[ceph-users] Re: download.ceph.com repository changes

2019-09-24 Thread David Turner
IRT a testing/cutting edge repo, the non-LTS versions of Ceph have been removed because very few people ever used them and tested them. The majority of people that would be using the testing repo would be people needing a bug fix ASAP. Very few people would actually use this regularly and its

[ceph-users] Re: download.ceph.com repository changes

2019-09-24 Thread Ken Dreyer
On Tue, Sep 17, 2019 at 8:03 AM Sasha Litvak wrote: > > * I am bothered with a quality of the releases of a very complex system that > can bring down a whole house and keep it down for a while. While I wish the > QA would be perfect, I wonder if it would be practical to release new > packages to

[ceph-users] Re: download.ceph.com repository changes

2019-09-18 Thread Yoann Moulin
Hello, > I still think this is something we should consider as users still > experience problems: > > * Impossible to 'pin' to a version. User installs 14.2.0 and 4 months > later they add other nodes but version moved to 14.2.2 > * Impossible to use a version that is not what the latest is

[ceph-users] Re: download.ceph.com repository changes

2019-09-17 Thread Sasha Litvak
I have been affected by few issues mentioned by Alfredo. * Version Pinning: Had to install several debs of specific version to be able to pull dependencies of the correct version. I believe that other projects resolving it by creating a virtual package that pulls all of the proper dependencies

[ceph-users] Re: download.ceph.com repository changes

2019-09-17 Thread vitalif
The worst part about the official repository is that it lacks Debian packages Also of course it would be very convenient to be able to install any version from the repos, not just the latest one. It's certainly possible with debian repos... ___

[ceph-users] Re: download.ceph.com repository changes

2019-09-17 Thread Janne Johansson
Den tis 17 sep. 2019 kl 15:15 skrev Alfredo Deza : > Reviving this old thread. > * When a release is underway, the repository breaks because syncing > packages takes hours. The operation is not atomic. > Couldn't they be almost atomic? I believe both "yum" and "apt" would only consider rpms/debs

[ceph-users] Re: download.ceph.com repository changes

2019-09-17 Thread James Dingwall
On 17/09/2019 14:14, Alfredo Deza wrote: > * Impossible to 'pin' to a version. User installs 14.2.0 and 4 months > later they add other nodes but version moved to 14.2.2 I dynamically generate a pin for the ceph .deb files in ansible using the tasks below. IIRC the ceph-deploy package doesn't

[ceph-users] Re: download.ceph.com repository changes

2019-09-17 Thread Abhishek Lekshmanan
"Alfredo Deza" writes: > Reviving this old thread. > > I still think this is something we should consider as users still > experience problems: > > * Impossible to 'pin' to a version. User installs 14.2.0 and 4 months > later they add other nodes but version moved to 14.2.2 > * Impossible to use

[ceph-users] Re: download.ceph.com repository changes

2019-09-17 Thread Marc Roos
:15 To: ceph-maintain...@ceph.com; ceph-users; ceph-devel Subject: [ceph-users] Re: download.ceph.com repository changes Reviving this old thread. I still think this is something we should consider as users still experience problems: * Impossible to 'pin' to a version. User installs 14.2.0 and 4

[ceph-users] Re: download.ceph.com repository changes

2019-09-17 Thread Alfredo Deza
Reviving this old thread. I still think this is something we should consider as users still experience problems: * Impossible to 'pin' to a version. User installs 14.2.0 and 4 months later they add other nodes but version moved to 14.2.2 * Impossible to use a version that is not what the latest