Re: [Crm-sig] Multiple inheritance

2018-05-11 Thread Richard Light
On 11/05/2018 08:50, Martin Doerr wrote: > Dear Richard, > > Following the latest extensions of the scope note of E4 Period, a > geopolitical entity is indeed regarded as a case (type, > specialization) of E4 Period. Since E4 Period IsA E92 spacetime > volume, its projection at some time or at all

Re: [Crm-sig] Multiple inheritance

2018-05-11 Thread Martin Doerr
Dear Daria, Continuing, I'd like to point you to the definition of "Contact Point". I think it is consistent to regard networks as services, and IP adresses as identifiers that can be resolved by a particular service. Postal Adresses use to be the same in the aspect of resolution, but simultan

[Crm-sig] ISSUE 332, S22 Segment of Matter

2018-05-11 Thread Martin Doerr
Dear All, Here my rework. Old scope note: S22 Segment of Matter// Subclass of: S20 <#_S20_Physical_Feature>Physical Feature Scope Note:This class comprises physical features in a relative stability of form within a specific spacetime volume. The spatial extent of an instance of S22 Se

Re: [Crm-sig] Multiple inheritance

2018-05-11 Thread Martin Doerr
Dear Richard, Following the latest extensions of the scope note of E4 Period, a geopolitical entity is indeed regarded as a case (type, specialization) of E4 Period. Since E4 Period IsA E92 spacetime volume, its projection at some time or at all times is an E53 Place. See respective properties

Re: [Crm-sig] Multiple inheritance

2018-05-11 Thread Stephen Stead
Dear Daria Good morning, I do not see the parallel between E53 Place and E45 Address with IP-addresses and VPN. In E53 Place we have a real-world place, typically a geographic extent on the surface of the Earth (though not restricted to this as we know) and in E45 Address we have a name for a

Re: [Crm-sig] Multiple inheritance

2018-05-11 Thread Дарья Юрьевна Гук
Dear all, generalising examples we get the same situation with E53 Place and E45 Address like we have now with IP-addresses and VPN. Real place with Internet-access can be somewhere on globe (GPS) and others recieve coded numbers (Singapore, Any Islands...), which are various in different time p

Re: [Crm-sig] ISSUE: E74 Group (from LRMoo discussions)

2018-05-11 Thread Robert Sanderson
At the Getty, we have exactly this issue as well, but would extend it to at least gender. We feel that these are not intrinsics, and thus like the group membership pattern, especially for citizenship/nationality, as many people are multi-national over their lifetimes. Religions, as added by Mar

[Crm-sig] Multiple inheritance

2018-05-11 Thread Richard Light
Hi, I'm wanting to encourage a colleague to use a CRM-based approach to a geographical-themed project.  We're talking about geopolitical [and geographical] entities which have a known duration (e.g. 'Abingdon from the 17th century until local government reorganisation in 1974'). This could be mod