Re: CForms stabilization tasks (was Re: Marking cforms stable in 2.1.8)

2005-06-10 Thread Reinhard Poetz
Sylvain Wallez wrote: I personally don't use v2 nor v3. People using it are invited to speak up! You answered the question in your summary of the last year GT Hackathon discussion about cforms (http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=xml-cocoon-devm=109774752401800w=2) yourself: [...] - don't use

Re: CForms stabilization tasks (was Re: Marking cforms stable in 2.1.8)

2005-06-10 Thread Paul Crabtree
Hi, i've just finished quite a large cocoon site using 2.1.7 with Forms V3. We choose this version for two reasons: 1. At the time i couldnt find much info on the different versions or why they were there so assumed V3 meant it was more mature and the latest. 2. showForm() in V3 offers the

Re: CForms stabilization tasks (was Re: Marking cforms stable in 2.1.8)

2005-06-10 Thread Sylvain Wallez
Paul Crabtree wrote: Hi, i've just finished quite a large cocoon site using 2.1.7 with Forms V3. We choose this version for two reasons: 1. At the time i couldnt find much info on the different versions or why they were there so assumed V3 meant it was more mature and the latest. Well,

Re: CForms stabilization tasks (was Re: Marking cforms stable in 2.1.8)

2005-06-10 Thread Sylvain Wallez
Reinhard Poetz wrote: Sylvain Wallez wrote: I personally don't use v2 nor v3. People using it are invited to speak up! You answered the question in your summary of the last year GT Hackathon discussion about cforms (http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=xml-cocoon-devm=109774752401800w=2)

Re: CForms stabilization tasks (was Re: Marking cforms stable in 2.1.8)

2005-06-10 Thread Leszek Gawron
Sylvain Wallez wrote: Paul Crabtree wrote: Hi, i've just finished quite a large cocoon site using 2.1.7 with Forms V3. We choose this version for two reasons: 1. At the time i couldnt find much info on the different versions or why they were there so assumed V3 meant it was more mature and

Re: CForms stabilization tasks (was Re: Marking cforms stable in 2.1.8)

2005-06-09 Thread Leszek Gawron
Sylvain Wallez wrote: Ralph Goers wrote: snip/ The bottom line is you cannot have code sitting around forever telling people its great but you have to use it at your own risk cause we might change it anytime we feel like it. This has just been going on for far too long. The code is never

RE: CForms stabilization tasks (was Re: Marking cforms stable in 2.1.8)

2005-06-09 Thread Bart Molenkamp
-Oorspronkelijk bericht- Van: Leszek Gawron [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 5 - flatten the configuration to allow for easier extension with the xconf include mechanism in 2.2 I could give it a shot but I have no deeper knowledge of cocoon.xconf syntax in this case. Do we have to

Re: CForms stabilization tasks (was Re: Marking cforms stable in 2.1.8)

2005-06-09 Thread Sylvain Wallez
Leszek Gawron wrote: Sylvain Wallez wrote: The main points to achieve stable state are: 1 - remove v2 and v3 apis I assume there are some features that we would like to port back to v1. Could we identify them? I personally don't use v2 nor v3. People using it are invited to speak up!

Re: CForms stabilization tasks (was Re: Marking cforms stable in 2.1.8)

2005-06-09 Thread Leszek Gawron
Sylvain Wallez wrote: I could give it a shot but I have no deeper knowledge of cocoon.xconf syntax in this case. Do we have to make every widget a component? That doesn't feel right. Nono, what I'm talking about is the various subcontainers that exist in CForms, such as forms-datatypes

Re: CForms stabilization tasks (was Re: Marking cforms stable in 2.1.8)

2005-06-09 Thread Mark Lundquist
On Jun 9, 2005, at 1:48 AM, Sylvain Wallez wrote: I personally don't use v2 nor v3. People using it are invited to speak up! I have a few Cocoon projects, and I use v2 in all but one of them (the oldest one)! cheers, :-) ml

Re: CForms stabilization tasks (was Re: Marking cforms stable in 2.1.8)

2005-06-09 Thread Reinhard Poetz
Mark Lundquist wrote: On Jun 9, 2005, at 1:48 AM, Sylvain Wallez wrote: I personally don't use v2 nor v3. People using it are invited to speak up! I have a few Cocoon projects, and I use v2 in all but one of them (the oldest one)! Can you give a short explanation on the reasons for