Re: On being back

2006-12-26 Thread Matt Grimaldi
Most of December...I even tried to access the account management page to see if I somehow got bumped, but that was broken too... --Matt - Original Message From: Jo Anne <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: brin-l@mccmedia.com Sent: Tuesday, December 26, 2006 11:04:47 AM Subject: On being back Hey

Re: Was religion necessary for developing civilizations?

2006-12-26 Thread Charlie Bell
On 27/12/2006, at 3:44 AM, Gary Nunn wrote: > > A question that came up in a deep, late night conversation > > Was religion a necessary tool for building moral and ethical > standards in > early civilizations or social groups? Or did someone simply invent > the fear > of "Going To Hell"

On being back

2006-12-26 Thread Jo Anne
Hey List (I see you hiding, Charlie (the married man))... It's interesting that Robert was gone, too. I wonder how many of us the old server picked out for shunning. Things have been alright, Doug. How are you doing? This was our grandson's second Christmas, and the first one he was really int

Re: Was religion necessary for developing civilizations?

2006-12-26 Thread dcaa
Typing from my Blackberry, so I'll keep this brief. I think the moralizing effect of religion is a function of the development of morality in civilization, as well as the level of *sophistication* of that civilization, than a function of a method of teaching morality. Many major ancient religion

Re: Was religion necessary for developing civilizations?

2006-12-26 Thread William T Goodall
On 26 Dec 2006, at 4:44PM, Gary Nunn wrote: > > A question that came up in a deep, late night conversation > > Was religion a necessary tool for building moral and ethical > standards in > early civilizations or social groups? Or did someone simply invent > the fear > of "Going To Hell"

Was religion necessary for developing civilizations?

2006-12-26 Thread Gary Nunn
A question that came up in a deep, late night conversation Was religion a necessary tool for building moral and ethical standards in early civilizations or social groups? Or did someone simply invent the fear of "Going To Hell" to impose their will on the masses? I suppose that also impl