Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-18 Thread Bob Proulx
D G Teed wrote: patk.1...@sent.as wrote: I notice that Debian has settled on Exim as the default MTA, unlike many (most?) other distros which seem to use Postfix. ... but Debian is all about choices, so you pick what you want. In Debian you are driving a car - you can get to many

Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-17 Thread Camaleón
On Fri, 16 Sep 2011 15:00:22 -0700, patk.1034 wrote: (...) Since 'here' is where Debian-ites 'live', I'd like to ask for experienced opinioins. Specifically in a Debian-server world, why one over the other? (...) I can tell you what I use and that's Postfix. To be sincere, I'm sticked to

Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-17 Thread Miles Fidelman
Camaleón wrote: On Fri, 16 Sep 2011 15:00:22 -0700, patk.1034 wrote: (...) Since 'here' is where Debian-ites 'live', I'd like to ask for experienced opinioins. Specifically in a Debian-server world, why one over the other? One thing to consider is what ELSE you're going to be running on

Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-17 Thread D G Teed
On Fri, Sep 16, 2011 at 7:00 PM, patk.1...@sent.as wrote: Hi, We're evaluating our company's future server platform, and are pretty much decided on Debian. At some companies, this would be regarded a miracle to achieve. I'm glad it worked out for you. I notice that Debian has settled on

Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-17 Thread David Sastre
Depending on your needs, you might find worth knowing that, as noted in /usr/share/doc/exim4-base/README.Debian.gz included in exim4-base 4.72-6+squeeze2: 4.5. SELinux There is no SELinux policy for Exim4 available so far. Until this is resolved, users should use postfix or sendmail if

Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-17 Thread Chris Davies
patk.1...@sent.as wrote: Those needs happen to include making an informed business decision that takes into account others experience opinions, the state of community/project, etc. Which is why I'm asking my question -- and looking forward to relevant answers. At the risk of stating the

Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-17 Thread Andrew McGlashan
Hi, Bob Proulx wrote: Just because installing Debian's standard[1] system task installs Exim doesn't mean that a lot of Debian users don't install Postfix. http://qa.debian.org/popcon.php?package=postfix I'm surprised with the level of Exim4 installs, given the number of guides on Postfix

Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-16 Thread patk . 1034
Hi, We're evaluating our company's future server platform, and are pretty much decided on Debian. I notice that Debian has settled on Exim as the default MTA, unlike many (most?) other distros which seem to use Postfix. As we're also evaluating our mail server tech, I'd like to understand the

Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-16 Thread Walter Hurry
On Fri, 16 Sep 2011 15:00:22 -0700, patk.1034 wrote: Hi, We're evaluating our company's future server platform, and are pretty much decided on Debian. I notice that Debian has settled on Exim as the default MTA, unlike many (most?) other distros which seem to use Postfix. As we're

Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-16 Thread Bob Proulx
patk.1...@sent.as wrote: We're evaluating our company's future server platform, and are pretty much decided on Debian. An excellent choice. But on this mailing list that is simply accepted practice. :-) I notice that Debian has settled on Exim as the default MTA, unlike many (most?) other

Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-16 Thread patk . 1034
What difference does it make which MTA is the distribution default? Given your response, I'd guess that it doesn't to you. Thanks for your opinion. It certainly made enough difference for Debian to choose -- differently than most. I've found Debian's 'decisions' as a distro to be generally

Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-16 Thread patk . 1034
But on this mailing list that is simply accepted practice. :-) Yes, which is why I'm here asking :-) You do realize that the discussing Exim and Postfix is like the classic discussions between emacs and vi? It will be difficult to really get objective answers. People like what they like.

Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-16 Thread Walter Hurry
On Fri, 16 Sep 2011 15:37:29 -0700, patk.1034 wrote: What difference does it make which MTA is the distribution default? Given your response, I'd guess that it doesn't to you. Thanks for your opinion. It certainly made enough difference for Debian to choose -- differently than most.

Re: Moving to Debian server. (Re)Visiting the Postfix or Exim decision. Asking for Debian-ites' opinions.

2011-09-16 Thread patk . 1034
What an amazingly patronising reply from someone seeking advice! Patronising? Hardly. Tbh, I'd initially considered your response of a similar vein, but chose to give you the benefit of the doubt, thank you for your opinion, and continue the discussion. Seems I'm making all sorts of mistakes