> Personally I'd love to see us stop maintaining the duplicated code of
> the underlying implementations. I wouldn't mind losing the legacy
> syntax as well - I'll take a clear, verbose API over a less-clear,
> concise one any day. But I'm probably a minority there.
+1, agree with Jason here,
Should we deprecate classic faceting in 9x now?
> It's worth investigating deprecating the stats component also. I believe
JSON facets covers that functionality as well. It will be painful for users
though to switch over unfortunately.
+1, lets deprecate stats component too.
On Thu, Jan 28,
It's worth investigating deprecating the stats component also. I believe
JSON facets covers that functionality as well. It will be painful for users
though to switch over unfortunately.
Joel Bernstein
http://joelsolr.blogspot.com/
On Fri, Jan 22, 2021 at 1:14 PM Jason Gerlowski
wrote:
>
Personally I'd love to see us stop maintaining the duplicated code of
the underlying implementations. I wouldn't mind losing the legacy
syntax as well - I'll take a clear, verbose API over a less-clear,
concise one any day. But I'm probably a minority there.
Either way I agree with Michael when
I agree it would make long-term sense to consolidate the backend
implementation. I think leaving the "classic" user-facing facet API (with
JSON Facet module as a backend) would be a good idea. Either way, I think a
first step would be checking for parity between existing backend
implementations --
Do these two options conflate concerns of input format vs. actual
algorithm? That was always my disappointment.
I feel like the java apis are off here at the lower level, and it
hurts the user.
I don't talk about the input format from the user, instead I mean the
execution of the faceting query.
There's a JIRA issue about this from 5 years ago:
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SOLR-7296
I don't recall seeing any resistance to the idea of having the JSON
Faceting module act as a back-end to the front-end (API surface) of Solr's
common/classic/original/whatever faceting API. I don't
Hi all,
Sorry to spam the list. I am querying the list in such quick succession
because of a realization I came to while on Twitter. Is it time to
deprecate the Legacy Facet API?
I understood in the past that they behaved slightly differently. Now, I'm
wondering if it makes sense to keep the
