Re: re Hydroponics (FWD from GREG WILLIS)

2002-01-11 Thread Chris Shade
OK, sorry, I guess I am testy about the Disney stint. Cheers, Chris --- Allan Balliett <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Chris - I assure you that the remarks were not meant > to be personal > and I apologize for the offense you have take - or I > have given. > -Allan > > >Allan, > > > >I do take o

Re: re Hydroponics (FWD from GREG WILLIS)

2002-01-11 Thread Allan Balliett
Chris - I assure you that the remarks were not meant to be personal and I apologize for the offense you have take - or I have given. -Allan >Allan, > >I do take offense to that condescending comment. The >fact that you mention conveyors with nutrient >solutions in reference to my ideas means y

Re: re Hydroponics (FWD from GREG WILLIS)

2002-01-10 Thread Chris Shade
Allan, I do take offense to that condescending comment. The fact that you mention conveyors with nutrient solutions in reference to my ideas means you do not read them - you know. Your instant lack of faith in me is upsetting. I don't know what it is specifically about this that makes you sh

Re: re Hydroponics (FWD from GREG WILLIS)

2002-01-10 Thread Allan Balliett
>Certainly true if only HID lights are used. > >I think we are raising too much dichotomy here. We >will talk about it some time. The things I have in >mind are hybrid systems that are good for greenhouse >work in areas with bad or polluted soils. It is not >so reductionist as you may be thinki

Re: re Hydroponics (FWD from GREG WILLIS)

2002-01-10 Thread Chris Shade
Allan, --- Allan Balliett <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I'm not interested in working with growing > systems in which > humans introduce the "parts" they think should be in > such a system, > I'm interested in working with growing systems that > optimize the > natural system ("heal the Earth").

Re: re Hydroponics (FWD from GREG WILLIS)

2002-01-10 Thread Fernando Cabral
In perfect agreement with Allan in this particular, let me add a few things more: a) The plants should give back something to the soil. Its root exudate as a minimum; b) Roots have a role to perform in the soil, like opening it up for air and water to drain in; c) micro life has a dynamic r

Re: re Hydroponics (FWD from GREG WILLIS)

2002-01-10 Thread Allan Balliett
Chris - I'm not interested in working with growing systems in which humans introduce the "parts" they think should be in such a system, I'm interested in working with growing systems that optimize the natural system ("heal the Earth"). You know: the plant between the earth and sun, with the p

Re: re Hydroponics (FWD from GREG WILLIS)

2002-01-09 Thread Chris Shade
Yeah, Allan, that was basically my reaction to your post, too, thought I didn't have much time to get into it. Watch out for the lure of BD piety. Hydroponics does not have to mean chemicals, it means you remove the soil physics, which are often limiting to the system, or contaminated. Here is

re Hydroponics (FWD from GREG WILLIS)

2002-01-08 Thread Allan Balliett
Dear Allan, You said: >Bob - Biodynamics is a system. Unlike factory-oriented approaches, >biodynamics cannot be 'parted out,' so, if you want to use a >biodynamic element as a "tool" in your hydroponics operation, well, >you still ain't doing biodynamics and there ain't any real reason to >dis