Re: [DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-03-07 Thread Eya Badal
Community please find the finalized committer requirements. Thank you for all your feedback and time. Committer Requirements: 1-Continuous contributions to AGE: Committers should have a decent amount of continuous engagement and contributions (fixing bugs, writing documentation, or answering

Re: [DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-03-01 Thread John Gemignani
I'm thinking that 4 months may be too long or restrictive. Maybe it should be based on the level of contribution activity, something like - - +3 months with light activity and engagement. - +2 months of medium activity and engagement. - +1 month with solid activity and engagement. john

Re: [DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-02-28 Thread Eya Badal
Thank you to anyone who contributed to this discussion. I would like to finalize the committer requirements guideline based on the discussions from this thread. Please following find the requirements: 1-Continuous contributions to AGE: Committers should have a decent amount, at least 4 contin

Re: [DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-01-11 Thread Muhammad Usama
I agree with most of the points mentioned above While in my opinion knowledge of the code base and of the core concept of the product should be weighted most among other requirements. Since the committer(s) has the responsibility and authority to accept the code changes so it is very important that

Re: [DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-01-09 Thread Alex Kwak
I want a committer to be a person who not only care his own work, but also to other people's work. So that each other can develop further and go in a good direction. On 2022/01/06 20:14:31 Eya Badal wrote: > Hello everyone, > > As recommended by our mentors I would like to get community feedba

Re: [DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-01-09 Thread Young Seung Andrew Ko
I suppose anyone having given regular suggestions about the AGE's roadmap or what other technologies AGE needs to be integrated with can be regarded as a committer. AGE belongs to the community not just limited to those who have put the codes in. Andrew Ko

Re: [DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-01-06 Thread Eya Badal
As recommended by mentors I am keeping this discussion open. Please let us know your thoughts on committer requirements. On 2022/01/06 21:01:16 Eya Badal wrote: > I am closing this discussion. Apologies I think this needs to happen in a > different channel. > > On 2022/01/06 20:14:31 Eya Bada

Re: [DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-01-06 Thread Eya Badal
I am closing this discussion. Apologies I think this needs to happen in a different channel. On 2022/01/06 20:14:31 Eya Badal wrote: > Hello everyone, > > As recommended by our mentors I would like to get community feedback and > thoughts on committer requirements. I think we should discuss t

Re: [DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-01-06 Thread Dehowe Feng
I agree with quantifying the contributions. We could also take into consideration the "quality" of the contributions as well. Are they making significant contributions On 2022/01/06 20:38:26 John Gemignani wrote: > How about - > > There should be a minimum of 1 month since the start of activit

Re: [DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-01-06 Thread Josh Innis
For example Kokou Afidegnon https://github.com/afidegnum has not made a code commit yet, but has been very helpful in error finding and building out processes. On Thu, Jan 6, 2022 at 12:40 PM Josh Innis wrote: > I think the user needs to show base competency in a specific area that is > benefic

Re: [DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-01-06 Thread Josh Innis
I think the user needs to show base competency in a specific area that is beneficial to the project: error testing, technical writing, programming, feature building, etc. On Thu, Jan 6, 2022 at 12:38 PM John Gemignani wrote: > How about - > > There should be a minimum of 1 month since the start

Re: [DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-01-06 Thread John Gemignani
How about - There should be a minimum of 1 month since the start of activity from said commiter. There should be a minimum of 5 commits. John On 2022/01/06 20:14:31 Eya Badal wrote: > Hello everyone, > > As recommended by our mentors I would like to get community feedback and > thoughts on c

[DISCUSS] Committer Requirements

2022-01-06 Thread Eya Badal
Hello everyone, As recommended by our mentors I would like to get community feedback and thoughts on committer requirements. I think we should discuss this and document the requirements. Best regards, Eya