possible less ass-backward way of computing naive bayesian conditional probabilities

2008-02-25 Thread Mike Dougherty
On Mon, Feb 25, 2008 at 2:51 PM, Ed Porter <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > But that does stop people from modeling systems in a simplified manner by > acting as if these limitations were met. Naïve Bayesian methods are > commonly used. I have read multiple papers saying that in many cases it >

RE: [agi] would anyone want to use a commonsense KB?

2008-02-25 Thread Ed Porter
Ben, Thanks for the info. If you knew of anything relatively simple that was on-line that would be preferred. But, if not, I guess I could try to Google for something myself. (Of if I wait long enough there probably will be a simple Wikipedia explanation.) Ed Porter -Original Message---

RE: [agi] A possible less ass-backward way of computing naive bayesian conditional probabilities

2008-02-25 Thread Ed Porter
Vlad, (1) You are correct that naïve Bayes assumes "not just conditional independence of Ei on hypothesis, that is P(Ei|Ej,H)=P(Ei|H), but also mutual independence of Ei, that is P(E1,...,En)=P(E1)*...*P(En).:" That is a major limitation, one often not met in reality. But that does stop people f

Re: [agi] A possible less ass-backward way of computing naive bayesian conditional probabilities

2008-02-25 Thread Vladimir Nesov
On Mon, Feb 25, 2008 at 8:18 PM, Ed Porter <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > As you all know the Naïve Bayes formula for the conditional probability of H > given evidence E1, E2,...EN is > > p(H|E1,E2,...EN) = p(H) * p(E1|H)/p(E1) * p(E2|H)/p(E2) *...* > p(EN|H)/p(EN) Hi Ed, This variant is

[agi] A possible less ass-backward way of computing naive bayesian conditional probabilities

2008-02-25 Thread Ed Porter
Last night in bed I came upon what seems to me like a new and at times useful way to compute naïve Bayesian conditional probabilities. But since I have never seen it before, and since as I get older I often overlook things, I though I would share it with those on this list to see (A) if my math co