On Mon, 12 Nov 2012, Ed Murphy wrote:
> Kolja wrote:
>
> > Wouldn't that mean that appeals are always judged by a panel biased
> > against the original judgement?
>
> That's not what "favor/disfavor" mean; they mean "I do/don't want this
> case assigned to me", regardless of how they would judg
Kolja wrote:
Wouldn't that mean that appeals are always judged by a panel biased
against the original judgement?
That's not what "favor/disfavor" mean; they mean "I do/don't want this
case assigned to me", regardless of how they would judge it if it was.
Wouldn't that mean that appeals are always judged by a panel biased against the
original judgement?
I don't like that for several reasons:
- generally, designing bias into judge selection doesn't rhyme with my real
likfe understanding of justice as a neutral decision maker
- seems to make it ha
3 matches
Mail list logo
