[arr] Re: Why did Ghai choose Western classical music as the backdrop?

2008-10-04 Thread Dinesh
that was wat i was thinking as well... maybe he felt he couldnt make any movies more grandeur than Devdas... thus he doesnt wanna take the risk... i think Devdas shows Indian classical culture at its best... so maybe Ghai wants to show something else to the audience --- In arrahmanfans@yahoog

[arr] Re: Why did Ghai choose Western classical music as the backdrop?

2008-10-04 Thread brijesh.anantharam
What about TAAL?? --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "Chord" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I get it that he wanted to make a movie about music. But, why > couldn't he have chosen Indian classical music? From photos and > promos, the whole music scene looks Western. Why not make a film with >

[arr] Re: Why did Ghai choose Western classical music as the backdrop?

2008-10-04 Thread rivjot
They have been sayin movie/soundtrack is blend of both Western and Indian classical music. Anil Kapoor plays the role of classical singer in the movie, so I am sure there will also be few classical songs as well. Watch out for more promos or for soundtrack to release. It is not wise to decide wha

[arr] Re: Why did Ghai choose Western classical music as the backdrop?

2008-10-04 Thread Pravinder Sheoran
Hi Chord and all, I completely agree with chord. After seeing the trailers, i have no doubts left that there is nothing to hope out of this movie. Also, i am sorry to say but the music in the trailer is not impressive at all. It looks like Ghai has intervened too much and have forced ARR to commerc

[arr] Re: Why did Ghai choose Western classical music as the backdrop?

2008-10-05 Thread caran
Coz Subhash Ghai is running short of ideas. And as a storyteller, he never was original nor has he matured with time. 'Yuvraaj' is supposed to be a rip off of the hollywood classic 'Amadeus' (based on western classical music) and Ghai is the last the one to bend the genre and convert it to Indian c

[arr] Re: Why did Ghai choose Western classical music as the backdrop?

2008-10-05 Thread Pravinder Sheoran
Hi Farzad, I was shocked and stunned when i read your message and your comment, "are you the assistant of joginder tuteja" about me. Well man, first of all just to open your eyes, please read the following message that I wrote when Jodhaa Akbar was released and find out my relationship with jogin

[arr] Re: Why did Ghai choose Western classical music as the backdrop?

2008-10-05 Thread jibandevta
Why Ghai should not??...It's my question.. what is wrong with u guys?...Tell me in detail what's wrong in 'western classical ' music..Why ARR should not compose tunes in western music?.. I challenge very few still listens 'Zubeida' which is complete 'Indian Classical'..grow up ppl..do not be such

[arr] Re: Why did Ghai choose Western classical music as the backdrop?

2008-10-06 Thread Pravinder Sheoran
Its all right Farzad, I have no hard feelings anymore. I know there are some fake members in the group who write bad about ARR and try to provoke others' feelings. Its hard to differentiate between right and wrong. This incident is a good lesson for all of us and tells a lot about how to take criti

[arr] Re: Why did Ghai choose Western classical music as the backdrop?

2008-10-07 Thread JOHN JEEVINTH
Rahman is doing something different after a long time.. i mean he always keeps xperementing and he does bring out some new sounds.. but when was the last time he worked with Music as Theme Taal sangamam and Sangamam was Indian classical Taal is a mixture of both ARR has proved his worth in both

Re: [arr] Re: Why did Ghai choose Western classical music as the backdrop?

2008-10-05 Thread Farzad Khaleel
Duplicate post. Pravinder, same comment came out when Guru came out... All th awrd ppls were wrong, they gave away all the awards to Guru and also indeed Outstanding achivemnt by an Indian by IIFA :P are you the assistant of joginder tuteja :P On Sun, Oct 5, 2008 at 4:56 AM, Pravinder Sh

Re: [arr] Re: Why did Ghai choose Western classical music as the backdrop?

2008-10-06 Thread Farzad Khaleel
Sorry Pravinder. I am just exhausted seeing all the comments after hearing a 50 seconds trailor. Once again Sorrry boss. On Mon, Oct 6, 2008 at 10:45 AM, Pravinder Sheoran < [EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Hi Farzad, > I was shocked and stunned when i read your message and your comment, >