[BAROQUE-LUTE] Re: 11 or 13 (barring)

2009-01-15 Thread Anthony Hind
I suppose to the three hypotheses, mentioned in my previous message, I should add something about the apparent success of demi-filé, probably around the same time that swannecks became "popular". There are arguments about whether the extension on swan-necked lutes had pure gut or demifilé, o

[BAROQUE-LUTE] Re: 11 or 13 (barring)

2009-01-14 Thread Edward Martin
Once you learn to use gut, you will not want to go back. ed At 05:25 PM 1/14/2009 -0800, sterling price wrote: >I have a Widhalm that does have fan-barring and a soundboard carefully >thicknessed as the original (assuming that the original has not been >altered over the years). It also has a ba

[BAROQUE-LUTE] Re: 11 or 13 (barring)

2009-01-14 Thread sterling price
I have a Widhalm that does have fan-barring and a soundboard carefully thicknessed as the original (assuming that the original has not been altered over the years). It also has a bass extension based on the 1764 Martin Brunner which is very similar to the Jauch extension. This pegbox, as you all

[BAROQUE-LUTE] Re: 11 or 13 (barring)

2009-01-14 Thread Anthony Hind
Matthias, thanks for your comments. Le 14 janv. 09 à 18:56, Mathias Rösel a écrit : >> There have been discussions on the issue of barring (fan versus J- >> barring) on this list, but I don't think there is any automatic >> relation between swan-necks and fan-barring, > > Well, there is. Provided