Re: [CGUYS] Hard Drive manufacturers?

2008-09-12 Thread Snyder, Mark (IT CIV)
Larry, I have sourced and bought hundreds of disks drives for about twenty years. Early on, the going was rough; many failures. Today, drives are much more reliable. My point about the (fictitious) 72 Chevy was that I too have seen manufactures go through bad stretches, but don't pay much

Re: [CGUYS] Hard Drive manufacturers?

2008-09-12 Thread gerald
i have come to like maxtor. their turn around time on the failures is very short. we buy drives of the same physical shape, as maxtor wants the returns in the original packing * ** List info, subscription management,

Re: [CGUYS] Hard Drive manufacturers?

2008-09-12 Thread Michael Fernando
My experiences with Seagate are based upon about 20 consecutive failures (by Sun workstation serial number) about 10 years ago. After the first 5 or so, Sun contacted us and started to proactively replace workstation hard drives - all by Seagate. I've worked with Sun workstations and servers

Re: [CGUYS] Hard Drive manufacturers?

2008-09-12 Thread Tony B
Why does this just sound _odd_? It's like you've had so many failures you've learned their habits. Really, that can't be a Good Thing. But it sounds like why I stopped using Maxtors (cheap, but at what cost?). Have you even _tried_ other brands? In some 5-10 years of external video drives

Re: [CGUYS] Hard Drive manufacturers?

2008-09-11 Thread mike
All this talk of failure, wasn't someone supposed to tell us about drives that don't fail? On Thu, Sep 11, 2008 at 11:59 AM, Tony B [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: For our video drives (which really get hammered), we use exclusively Hitachi. But I'm not real anal about internal drives and will get

Re: [CGUYS] Hard Drive manufacturers?

2008-09-11 Thread Larry Sacks
Your diatribe against manufacturers translated to cars: You thought that was a diatribe? Really? Seems I should post one sometime so you can see the difference. I used to have a 72 Chevy, but it broke down so I won't go near GM. So, you won't go near GM because of experiences with a car

Re: [CGUYS] Hard Drive manufacturers?

2008-09-11 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
Hey don't laugh I had two of those cars. They were not as bad as many made them out to be. Stewart At 04:19 PM 9/11/2008, you wrote: So, you won't go near GM because of experiences with a car over 30 years ago? You should check out what GM has to offer. You'll find they in general - and

Re: [CGUYS] Hard Drive manufacturers?

2008-09-11 Thread Larry Sacks
] Hard Drive manufacturers? Hey don't laugh I had two of those cars. They were not as bad as many made them out to be. Stewart At 04:19 PM 9/11/2008, you wrote: So, you won't go near GM because of experiences with a car over 30 years ago? You should check out what GM has to offer. You'll find

Re: [CGUYS] Hard Drive manufacturers?

2008-09-11 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
Discussion List [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Rev. Stewart Marshall Sent: Thursday, September 11, 2008 2:41 PM To: COMPUTERGUYS-L@LISTSERV.AOL.COM Subject: Re: [CGUYS] Hard Drive manufacturers? Hey don't laugh I had two of those cars. They were not as bad as many made them out to be. Stewart

Re: [CGUYS] Hard Drive manufacturers?

2008-09-11 Thread Tom Piwowar
All this talk of failure, wasn't someone supposed to tell us about drives that don't fail? Good point. Same point. Back when the manufacturing of hard drives was a black art and the MTBF in the low 5 digits I think the brand to brand differences were more significant. MTBF is now 10 times

Re: [CGUYS] Hard Drive manufacturers?

2008-09-11 Thread b_s-wilk
Hey don't laugh I had two of those cars. They were not as bad as many made them out to be. Stewart At 04:19 PM 9/11/2008, you wrote: So, you won't go near GM because of experiences with a car over 30 years ago? You should check out what GM has to offer. You'll find they in general -