Re: [BLOCKER] - Guest VMs are not getting IPs as the DHCP port is not opened in VR

Hi all, I did not say that the issues are not VR related, because they are. What I said was to not try fixing it by calling the bash scripts form within the python files. Those changes landed on master a few months ago, or more. The thing is that most of us rely on the simulator and there was

Re: [BLOCKER] - Guest VMs are not getting IPs as the DHCP port is not opened in VR

completely agree. We lack dev support for fixing and testing networking issues :( PS: I feel like there should be document in github describing contributor / reviewer / jira guidelines ~Rajani On Wed, Sep 16, 2015 at 12:51 PM, Wilder Rodrigues < wrodrig...@schubergphilis.com> wrote: > Hi all,

Re: [BLOCKER] - Guest VMs are not getting IPs as the DHCP port is not opened in VR

Hi Wilder, CLOUDSTACK-8843 This ticket is actually NOT regression. It is not implemented/tested for the basic zone VR. What I have observed in the VR refactor is that sanity testing of components the code affects is not done. Now we are

Re: [BLOCKER] - Guest VMs are not getting IPs as the DHCP port is not opened in VR

I agree. Most of the blockers we see now are VR related. ~Rajani On 16-Sep-2015, at 10:15 am, Raja Pullela wrote: > I agree with jayapal, so far none of the BVTs for the hypervisors are at 100% > except for the simulator's. > Also, changes/refactoring some of the

RE: [BLOCKER] - Guest VMs are not getting IPs as the DHCP port is not opened in VR

I agree with jayapal, so far none of the BVTs for the hypervisors are at 100% except for the simulator's. Also, changes/refactoring some of the very core functionality such as VR should be thought through and thoroughly tested before being pushed as the impact will be huge and stabilization

Re: [BLOCKER] - Guest VMs are not getting IPs as the DHCP port is not opened in VR

Assigned to myself. Thanks, Jayapal > On 15-Sep-2015, at 2:49 pm, Raja Pullela wrote: > > Hi, > > JIRA - ticket https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CLOUDSTACK-8843 > Can someone please pick up this ticket ? This is failing a bunch of the BVTs > tests in Basiczone.

Re: [BLOCKER] - Guest VMs are not getting IPs as the DHCP port is not opened in VR

Hi Jayapal, I would not suggest to move back to the sceptres, but focus on fixing and for every fix test it very well so we get confidence. If we start calling scripts com the python code it will have a huge chance to become a real mess! Let’s stick to it and fix it and once it’s stable we can

Re: [BLOCKER] - Guest VMs are not getting IPs as the DHCP port is not opened in VR

I have the feeling that we are fixing 1 issue and created 2. Please, make sure the routers tests are executed and green before creating the PR. I will do the same. Cheers, Wilder > On 15 Sep 2015, at 14:23, Jayapal Reddy Uradi > wrote: > > Assigned to myself.

Re: [BLOCKER] - Guest VMs are not getting IPs as the DHCP port is not opened in VR

Wilder, That is true. All these issues are because of the VR refactoring. I don’t know what are the unit test cases run on VR refactor code. VR (shell) scripts are stabilized over years and now suddenly moved to new implementation. What we have figured out is that this new implementation is