Re: [VOTE-SUMMARY] - IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-02-07 Thread Antonio Gallardo
Hi: The results of the votation: http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?t=10748904244r=1w=2 is: A- [ +2] Cocoon will don't throw any exception when this happen. B- [ -4] Log the event at INFO level. C- [ +6] Log the event at DEBUG level. Also Nicola comment: snip *IMPORTANT* IIRC this

Re: [VOTE] - IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-24 Thread Geoff Howard
Antonio Gallardo wrote: Hi: This changes was suggested by Peter Hunsberger: Overview: = When Cocoon attempt to close an already closed stream you get an IO exception. If the user keeps closing the session the error doesn't tell you why, just that it happened. If it's an error on the

Re: IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-23 Thread Vadim Gritsenko
Antonio Gallardo wrote: Hi Peter: Seems like we agree in the exception is not useful at all. Posible solutions: 1- Cocoon will don't throw any exception when this happen. -0 2- Log the event at INFO level. -1 3- Log the event at DEBUG level. +1 Vadim

Re: IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-23 Thread peter royal
On Jan 22, 2004, at 10:58 AM, Antonio Gallardo wrote: 1- Cocoon will don't throw any exception when this happen. -1 2- Log the event at INFO level. -0 3- Log the event at DEBUG level. +1 (and into its own special logger too) -pete

[VOTE] - IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-23 Thread Antonio Gallardo
Hi: This changes was suggested by Peter Hunsberger: Overview: = When Cocoon attempt to close an already closed stream you get an IO exception. If the user keeps closing the session the error doesn't tell you why, just that it happened. If it's an error on the client side and I

Re: [VOTE] - IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-23 Thread Tim Larson
On Fri, Jan 23, 2004 at 02:40:55PM -0600, Antonio Gallardo wrote: When Cocoon attempt to close an already closed stream you get an IO exception. If the user keeps closing the session the error doesn't tell you why, just that it happened. If it's an error on the client side and I personally

RE: [VOTE] - IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-23 Thread Hunsberger, Peter
Here is the vote: 1- [+1] Cocoon will don't throw any exception when this happen. 2- [-1] Log the event at INFO level. 3- [+0] Log the event at DEBUG level.

Re: [VOTE] - IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-23 Thread Joerg Heinicke
On 23.01.2004 21:40, Antonio Gallardo wrote: Here is the vote: 1- [-0] Cocoon will don't throw any exception when this happen. 2- [+0] Log the event at INFO level. 3- [+1] Log the event at DEBUG level. Joerg

Re: [VOTE] - IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-23 Thread Vadim Gritsenko
Here is the vote: 1- [+0] Cocoon will don't throw any exception when this happen. 2- [-1] Log the event at INFO level. 3- [+1] Log the event at DEBUG level. Vadim

RE: IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-22 Thread Hunsberger, Peter
Antonio Gallardo [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Hunsberger, Peter dijo: I'm not sure I even see a reason for logging it at INFO? If you've got an error that occurs because the client closed the socket you're either going to know this, or if you turn up logging to the INFO level to

RE: IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-22 Thread Antonio Gallardo
Hi Peter: Seems like we agree in the exception is not useful at all. Posible solutions: 1- Cocoon will don't throw any exception when this happen. 2- Log the event at INFO level. 3- Log the event at DEBUG level. Please tell me what of this options you prefer. Best Regards, Antonio Gallardo

RE: IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-22 Thread Hunsberger, Peter
Antonio Gallardo [EMAIL PROTECTED] asks: Hi Peter: Seems like we agree in the exception is not useful at all. Posible solutions: 1- Cocoon will don't throw any exception when this happen. +1 2- Log the event at INFO level. -1 3- Log the event at DEBUG level. +0

RE: IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-21 Thread Hunsberger, Peter
Antonio Gallardo [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Hunsberger, Peter dijo: It appears that if you attempt to close an already closed stream you get an IO exception. This means that if Cocoon gets stopped and restarted it is possible, in at least some circumstances, for Cocoon to throw

RE: IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-21 Thread Antonio Gallardo
Hunsberger, Peter dijo: I'm not sure I even see a reason for logging it at INFO? If you've got an error that occurs because the client closed the socket you're either going to know this, or if you turn up logging to the INFO level to try and find this out you're going to need some way to

Re: IOException closing stream in Cocoon Servlet

2004-01-20 Thread Antonio Gallardo
Hunsberger, Peter dijo: It appears that if you attempt to close an already closed stream you get an IO exception. This means that if Cocoon gets stopped and restarted it is possible, in at least some circumstances, for Cocoon to throw an IOException in