Re: Specs: Individual specs also in J2EE...

2005-11-10 Thread Dain Sundstrom
+1 This really helps when people want to use the code standalone But we must provide a rollup jar so our users don't have to hunt down 10 spec jars. -dain On Nov 9, 2005, at 11:40 PM, Alan D. Cabrera wrote: I am of the same opinion. Regards, Alan David Jencks wrote, On 11/9/2005 9:08 PM

Re: Specs: Individual specs also in J2EE...

2005-11-09 Thread Alan D. Cabrera
I am of the same opinion. Regards, Alan David Jencks wrote, On 11/9/2005 9:08 PM: I have a REALLY REALLY REALLY strong preference that ALL geronimo modules depend ONLY on the specs they actually use. I would prefer that we don't build the universal spec jar or that we build it after everyt

Re: Specs: Individual specs also in J2EE...

2005-11-09 Thread Brett Porter
>From a Maven point of view with transitive dependencies, this is imperative. The universal jar should just be a distribution convenience (if it is built at all). - Brett On 11/10/05, David Jencks <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I have a REALLY REALLY REALLY strong preference that ALL geronimo > mod

Re: Specs: Individual specs also in J2EE...

2005-11-09 Thread David Jencks
I have a REALLY REALLY REALLY strong preference that ALL geronimo modules depend ONLY on the specs they actually use. I would prefer that we don't build the universal spec jar or that we build it after everything else is built and all the configurations are built. I really prefer to know what

Re: Specs: Individual specs also in J2EE...

2005-11-09 Thread Matt Hogstrom
I think referring to one is simpler. That way exceptions will stand out. I'm not sure I see a downside. Aaron Mulder wrote: So I notice that the JSR-88 code is in geronimo-spec-j2ee-deployment-1.1-rc4.jar and also geronimo-spec-j2ee-1.4-rc4.jar. I guess "spec-j2ee" is a rollup of all (or mos

Specs: Individual specs also in J2EE...

2005-11-09 Thread Aaron Mulder
So I notice that the JSR-88 code is in geronimo-spec-j2ee-deployment-1.1-rc4.jar and also geronimo-spec-j2ee-1.4-rc4.jar. I guess "spec-j2ee" is a rollup of all (or most of) the others? Is there a preference for whether other modules should depend on the individual spec modules or the overall "sp