Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-12 Thread Marc Dirix
Marc I'm not convinced that it is dbmail or gmime adding a host part. Do you have an example of the full message headers? John Yes, I'm however pretty sure postfix does not change the from address. I have furthermore spamassassin and clamavsmtp running. But online the ones with a

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-12 Thread Paul J Stevens
Marc, dbmail doesn't do this, afaict. The only set_header call we do during normal delivery is for 'Return-Path'. What do the postfix logs tell you? Marc Dirix wrote: Marc I'm not convinced that it is dbmail or gmime adding a host part. Do you have an example of the full message headers?

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-12 Thread Marc Dirix
dbmail doesn't do this, afaict. The only set_header call we do during normal delivery is for 'Return-Path'. What do the postfix logs tell you? Nothing intelligible, the rcpt-to address (in the message envelope) is correct. I can't find an option for postfix where it enables / disables it

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-12 Thread Paul J Stevens
Marc Dirix wrote: dbmail doesn't do this, afaict. The only set_header call we do during normal delivery is for 'Return-Path'. What do the postfix logs tell you? Nothing intelligible, the rcpt-to address (in the message envelope) is correct. I can't find an option for postfix where it

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-12 Thread Marc Dirix
Oops. The README clearly states: Rewrite user to u...@$myorigin This feature is controlled by the boolean append_at_myorigin parameter (default: yes). You should never turn off this feature, because a lot of Postfix components expect that all addresses have the form u...@domain.

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-12 Thread John Fawcett
Marc Dirix wrote: Oops. The README clearly states: Rewrite user to u...@$myorigin This feature is controlled by the boolean append_at_myorigin parameter (default: yes). You should never turn off this feature, because a lot of Postfix components expect that all addresses have the form

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-11 Thread John Fawcett
Marc Dirix wrote: My Point was not the part about not being able to decode, but the part where dbmail (or gmime) adds an @host.domain after the non-decodable address. This confuses things. Marc I'm not convinced that it is dbmail or gmime adding a host part. Do you have an example of the

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-08 Thread John Fawcett
Paul J Stevens wrote: John Fawcett wrote: It's likely a bug of the sending client (probably a webmail service). Shouldn't the from header contain only ascii encoding? That's not the point. Even if you are correct (I would assume rfc2047 would apply to From_ headers as well), we'd

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-07 Thread John Fawcett
It's likely a bug of the sending client (probably a webmail service). Shouldn't the from header contain only ascii encoding? John Aaron Stone wrote: I've noticed this, too. It's not an added header, it's a mis-decoded header. I suspect a GMime bug; perhaps Paul has identified which versions of

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-07 Thread Brandon Adams
This is done because the us-ascii character set does not include support for accented characters (José). This string also utilized quoted printable. I would think that the decoding of this string should be handled not by the server, but rather by the client. If this is something that DBMail

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-07 Thread Paul J Stevens
John Fawcett wrote: It's likely a bug of the sending client (probably a webmail service). Shouldn't the from header contain only ascii encoding? That's not the point. Even if you are correct (I would assume rfc2047 would apply to From_ headers as well), we'd like dbmail to gracefully degrade.

[Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-06 Thread Marc Dirix
Hi I'm on 2.2.11. Often some customers receive emails with incorrect (or strangely encoded) From headers. This From header then gets mangled at some point between reception and delivery. The newly formed From header has been mangled, and @host.domain of the mailserver has been added. See here

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-06 Thread Aaron Stone
I've noticed this, too. It's not an added header, it's a mis-decoded header. I suspect a GMime bug; perhaps Paul has identified which versions of GMime are buggy in this way? Aaron On Wed, 6 May 2009 15:19:41 +0200, Marc Dirix m...@electronics-design.nl wrote: Hi I'm on 2.2.11. Often

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-06 Thread Uwe Kiewel
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Aaron Stone wrote: I've noticed this, too. It's not an added header, it's a mis-decoded header. I suspect a GMime bug; perhaps Paul has identified which versions of GMime are buggy in this way? Me too, but in a different way: Not the address but

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-06 Thread Jorge Bastos
2009 15:17 To: DBMail mailinglist Subject: Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Aaron Stone wrote: I've noticed this, too. It's not an added header, it's a mis-decoded header. I suspect a GMime bug; perhaps Paul has identified which

Re: [Dbmail] mysterious from-address

2009-05-06 Thread Marc Dirix
Although I could live with mis-encoding. The addition of @host.domain is somewhat annoying as it makes outlook think the email address is valid, and does not complain to the user. Marc ___ DBmail mailing list DBmail@dbmail.org