Re: [DISCUSS] Incremental and cadence predictable release activity for HIVE

2023-03-23 Thread Denys Kuzmenko
Sorry for being late to the party. I think what Kirti proposes would be good for the project and end-users. As mentioned, we could start with 2-3 releases per year, and once we improve on the process and automation (CI/CD) we could reevaluate.

Re: [DISCUSS] Incremental and cadence predictable release activity for HIVE

2023-03-23 Thread Kirti Ruge
Thanks Ayush, Thanks Stamatis for your valuable inputs. Let us a give a try to get at least 2 releases/year so that we can evaluate further on strategy plan of release activity. I see another mail thread for interested devs who can volunteer as Release Managers for next subsequent releases

Re: [DISCUSS] Incremental and cadence predictable release activity for HIVE

2023-03-13 Thread Stamatis Zampetakis
Hello, I am not sure what a branch cut actually refers to. As I mentioned in the past I am not in favor of maintaining multiple release branches; the cost is high and the number of volunteers is simply not enough. I am willing to reconsider if things change in the near future. Apart from that,

Re: [DISCUSS] Incremental and cadence predictable release activity for HIVE

2023-03-12 Thread Ayush Saxena
Hi Kirti, Thanx for the initiative. This sounds very interesting, but I doubt if it is that easy to incorporate. Sharing my thoughts: - Regarding "Unpredictable" : I don't think we are like doing very unpredictable releases. It should be a formal mail, like Release x.y.z and then the RM

[DISCUSS] Incremental and cadence predictable release activity for HIVE

2023-03-12 Thread Kirti Ruge
Hello HIVE Dev, I would like to discuss/propose incremental and cadence predictable process for HIVE releases. https://hive.apache.org/general/downloads/ Currently, our releases have a very random span in between, and those have sometimes caused problems like- 1. All downstream and end