Re: What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-07 Thread Pierre-Arnaud Marcelot
+1. I would add that with the removal of the server.xml file and the future changes in the InstallationLayout of ApacheDS, the current implementation of the Server Tools will be completely irrelevant and outdated. What about starting a complete re-vamp of these tools for the 2.0 release

Re: What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-07 Thread Emmanuel Lecharny
On 6/7/10 10:30 AM, Pierre-Arnaud Marcelot wrote: +1. I would add that with the removal of the server.xml file and the future changes in the InstallationLayout of ApacheDS, the current implementation of the Server Tools will be completely irrelevant and outdated. What about starting a

Re: What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-07 Thread Pierre-Arnaud Marcelot
Indeed, I saw that too. These are interesting tools to have but they're not very related to ApacheDS. It could be interesting to have the dump/load commands working again, as well as a tool to rebuild indices and recover a broken partition. Regards, Pierre-Arnaud On 7 juin 2010, at 11:57,

Re: What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-05 Thread Alex Karasulu
On Fri, Jun 4, 2010 at 5:56 PM, Felix Knecht fel...@apache.org wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 The question is : should we keep going and fix this module or should we move it to the deceased projects ? A thrd option would be to make this module a separate project we

Re: What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-05 Thread Stefan Seelmann
Emmanuel Lecharny wrote: Hi guys, this module is broken since, pfeww, september 11 2008 (what a coincidence ! Bad things always happen on 11/09...) The question is : should we keep going and fix this module or should we move it to the deceased projects ? A thrd option would be to make

Re: What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-05 Thread Emmanuel Lecharny
On 6/5/10 10:38 AM, Stefan Seelmann wrote: Emmanuel Lecharny wrote: Hi guys, this module is broken since, pfeww, september 11 2008 (what a coincidence ! Bad things always happen on 11/09...) The question is : should we keep going and fix this module or should we move it to the deceased

Re: What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-05 Thread Kiran Ayyagari
On Sat, Jun 5, 2010 at 11:38 AM, Stefan Seelmann seelm...@apache.org wrote: Emmanuel Lecharny wrote: Hi guys, this module is broken since, pfeww, september 11 2008 (what a coincidence ! Bad things always happen on 11/09...) The question is : should we keep going and fix this module or

What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-04 Thread Emmanuel Lecharny
Hi guys, this module is broken since, pfeww, september 11 2008 (what a coincidence ! Bad things always happen on 11/09...) The question is : should we keep going and fix this module or should we move it to the deceased projects ? A thrd option would be to make this module a separate project

Re: What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-04 Thread Felix Knecht
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 The question is : should we keep going and fix this module or should we move it to the deceased projects ? A thrd option would be to make this module a separate project we can release separately from ADS 2.0. - From an administrators POV (who

Re: What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-04 Thread Emmanuel Lecharny
On 6/4/10 4:56 PM, Felix Knecht wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 The question is : should we keep going and fix this module or should we move it to the deceased projects ? A thrd option would be to make this module a separate project we can release separately from ADS

Re: What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-04 Thread Felix Knecht
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 It all depends on which command we are talking about here. On any linux box, you have many tools like ldapadd or ldapsearch existing. No need to rewite those guys (just because starting a command which spawns a JVM is too freaking slow). Aren't

Re: What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-04 Thread Emmanuel Lecharny
On 6/4/10 5:17 PM, Felix Knecht wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 It all depends on which command we are talking about here. On any linux box, you have many tools like ldapadd or ldapsearch existing. No need to rewite those guys (just because starting a command which

Re: What should we do with apacheds-server-tools ?

2010-06-04 Thread Felix Knecht
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 06/04/10 17:25, Emmanuel Lecharny wrote: On 6/4/10 5:17 PM, Felix Knecht wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 It all depends on which command we are talking about here. On any linux box, you have many tools like ldapadd or