Re: Who Am I Anyway?

2001-12-14 Thread cubic-dog
On Thu, 13 Dec 2001, Jim Choate wrote: > On Thu, 13 Dec 2001, Duncan Frissell wrote: > > > Frissell's Believe it or Not: > > > > WWII was won by soldiers, sailors, and marines who fought, died, flew > > bombers, commanded armies, commanded fleets, and possessed and used nuclear > > weapons wi

Re: CDR: Re: Who Am I Anyway?

2001-12-14 Thread F. Marc de Piolenc
Jim Choate wrote: > > On Fri, 14 Dec 2001, F. Marc de Piolenc wrote: > > > It is clear that whatever ID procedures were in effect, they were not > > effective. Many enlistees lied about their ages and got away with it. > > I have zero problem with that assertion. > > However, lying about one

Re: CDR: Re: Who Am I Anyway?

2001-12-13 Thread measl
On Fri, 14 Dec 2001, F. Marc de Piolenc wrote: > It is clear that whatever ID procedures were in effect, they were not > effective. Many enlistees lied about their ages and got away with it. At the time, insufficient age was an "open secret" for these so afflicted. Warm bodies are what drive a

Re: Who Am I Anyway?

2001-12-13 Thread Jim Choate
On Fri, 14 Dec 2001, F. Marc de Piolenc wrote: > It is clear that whatever ID procedures were in effect, they were not > effective. Many enlistees lied about their ages and got away with it. I have zero problem with that assertion. However, lying about ones age and getting away with it is a fa

Re: CDR: Re: Who Am I Anyway?

2001-12-13 Thread F. Marc de Piolenc
It is clear that whatever ID procedures were in effect, they were not effective. Many enlistees lied about their ages and got away with it. Marc de Piolenc Duncan Frissell wrote: > > At 05:10 PM 12/13/01 -0600, Jim Choate wrote: > >Which is beside your point. Your statement was that the governm

Re: Who Am I Anyway?

2001-12-13 Thread Duncan Frissell
At 05:10 PM 12/13/01 -0600, Jim Choate wrote: >Which is beside your point. Your statement was that the government didn't >do ANY identification for ANY of the soldiers in WWII. Patently wrong. >Quit trying to change the rules in the middle of the game. >AFTER the war started, not before. When t

Re: Who Am I Anyway?

2001-12-13 Thread Jim Choate
On Thu, 13 Dec 2001, Duncan Frissell wrote: > On Thu, 13 Dec 2001, Jim Choate wrote: > > > Bullshit, if they had birth certificates they were required to produce > > them. And if you worked on the neuclear weapons then the FBI most > > certainly did do a background check. > > But of course the

Re: Who Am I Anyway?

2001-12-13 Thread Duncan Frissell
On Thu, 13 Dec 2001, Jim Choate wrote: > Bullshit, if they had birth certificates they were required to produce > them. And if you worked on the neuclear weapons then the FBI most > certainly did do a background check. But of course they weren't required to have birth certificates. It also se