Re: [CF-metadata] udunits time units question

2011-03-31 Thread Schultz, Martin
Hi Chris et al., indeed it seems like some clarification is necessary about the use of different calendars in modelling. Your suggestion to "map" the 360 day calendar onto the Gregorian calendar in output files won't work: there would be no need for a 360 day calendar if it would. The idea

Re: [CF-metadata] udunits time unit question

2011-03-31 Thread Seth McGinnis
For those who have never encountered a non-standard calendar in the wild, here's one place they show up: 360-day and 365-day calendars are used in climate modeling. It requires a lot of extra work to write code that can handle leap years by making the year length variable, and the payoff for doin

Re: [CF-metadata] udunits time unit question

2011-03-31 Thread Christopher Barker
On 3/31/11 12:42 AM, Lowry, Roy K. wrote: Dear All, This debate between Chris and Benno hinges upon how one determines the sampling interval for a time series. Benno depends upon semantics encoded in the units of measure field - something I have done in the past although I am now convinced t

Re: [CF-metadata] physical vs dimensional units

2011-03-31 Thread Lowry, Roy K.
Hi John, We label Units of Measure with a URI (e.g. SDN:P061::ULAA represents metres), which represents a term in the P061 vocabulary (http://vocab.ndg.nerc.ac.uk/P061/list/current). The vocab (born in the late 70s) is a work of pragmatism that contains a mixture of 'dimensional units' plus 'p

[CF-metadata] physical vs dimensional units

2011-03-31 Thread John Caron
udunits is a "dimensional units" library, for manipulating powers of the fundamental dimensions (length, mass, time, charge, temperature). this is necessary but not complete for capturing the meaning of the "physical units" of our data. We also need units like kg/kg, for which the udunit canon

Re: [CF-metadata] udunits time unit question

2011-03-31 Thread Lowry, Roy K.
Dear All, This debate between Chris and Benno hinges upon how one determines the sampling interval for a time series. Benno depends upon semantics encoded in the units of measure field - something I have done in the past although I am now convinced that it is not best practice. Chris advocate