Re: DMCA Final Rule

2000-11-07 Thread Steven M. Bellovin
In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Rick Smith at Secure Computing writes: >At 09:20 PM 10/29/00, Peter Wayner wrote: > >>What is obsolete anyways? The question to me sounds like the one children >>would ask: "how old is old?" Well, it's as old as you feel. Are Sony Beta >>tapes obsolete? Most will

Re: DMCA Final Rule

2000-11-07 Thread Rick Smith at Secure Computing
At 09:20 PM 10/29/00, Peter Wayner wrote: >What is obsolete anyways? The question to me sounds like the one children >would ask: "how old is old?" Well, it's as old as you feel. Are Sony Beta >tapes obsolete? Most will say yes, but I think there are devotees who will >say "No". I know that the

Re: DMCA Final Rule

2000-10-31 Thread Peter Wayner
> > >More to the point, if you buy a Japanese DVD containing literary works, >such as movies or artwork or music or (given this definition) games, >and it fails to work because the access control mechanism >doesn't know how, that seems like a slam-dunk application >for this exemption to the DMCA f

Re: DMCA Final Rule

2000-10-31 Thread Bill Stewart
At 11:27 PM 10/27/00 -0400, Peter Wayner wrote: >> >>2. Literary Works, Including Computer Programs and >>Databases, Protected by Access Control Mechanisms >>That Fail to Permit Access Because of Malfunction, >>Damage or Obsoleteness." > > >If you ask me, Linux, FreeBSD, OpenBSD, and NetBSD are th

Re: DMCA Final Rule

2000-10-29 Thread Peter Wayner
> >2. Literary Works, Including Computer Programs and >Databases, Protected by Access Control Mechanisms >That Fail to Permit Access Because of Malfunction, >Damage or Obsoleteness." If you ask me, Linux, FreeBSD, OpenBSD, and NetBSD are the wave of the future. If my forward-looking computer ca

DMCA Final Rule

2000-10-27 Thread John Young
We offer the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act Final Rule on Access Control Circumvention: http://cryptome.org/dmca102700.txt (149KB) An excerpt on why there will be no exemption for circumventing access to DVDs by tools such as DeCSS: http://cryptome.org/dmca-dvd.htm (15KB) The two