Re: Defense Sec Gates Breaks Down

2007-07-24 Thread Russel Madere
Hasn't this been the policy since the US started repatriating the bodies of our fallen servicemen? This one statement makes the rest of the article sound foolish too me. ... That's why for so long he refused to allow photographs of caskets arriving on American soil. ...

Re: Defense Sec Gates Breaks Down

2007-07-24 Thread Gruss Gott
Russ wrote: Hasn't this been the policy since the US started repatriating the bodies of our fallen servicemen? Not to show the coffins? I'm not sure, but where it was or wasn't, why not do it now? Secondly why doesn't the President attend any funerals especially of notables such as Major

Re: Defense Sec Gates Breaks Down

2007-07-24 Thread William Bowen
Secondly why doesn't the President attend any funerals especially of notables such as Major Zembiec? I believe the official line is because he cannot attend all of them. -- will If my life weren't funny, it would just be true; and that would just be unacceptable. - Carrie Fisher

Re: Defense Sec Gates Breaks Down

2007-07-24 Thread William Bowen
actually yes. On 7/24/07, G Money [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Which, while morbid and depressing, makes sense, does it not? On 7/24/07, William Bowen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Secondly why doesn't the President attend any funerals especially of notables such as Major Zembiec? I believe

Re: Defense Sec Gates Breaks Down

2007-07-24 Thread G Money
Which, while morbid and depressing, makes sense, does it not? On 7/24/07, William Bowen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Secondly why doesn't the President attend any funerals especially of notables such as Major Zembiec? I believe the official line is because he cannot attend all of them. --

Re: Defense Sec Gates Breaks Down

2007-07-24 Thread Gruss Gott
WillBo wrote: actually yes. To me, I would think it would be great idea to attend Majors and above as well as notables: e.g., somebody jumps on a grenade and saves his platoon and is issued a DSC or something after death. However, it does seem like there's an effort to sanitize the war:

RE: Defense Sec Gates Breaks Down

2007-07-24 Thread Loathe
: Gruss Gott [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, July 24, 2007 12:31 PM To: CF-Community Subject: Re: Defense Sec Gates Breaks Down WillBo wrote: actually yes. To me, I would think it would be great idea to attend Majors and above as well as notables: e.g., somebody jumps on a grenade

Re: Defense Sec Gates Breaks Down

2007-07-24 Thread Gruss Gott
tBone wrote: Something else to remember, yes it's great to recognize troops for their sacrifices, but a certain level of emotional detachment is required to prosecute a war on the sharp end. Absolutely, although I think that each American needs to decide that for themselves; the government

Defense Sec Gates Breaks Down

2007-07-23 Thread Gruss Gott
Ms. Huffington describes it best: I had read about Gates' speech at the Marine Corps Association's annual dinner in Arlington when he broke down in tears during a tribute to Major Douglas Zembiec. But it was only when I saw the clip while taping the McLaughlin Group that I realized how