[BAROQUE-LUTE] Re: 18th-century right hand fingering (short)

2007-01-07 Thread David Rastall
On Jan 7, 2007, at 6:17 PM, Dale Young wrote: > ...There can > always be exceptions. But that means there is always A RULE. The > old guys > knew best. Definitely a very useful dictum for today's HIP musicians to live by, but the problem is that we seldom seem to talk about what those rules

[BAROQUE-LUTE] Re: 18th-century right hand fingering (short)

2007-01-07 Thread Dale Young
Sorry that sentence should have said; Just a little attention to details, like alternating fingers ( middle / index) and always attempting to use the middle finger on the strong beat, can be very effective a bringing out the true nature of the melody. Dale - Original Message - Fro

[BAROQUE-LUTE] Re: 18th-century right hand fingering (short)

2007-01-07 Thread Dale Young
I believe that underlying all this is that we / I can become complacent about plucking with whatever finger happens to show up nearby the string. That's not good enough. Just a little attention to alternating fingers ( middle / index) and always attempting to use the middle finger on

[BAROQUE-LUTE] Re: 18th-century right hand fingering (short)

2007-01-07 Thread Markus Lutz
Hi Robert, I can only concur with that. If I look at Weiss autograph fingerings there are only few for the right hand - and only once with the ring finger. But regarding left hand there are many examples of his personal way to play. And maybe the main principle that we can learn from it is his hu

[BAROQUE-LUTE] 18th-century right hand fingering (long)

2007-01-07 Thread Stewart McCoy
Dear Robert, Thank you for what you say about right-hand fingering, and for giving us the two website addresses. Whether or not it is a good idea to use the ring finger is determined to some extent by one's hand position in relation to the bridge. If one's right hand plucks close to the rose, the