Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-16 Thread Sanjiva Weerawarana
On Sun, 2006-10-15 at 21:19 -0500, Alan M. Feldstein wrote: > > I agree that the vast majority of Axis2 use cases would enjoy the > convenience of a single jar, but consider the fact that the Java > language lacks unsigned types. The principle of reuse teaches use to > go find existing classes. Pr

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-15 Thread Eran Chinthaka
Hi Alan, What Srinath is trying to explain is about the released artifacts that are going to be listed in the release page. Like war, std-bin, min-bin, etc. For your requirement, we can host all the released jars in maven repo, which you can directly get from. For example, you will see axis2-adb-1

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-15 Thread Srinath Perera
Hey Eran. Did I opposed :) Well one have to set the Axis2 classpath few times before realization hit him --Srinath > Lets bring them down to two jars .. Most of these axis2 jars are > small. So no harm putting everything in the one jar Hmm, Srinath is this you? :). I put this suggestion long t

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-15 Thread Srinath Perera
-0.9 For my application (nothing to do with Web services), there is a dependency on ADB only, specifically org.apache.axis2.databinding.types.UnsignedLong The harm is in introducing a larger-than-necessary jar as a dependency. How much larger than the ADB jar are you proposing that I accept? "Sm

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-15 Thread Eran Chinthaka
Srinath Perera wrote: > Just looked at the std distribution .. we have > 3 axom jars > 10 Axis2 jars !!! > > Lets bring them down to two jars .. Most of these axis2 jars are > small. So no harm putting everything in the one jar Hmm, Srinath is this you? :). I put this suggestion long time back an

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-14 Thread Davanum Srinivas
Yep. -- dims On 10/14/06, robert lazarski <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Just to clarify, what I believe Dims and I agreed to via +1 was to remove all the spring jars from the war , and place just one 4K jar inside the std-bin dist - axis2-spring*.jar - which has the axis2 code to tie together spri

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-14 Thread robert lazarski
Just to clarify, what I believe Dims and I agreed to via +1 was to remove all the spring jars from the war , and place just one 4K jar inside the std-bin dist - axis2-spring*.jar - which has the axis2 code to tie together spring and axis2 . Robert On 10/14/06, Ajith Ranabahu <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-14 Thread Ajith Ranabahu
Hi, And provide all aditional dependacncies of Axis2 as a one zip file from the site. Or add a minmial standard and exteneded distribution. I agree with Srinath in this. My guess is there would be users who want everything and some would want most of it but not all. Right now we have standard

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-14 Thread Srinath Perera
Just looked at the std distribution .. we have 3 axom jars 10 Axis2 jars !!! Lets bring them down to two jars .. Most of these axis2 jars are small. So no harm putting everything in the one jar I would say 1) Get rid of bcel-5.2.jar 2) jaxme-* 3) spring-* And provide all aditional dependacnc

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-14 Thread Srinath Perera
Couple of comments 1) Do we need JMS jar on minimal distribution? Plus we do not need jms transport on the axis2.xml by default. users could uncomment and add a jar if they need. 2) Can we make everything belong to Axis2 a one jar. At the time of creating the distribution we could do that. Also

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-13 Thread Davanum Srinivas
+1 to keep the jars out. Let's add a commented out the entry in web.xml and document that people have to enable that entry for the listener. --- dims On 10/13/06, robert lazarski <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I'm +0 on keeping the jars in the WAR. If a user is purposely adding a listener, he can p

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-13 Thread robert lazarski
I'm +0 on keeping the jars in the WAR. If a user is purposely adding a listener, he can purposely copy a few jars to web-inf/lib. Its documented as such. Following what most users on axis-users are doing with spring anyways, most want to put spring in an aar . In that case, they'd be just moving t

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-13 Thread Saminda Abeyruwan
Hi Robert,In the Spring WAR case, according to the xdoc one has to write the following in the web.xmlorg.springframework.web.context.ContextLoaderListener contextConfigLocation /WEB-INF/applicationContext.xml If above is specified and .aar not available in services folder,

Re: [Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-13 Thread robert lazarski
IMHO: 1) None of the spring stuff should be included in the WAR. These jars might be placed inside the AAR if a user chooses to do so, so its really up to the user where to put these jars. This is the way it was and is documented as such. 2) The std-bin distro should not include the spring-* jar

[Axis2] What to include in the Axis2 1.1 distributions??

2006-10-13 Thread Thilina Gunarathne
Hi Devs, We found that we have shipped some unnecessary libraries with the Axis2-RC1 distributions.. I created the following lists to capture what to include, what not to include... Please do review them and add your suggestions.. http://wiki.apache.org/ws/FrontPage/Axis2/axis2_war_build_list htt