Re: PaceAllowDuplicateIDs alteration

2005-05-12 Thread David Powell
Friday, May 6, 2005, 3:52:19 PM, Eric Scheid wrote: On 7/5/05 12:09 AM, Graham [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If an Atom Feed Document contains multiple entries with the same atom:id, software MUST treat them as multiple versions of the same entry I don't think this changes the technical

Re: PaceAllowDuplicateIDs alteration

2005-05-07 Thread Eric Scheid
On 7/5/05 3:53 AM, Tim Bray [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On May 6, 2005, at 8:49 AM, Eric Scheid wrote: Are they still the same entry if they have different source elements that identify their source as being different feeds? I don't see why. I subscribe to a Local News feed, a National News

PaceAllowDuplicateIDs alteration

2005-05-06 Thread Graham
As the WG may have noticed, I have some serious problems with the Pace. One small change would eliminate about 75% of them: Replace the line: If an Atom Feed Document contains multiple entries with the same atom:id, software MAY choose to display all of them or some subset of them with: If

Re: PaceAllowDuplicateIDs alteration

2005-05-06 Thread Brett Lindsley
What determines a version? If we have multiple entries with identical information, these are copies, not versions. The real issue is feed state. Given there are identical IDs, can we determine if the entries are identical or different? The end client can then deal with it any way it wants

Re: PaceAllowDuplicateIDs alteration

2005-05-06 Thread Tim Bray
On May 6, 2005, at 7:09 AM, Graham wrote: Replace the line: If an Atom Feed Document contains multiple entries with the same atom:id, software MAY choose to display all of them or some subset of them with: If an Atom Feed Document contains multiple entries with the same atom:id, software MUST

Re: PaceAllowDuplicateIDs alteration

2005-05-06 Thread Eric Scheid
On 7/5/05 12:09 AM, Graham [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If an Atom Feed Document contains multiple entries with the same atom:id, software MUST treat them as multiple versions of the same entry I don't think this changes the technical meaning of the proposal, but does make it very explicit.

Re: PaceAllowDuplicateIDs alteration

2005-05-06 Thread Eric Scheid
On 7/5/05 1:16 AM, Bob Wyman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Graham wrote: If an Atom Feed Document contains multiple entries with the same atom:id, software MUST treat them as multiple versions of the same entry Are they still the same entry if they have different source elements that identify

Re: PaceAllowDuplicateIDs alteration

2005-05-06 Thread Robert Sayre
On 5/6/05, Bob Wyman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Graham wrote: If an Atom Feed Document contains multiple entries with the same atom:id, software MUST treat them as multiple versions of the same entry Are they still the same entry if they have different source elements that

Re: PaceAllowDuplicateIDs alteration

2005-05-06 Thread Tim Bray
On May 6, 2005, at 8:49 AM, Eric Scheid wrote: Are they still the same entry if they have different source elements that identify their source as being different feeds? I don't see why. I subscribe to a Local News feed, a National News feed, and a Science News feed. All from the same publisher.

Re: PaceAllowDuplicateIDs alteration

2005-05-06 Thread Graham
On 6 May 2005, at 4:16 pm, Bob Wyman wrote: Graham wrote: If an Atom Feed Document contains multiple entries with the same atom:id, software MUST treat them as multiple versions of the same entry Are they still the same entry if they have different source elements that identify their source

Re: PaceAllowDuplicateIDs alteration

2005-05-06 Thread Antone Roundy
On Friday, May 6, 2005, at 09:16 AM, Bob Wyman wrote: Graham wrote: If an Atom Feed Document contains multiple entries with the same atom:id, software MUST treat them as multiple versions of the same entry Are they still the same entry if they have different source elements that identify