Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-02-03 Thread Moonbase
Updated patch for SC 7.4-24858. -- Moonbase Moonbase: 'The Problem Solver' (http://www.kaufen-ist-toll.de/moonbase) Moonbase's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=21594 View this thread: http://forums

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-02-03 Thread Moonbase
Guess I got it fixed. Patch for 7.4 is in 'Bug 10583' (http://bugs.slimdevices.com/show_bug.cgi?id=10583). I’d be happy to get some testing and feedback on this change, especially from people who use the MusicBrainz data (MUSICBRAINZ_ALBUM_ID), FLAC files, and probably who don’t store all their

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-31 Thread Moonbase
In SC7.4-24817, still the same bug as originally decribed: SC -requires- dumb stuff like "Disc #1 of 1" to be able to group VA compilations (that are not in the same folder) correctly. -- Moonbase Moonbase: 'The Problem Solver' (http://www.kaufen-ist-toll.de/moonbase) -

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-09 Thread snarlydwarf
Philip Meyer;381552 Wrote: > I haven't used MusicBrainz, but are you saying that even the most > obscure albums (eg. unofficial live concerts, etc), will have unique > *album* id's? Are they album id's, or disk id's? > > Are the unique id's really guaranteed to be unique, or just unlikely > (eg

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-09 Thread Moonbase
They are actually album id’s since MB tends to use only one entry for "identical" re-releases. This -might- pose a problem for collectors that collect several releases of the "same" album, I must admit (thinking of old Blues and Jazz records). The real "obscure" releases you might have to enter in

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-09 Thread Phil Meyer
>I’m really happy that we have adopted MusicBrainz and MusicIP (MusicDNS) >early enough to -never- run into that problem – each album has an >ID*guaranteed to be unique. > Really? Some of my albums are in formats not supported by MusicIP. I don't archive analysis, due it to corrupting some of my

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-08 Thread Moonbase
I’m really happy that we have adopted MusicBrainz and MusicIP (MusicDNS) early enough to -never- run into that problem – each album has an ID*guaranteed to be unique. -- Moonbase Moonbase: 'The Problem Solver' (http://www.kaufen-ist-toll.de/moonbase) ---

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-08 Thread Phil Meyer
>still, my solution would work, "Circus (Take >That)" and "Circus (Spears)" may not be pretty, but effective. > Yes, the kludge would kind of work, except unless you always add it to all albums, you could be caught out with two albums that have the same name. The following SQL query run against t

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-08 Thread MrSinatra
Philip Meyer;380960 Wrote: > >i'm not sure how you would deal with the so called "greatest hits" > >issue as phil pointed out if you didn't look at folder structure tho, > >whats your suggestion? (i actually already do mine like this: > >"Greatest Hits (Queen)" which i think is a hell of a lot e

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-08 Thread Siduhe
Philip Meyer;380960 Wrote: > Eg. This xmas just gone, there were two albums with the same title > released in the same week, by two common pop artists (Take That and > Britney Spears) [I have no interest either, BTW!]. OT, but Take That's album was called "The Circus" and it's pretty good IMHO i

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-08 Thread Phil Meyer
You haven't said how you are browing your music library. Have you tried "Browse Artists > Various Artists" to see your compilation albums? >Compilations: >(x) List compilation albums under each artist > Selecting this option will mean that all track artists (performers on compilation albums) wi

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-08 Thread Phil Meyer
>i'm not sure how you would deal with the so called "greatest hits" >issue as phil pointed out if you didn't look at folder structure tho, >whats your suggestion? (i actually already do mine like this: >"Greatest Hits (Queen)" which i think is a hell of a lot easier than >counting on SC logic, but

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-08 Thread Phil Meyer
>So much for theory … you might want to actually try it … >I’m still working at SC’s Schema logic (trying to understand contributors and >roles). > All artists contribute to music in some way (various roles). Some are the primary performers on songs (artist role for normal albums), some are ba

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-07 Thread MrSinatra
Moonbase;380908 Wrote: > The main reason is a very simple one: For broadcasting purposes, I > -need- (and want) all songs I have from any one artist stored together, > namely, in (below) an »artist« folder. Let’s say I’m more interested in > which titles I have than on which album they were. do

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-07 Thread Moonbase
The main reason is a very simple one: For broadcasting purposes, I -need- (and want) all songs I have from any one artist stored together, namely, in (below) an »artist« folder. Let’s say I’m more interested in which titles I have than on which album they were. It’s still nice (and needed because

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-07 Thread MrSinatra
moonbase, i have read very carefully this thread, but i'm confused... is there a reason you don't store all the songs on a given disc in one folder or dir? btw, if all songs on a disc are in one dir, then my exp is if they don't have an albumartist tag, or a tag treated as albumartist, (like TP

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-07 Thread Moonbase
So much for theory … you might want to actually try it … I’m still working at SC’s Schema logic (trying to understand contributors and roles). And I can’t really find any other difference in the tags, maybe you’d like to check the -metamp3- output in the text file. I guess it must have have somet

Re: [SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-07 Thread Phil Meyer
>- If the single tracks are stored -elsewhere-, no »artist list« will > appear. (Mine are usually stored under the artist folder, even for > compilations, since I want to know -all- titles I have from any > single artist. Compilations are »held together« by playlists, or SC > logic.) It's not

[SlimDevices: Beta] SC7.3.2-24523: Bug: VA albums handled as many one-track albums by 2 artists

2009-01-07 Thread Moonbase
I think I have found some more faults regarding the aggregation of »VA«/»Compilation« albums, verified against both SC 7.3.2-24401 and 7.3.2-24523 (both Windows). I was wondering why very few of my VA albums were shown as »albums«, some even with a list of artists beneath, while -most- of them di