Re: Adding Telemetry information to Cordova

2015-11-04 Thread Steven Gill
Problem with collecting from lib is how do you show notice to users to opt out? If we build that notice into lib, imagine how confusing that might be for PhoneGap/Taco/Mobilefirst users to see a message about cordova wanting to collect data. I think we should only introduce it to CLI if we do.

Re: Adding Telemetry information to Cordova

2015-11-04 Thread Carlos Santana
Yep, no collection on app just tools. And also be careful on what we collect on tooling also, there might things we might not want to collect. (cli commands might have sensitive data) we just need to collect some of it in a anonymous way. Also some environment info also is useful (node version,

Re: Adding Telemetry information to Cordova

2015-11-04 Thread Carlos Santana
I meant it's an opt-in, it's off by default in cordova-lib CLI will tell lib to turn on collection, other CLIs can choose to collect or not to collect and tell Lib On Wed, Nov 4, 2015 at 6:01 PM Steven Gill wrote: > Problem with collecting from lib is how do you show

Re: Adding Telemetry information to Cordova

2015-11-04 Thread Jesse
We would collect data from cli use, not in app. cli and lib versions, plugins used, cli commands used, platforms used and versions, etc NOTHING should be added to the app a developer installs on the emulator or device. Ideally this is all done in the cli directly so other tools can still

Re: Adding Telemetry information to Cordova

2015-11-04 Thread Tammo Schimanski
I think the same, this could be very useful. But we have to think about the things terence already mentioned. These are three very big points for data collection and they have to be 100% clear before we get started with this. I think that we don’t need to collect user identifiable information,

Re: Adding Telemetry information to Cordova

2015-11-03 Thread julio cesar sanchez
I think it's a good idea to add it and it will help understand how people use cordova and find common problems that they might have 2015-11-02 23:13 GMT+01:00 Parashuram N : > Hey folks, > > One of the action items from the face to face meeting was about adding the >

Re: Adding Telemetry information to Cordova

2015-11-03 Thread Terence M. Bandoian
Could be useful. What exactly would be collected? Would it be optional? Any user identifiable information? -Terence Bandoian On 11/3/2015 2:31 AM, julio cesar sanchez wrote: I think it's a good idea to add it and it will help understand how people use cordova and find common problems that

Adding Telemetry information to Cordova

2015-11-02 Thread Parashuram N
Hey folks, One of the action items from the face to face meeting was about adding the ability to the Cordova CLI to collect telemetry data. Folks said that they were not sure if Apache had any policies against it. I checked with legal-disc...@apache.org (and