[dash-dev] IP Cleanliness question

2012-04-23 Thread Aaron Digulla
Hello, I've stumbled over one of these corner cases: I copied 7 lines of code from stackoverflow.com (http://stackoverflow.com/a/3758880/34088) The code isn't an OSS project, it's not under a specific license and I feel that it's not worth the effort to run this through the standard IP process.

Re: [dash-dev] IP Cleanliness question

2012-04-23 Thread Wayne Beaton
The copied code is intellectual property and as such is subject to the Eclipse IP Due Diligence process. It can only be distributed from eclipse.org (e.g. a source code repository) if we have clear license from the author to do so. Yes, it's a small bit of code, but the full IP process still

Re: [dash-dev] IP Cleanliness question

2012-04-23 Thread Aaron Digulla
Am 23.04.2012 19:24, schrieb Wayne Beaton: Alternatively, I think we can make the case that Stack Overflow contributions are CC-licensed [1] and treat the code similar to a third-party library. However, I believe that license compatibility will be complicated. Here is some material to

Re: [dash-dev] IP Cleanliness question

2012-04-23 Thread Wayne Beaton
Sounds like a plan. Wayne On 04/23/2012 01:47 PM, Aaron Digulla wrote: How about I open an IP request so the lawyers can give a nod to the rule? This would create a simple, safe solution for all Eclipse developers because I bet that I wasn't the first one to wonder - I was just the first

Re: [dash-dev] IP Cleanliness question

2012-04-23 Thread Aaron Digulla
Am 23.04.2012 20:08, schrieb Miles Parker: That's kind of perverse, given that one of the major points of Open Source is to be able to share code with one another... rant OSS is not about sharing code with just anyone; it's only with anyone you happen to like! The main difference to

Re: [dash-dev] IP Cleanliness question

2012-04-23 Thread Aaron Digulla
Am 23.04.2012 19:59, schrieb Wayne Beaton: Sounds like a plan. Since this is my first attempt to do this: That means I should open a CQ request on ipzilla, right? What project should I select? eclipse.platform? How about I open an IP request so the lawyers can give a nod to the rule? This

Re: [dash-dev] IP Cleanliness question

2012-04-23 Thread Wayne Beaton
Good question. Go to the portal, select any project (it doesn't matter) in the Eclipse Projects component. Click on the [pose] a question about general legal issue option. That'll take you to the right place. (or just go here:

Re: [dash-dev] IP Cleanliness question

2012-04-23 Thread Aaron Digulla
Am 23.04.2012 21:01, schrieb Wayne Beaton: Good question. Go to the portal, select any project (it doesn't matter) in the Eclipse Projects component. Click on the [pose] a question about general legal issue option. That'll take you to the right place. (or just go here:

Re: [dash-dev] IP Cleanliness question

2012-04-23 Thread Wayne Beaton
Right. That functionality is limited to Project Leads and PMC members. Sorry about that. I guess that I'll have to pose the question. Can you give me some words to start from? Thanks, Wayne On 04/23/2012 04:01 PM, Aaron Digulla wrote: Am 23.04.2012 21:01, schrieb Wayne Beaton: Good