[android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-13 Thread michael
Dipu, > For > example I took a picture of a globe and edited the image and put it as > an app icon. Strictly speaking that could be a problem unless the original globe image is available to you under some free license. I was in the exact same situation, wanting a globe image for one of my app ico

[android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-12 Thread Piotr Buła
It doesn't matter if the patent could stand up in court or not. Defending would cost you thousands of dollars. And if you're an indie dev, you're pretty much defenseless. Patents (and especially software patents) have long lost their original purpose of protecting inventors and became a tool for de

[android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-12 Thread Indicator Veritatis
I can understand his reluctance to face a lawsuit, but I cannot believe that patent could stand a court challenge. The feature is too obvious: the only way they could have met the requirement for non- obviousness would be if they had a particular WAY to display it, and that was was novel and non-ob

[android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-12 Thread Gene R.
There have been instances of the rights holder threatening the developer directly (ie. bypassing Google entirely). About 3-4 months ago, some patent IP company notified one of the developers of a caller ID app that they had a patent on displaying location information of the caller id. The develop

[android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-12 Thread dipu
Very interesting topic. I would like to learn more about it. I have few apps in the market and several others prototyped. I am concerned about how do I know if I am violating any copyrights or other IP. For example I took a picture of a globe and edited the image and put it as an app icon. I have c

[android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-12 Thread Stephen Lebed
I''m 43 and try to place by the rules. I've got a couple of apps in the market that I wish were doing better, but thats the way things are right now. I've often thought about reporting such apps, but I agree that it will fall on deaf ears with Google. Reporting the apps to the IP rights holders

[android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-10 Thread Maps.Huge.Info (Maps API Guru)
50+ - I'm from a time that if you plagiarized to write a paper, you got expelled from school. That mentality stuck. -John Coryat -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Android Developers" group. To post to this group, send email to android-developers@google

[android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-10 Thread michael
Hi Yahel, thanks for your view! Personally I'm not worried about the ethics of say hurting Disney either. I just don't want to get myself into legal trouble because I don't fully understand the consequences. Maybe you are right though, and I take it all too seriously -- I'm in the upper end (29) o

[android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-10 Thread Yahel
Hi Michael, You need a little more cynism :) What will happen to these infringers and their app if they get caught ? They will receive a cease-and-desist letter from the rights holders and maybe Google will ban the appMost likely not the developper, just the app. So thinking about it being

[android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-10 Thread Maps.Huge.Info (Maps API Guru)
Virtually every market category is just stuffed with copyright violators. In my favorite category, "News & Weather" there is a developer that has about 50 apps that all violate someone's copyright. This developer basically scrapes a web site and publishes it as an app, and runs his ads in it. Does

[android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-10 Thread michael
Hi again, > Doing so may well violate their DMCA safe harbor provisions and open > them up to big-ticket lawsuits. I suspect that they are best served by > following the DMCA rules, which requires takedown notices by the > rights holders (e.g., Disney). I didn't think of that but good point. I a

Re: [android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-10 Thread Mark Murphy
On Sat, Jul 10, 2010 at 8:37 AM, michael wrote: > However, I doubt flagging apps as inappropriate will have much of an > effect. I am sure you are correct. To be honest, I was just trying to make you happy, because I am guessing that you won't like anything else that I tell you. AFAICT, the only

[android-developers] Re: IP infringements on the Market

2010-07-10 Thread michael
Thanks for your reply Mark. However, I doubt flagging apps as inappropriate will have much of an effect. Surely Google is already aware of the issue and choose not to do anything about it. But who knows, maybe they would react if infringing apps are flagged by sufficiently many people. /Michael.