Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Hi.Well, I couldn't tell.I have perfect pitch as well.Both sounded almost exactly the same, file1 had more base, and there was possibly a slight harmonic on the timpany, file 2 didn't but I don't do drums as such.It sounded

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? I never ever heard it yanny and I wonder how could anyone hear it anything other than loral, that's too obvious lol.On a side note, that reminds me since I was in a regular school, around 2014 I think, there was a similar visual debate

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? The funny thing with Yani/Laurel was that I heard "yairy" until my wife found some site where you could mess with the pitch. I forget which way it went but on one end I finally got laurel really clear. I don't remember if

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Lol with the Yanny Laurel debate I always heard laurel. I oculd only vaguely hear yanny with eqing and other things, but even so I had to force it if that makes sense. URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/618892/#p618892

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? I decided to stop reading at post 18 so I can test this myself. I will give my opinions before and after reading your post. Here we go...I voted can't tell, but I honestly believe it's both files. I feel like a timpani sort

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? I thought about yani laurel too and I could hear both, especially if I manipulated the audio by speeding it up and down, or if I listened while I was alert Vs. tired. URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/618879/#p618879 -- Audiogames

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Right, I just read 18. Good work there. Rig might still color it though, making that second tone more obvious. So I am a fundamental hearer as well. Which probably explains why I'm terrible at EQing. URL: https://forum.audiogames.net

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? @21 I do see how. What they're picking up on in file 2 is that there is a second harmonic of the timpani, which dies out a lot faster than the first. It is file 1 to me, because the complete, fundamental tone of the timpani is basicall

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? @21 I do see how. What they're picking up on in file 2 is that there is a second harmonic of the timpani, which dies out a lot faster than the first. It is file 1, because the complete, fundamental tone of the timpani is basically the

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Yeah it's definitely more muddy and difficult to distinguish on the timpani. That said, I have that issue with just about every instrument that can go that low. I find it more easy to discern higher pitches than lower ones.Those circle

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? I disagree. I have never had trouble discerning pitch on timpani. It's true sometimes rapid tuning isn't as accurate as it could be, but there are gauges along the side which people can use to tune quickly, assuming they're a

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? I'm with 26. I voted for file one, because I could hear more of the lower octave. But the timpany is weird. For all that it's considered a pitched drum in Western orchestral music, I don't really consider it to be. I'd

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? they both play the same notes. one of them plays the same note one octave higher URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/618656/#p618656 -- Audiogames-reflector mailing list Audiogames-reflector@sabahattin-gucukoglu.com https

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? LOL I voted for file 1 as well. I mean, seeing as we can manipulate stereo signals such that when they come through headphones they trick the brain into perceiving them as coming from impossible directions, nothing surprises me. URL: https

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Ahh, harmonic series. When taking brass techniques in college we had to know up to the sixteenth partial.  I've forgotten most of it. It's neat though. URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/618610/#p618610 -- Audiogames

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? The clips are quite fine, but maybe the question should be which has a closer note rather, because the second clip still does not match exactly for some reason. I honestly was going to vote for can't tell exactly for this, but I rea

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? @19, interesting, I'll have to listen to that and see what I notice! I haven't heard it yet as of right now.@20, the results are almost evenly split as you said. Since more and more people are having trouble telling, I'm st

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? It is very obvious. I don't really see how anyone could vote for file 2. URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/618531/#p618531 -- Audiogames-reflector mailing list Audiogames-reflector@sabahattin-gucukoglu.com https://sabah

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? That was very interesting. When I voted for file 1, I thought: "Nobody will pick differently. It's so damn obvious." But what do I know? The results at this moment are 40, 40, 20. URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? @musicalman that's really interesting to know, and the more interesting thing although I voted for the second file, the piano notes you presented at the beginning confused me a bit.However, when you added the distortion the difference r

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Okay, all will be revealed in this post. If you intend to take the test without any bias, skip this post please, and probably don't read the rest of this thread for that matter, until you're done the test. The pole and files will

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Okay, all will be revealed in this post. If you intend to take the test without any bias, skip this post please, and probably don't read the rest of this thread for that matter. The pole and files will remain up indefinitely so

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? I'd be interested in a reveal fairly soon as well, maybe let it go for the rest of today, or, maybe, Monday to give even more people a chance over the weekend? URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/618425/#p618425 -- Audio

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Do not read if you haven't voted!spoiler alert!Ok, so I also agree with many people here,, to be honest to me none of them exactly matches it but if I had to pick one I'd choose 2 since it was closer. I don't have a perfect pi

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Well, I haven't read any post after OP, but I choose file 2. URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/618371/#p618371 -- Audiogames-reflector mailing list Audiogames-reflector@sabahattin-gucukoglu.com https://sabahattin-gucukoglu.co

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Interesting. SpoilershereSo, the range of a typical set of four timpani is written realistically between about second octave D and third octave g. Below that the overtones just make it too wet, and above that it just sounds dead. You can, of

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? I picked can't tell because to me it sounds like the drum is in the middle of both. URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/618359/#p618359 -- Audiogames-reflector mailing list Audiogames-reflector@sabahattin-gucukoglu.com

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? I'm with 3 on this one.  they sounded great for the  first hundred ms of each but then I felt like the little drum thing wavered just a bit and that made me question myself too much until I went with can't tell.

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? I haven't read any responses yet or even looked at the results.I selected can't tell because the drum sounded a tiny bit off on both.  I could tell that the note was there just an octave below but it just sounded slight

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Why don't you reveal it all now? The suspense is killing me! You could just add a heading to the bottom of the original post and advise people not to read it until they completed the experiment. URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/6

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? For my perfect pitch ears its 2, even though the scales are different, so its a bit like ocmparing apples to oranges. URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/618290/#p618290 -- Audiogames-reflector mailing list Audiogames-reflector

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Nice to see this is getting attention! I'll keep the pole open and the files up indefinitely so this can continue.The results are pretty much trending the way I and probably most researchers would anticipate. However I'll co

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Nice to see this is getting attention! I'll keep the pole open and the files up indefinitely so this can continue.The results are pretty much trending the way I and probably most researchers would anticipate. However I'll co

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Do not read this post if you haven't voted yet. It is going to get into, not quite technical, but possible theories.From an audio standpoint, it sounds like file 2 is playing the note at the same pitch. From a technical standpoint t

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Do not read this post if you haven't voted yet. It is going to get into, not quite technical, but possible theories.From an audio standpoint, it sounds like file 2 is playing the note at the same pitch. From a technical standpoint t

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? @GrannyCheeseWheel The ears playing tricks on us and stuff!Yeah, would love to try more of these. There's a great series on YouTube on psycho-acoustics if you're interested. I'll try and hunt down a link. URL: https://forum

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Do not read this post if you haven't voted yet. It is going to get into, not quite technical, but possible theories.From an audio standpoint, it sounds like file 2 is playing the note at the same pitch. From a technical standpoint t

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? @GrannyCheeseWheel The ears playing tricks on us and stuff!Yeah, would love to try more of these. There's a great series on YouTube on psycho-acousticsif you're I'll try and hunt down a link. URL: https://forum.audiogames.

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? How could there be any debate, it's file 1. File 2 is one octave higher on the piano while the timpani stays at the same note. URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/618206/#p618206 -- Audiogames-reflector mailing list Audio

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? I'll get my girl to try this later. I'll be curious what her pitch perfectness makes of it. Me personally? I can't hold a tune in a bucket. Though I still try URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/618203/#p618203

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? This is a cool experiment! I would love it if you could post more of them.Spoilers for anyone who hasn't done the test yet. If you haven't voted yet,don'tread.spoiler wrote:Uh ... both? Neither? I don't know.It sounds t

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? This is a cool experiment! I would love it if you could post more of them.Spoilers for anyone who hasn't done the test yet. If you haven't voted yet,don'tread.spoiler wrote:Uh ... both? Neither? I don't know.It sounds t

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

Re: audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Wow, it's even right now! The differences in what we perceive fascinates me. I chose file 1, but I'm interested to know which file had both notes the same, if any at all. URL: https://forum.audiogames.net/post/61819

audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Hi all,This has been on my agenda for posting here, but due to laziness I just haven't done it.This is an audio experiment, and while it is musical in nature, you don't have to be a musician to take part. I've left out all the t

audio experiment - how do you perceive this?

audio experiment - how do you perceive this? Hi all,This has been on my agenda for posting here, but due to laziness I just haven't done it.This is an audio experiment, and while it is musical in nature, you don't have to be a musician to take part. I've left out all the t